Al Jazeera Journalism Review

A word cloud generated from posts by social media platform users in Europe reflects the impact of politics on the narrative surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic in the region. [Graphic by Social Media Insights Lab]

Coronavirus conversations - revealing a world of difference 

Who or what are driving news and discussions about COVID-19 on social media? It all depends on where you are in the world.


Journalists can learn a great deal - and source great news stories - by following what is being said on social media. This is particularly true when it comes to understanding how people around the world are responding to the COVID-19 pandemic. 

An analysis by the Social Media Insights Lab at the University of South Carolina shows significant differences between attitudes in the Arab world compared to Europe and the United States. 

Lab researchers reviewed more than 870 million social media posts made between January 1, 2020, and July 31, 2021. Much of the sample was made up of posts on Twitter (69 percent). It also included comments on news stories as well as posts on various forums and blogs. 

The analysis found: 

• There is less stated resistance to vaccines in 21 Arab-speaking countries than in Europe and the US. 

• Earlier in the pandemic, comments in the Arab world focused more on the economic and social consequences of the coronavirus while in the US and Europe, comments were more sensationalised and focused on people like former President Donald Trump and entertainers like Pink and Selena Gomez.

• News organisations have the biggest impact on social media conversations in the Arab world while politicians and other public figures have a more significant impact in the US and Europe. 

“We have been following these coronavirus conversations since early 2020,” says Kaitlyn Park, Insights Lab manager. “COVID-19 has been a hot topic on social media and while there are many similarities worldwide, there also are major differences when you look at specific topics, such as vaccines.” 

Westerners are more influenced by ‘personalities’

The Insights Lab found hesitancy toward the vaccines worldwide, but the degree of hesitancy varies by region with less resistance in Arabic-speaking countries. 

The Insights Lab’s powerful Brandwatch Consumer Research software used artificial intelligence to better understand the massive data set. It looked specifically at negative sentiment, which can mean different things, including critical comments about the vaccines, about public figures talking about the vaccines or about the coronavirus itself.     

Among almost 30 million posts in the Arab world, 28 percent were negative. By comparison in Europe, 38 percent of more than 354 million posts were negative. In the US, 31 percent of more than 420 million posts were negative. 


“When you look at the big picture, the differences in sentiment are significant,” says Park. “In the Arab world, comments tend to be more factual, while in the US and Europe, comments include more opinion.” 

In the US, for example, the social media posts that had the most impact came from politicians like President Biden and US Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell as well as media figures like PBS Correspondent Yamiche Alcindor and Fox Business host Lou Dobbs.


In Europe, the posts that had the most impact came from writer Samina Chaudhry tweeting about the death of her husband from COVID-19; the World Health Organization; and media figures like Piers Morgan tweeting about Boris Johnson's policies relating to COVID-19 in the UK.


In Arabic countries, the posts with the most impact were made by Mohamed Al Karbooli (Iraqi MP) tweeting about the rising numbers of COVID-19 cases among Iraqi prison inmates; the Saudi Al Hilal Football Club tweeting about the vaccination process for its players; and a video posted by Al Jazeera Arabic’s Twitter account about clearing the Kaaba site in Mecca for sterilisation during the pandemic. 


Official sources and scientists more influential in Arab world

A good way to get an overview of social media conversations is to look at the word clouds generated by the lab’s software. For the US, common words in general discussions about the coronavirus include “Trump” and “President”. In the Arab world, people are more likely to rely on official sources and scientific opinion.


Former US President Donald Trump is a divisive figure and, during his presidency, he wielded a powerful presence on social media. His frequent posts about COVID-19, which often were critical of public health officials and downplayed the severity of the virus, had a major impact. For example in June, 2020, Trump posted this Tweet:


The rise in COVID-19 cases and deaths in the months following this Tweet by the former US President was partly blamed on his refusal to take the disease seriously.


On the day Trump made this comment, the United States was averaging around 41,000 new COVID cases and 2,466 deaths per day, according to a database maintained by The New York Times. However, as the year progressed, the number of coronavirus cases and deaths grew significantly, peaking seven months later at more than 300,000 new cases per day and more than 4,000 deaths per day. The increases have been blamed, in part, on the President’s reluctance to take the disease as seriously as he might have.

The word cloud for Europe also reflects the impact of politics. Trump and British Prime Minister Boris Johnson are frequently mentioned.


By contrast, the word cloud for the Arab world, which includes posts in Arabic and English, is less personality-driven and more focused on the impact of the disease and the responsibilities of the government, as shown by words like “Ministry”, “Procedures” and “Precautions”. 


“Posts in the Arab world were more neutral and commenters were more interested in the long-term impacts of COVID-19,” says Park. “Conversations seem to be less politicised than in the West, where many challenged the recommendations of health officials and scientific authorities.”

Measuring ‘impact’

Topic wheels are another way of gauging these conversations and the wheels tell a similar story. Trump is frequently mentioned in the US. In Arab countries, health and cases are more frequently mentioned. 


The lab’s Brandwatch software is able to evaluate who has the greatest impact on these online discussions.  Researchers looked at this from two perspectives.

·       Those with the largest followings on social media.

·       Those with the greatest impact, as measured by the Brandwatch software.   

Among the accounts with the largest number of followers in the Arab world, news organisations like Al Arabiya and Al Jazeera top the list of those driving coronavirus conversations. 


In the US, while media companies like The New York Times and The Washington Post had a big impact. So, too, did entertainers such as Selena Gomez and Pink. 


Europe was somewhere in between. Most of the European top 10 is composed of news organisations. However, the list also includes two football clubs - Liverpool and Barcelona.


The Brandwatch software also evaluates which posts have the most impact or engagement, which typically is defined as being shared, liked or commented upon. These influencers may not have the largest number of followers, but they do have the greatest impact on social media conversations.

Top influencers in the Arab world included several news organisations as well as individuals such as Mohammed al-Karbouli, a prominent Iraqi MP. 


In the US, the list of high-impact influencers included politicians, political commentators and a few journalists. Until he left office and was banned from Twitter, Donald Trump also was a significant influencer. 


In Europe, the list of high-impact influencers includes a mix of writers, news organisations, politicians and individual personalities. 


These influencer lists substantiate and help to explain the more politicised nature of American and European conversations when compared to the Arab world. 

Knowledge is power

It is often said that knowledge is power and, in commerce, the use of social media analytics is becoming increasingly popular because of the information they can provide. Businesses use these techniques to better understand their customers, including what they are saying and who is influencing them. 

In the same way, journalists can use social media analytics to understand what the general public is saying as well as to better understand their sources of information and, in some cases, sources of misinformation. 

There are several ways to analyse social media and they range from simple and cheap to complicated and more expensive. Social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook offer free tools to better understand the performance of a post. These tools are useful in helping newsrooms strategize and plan content based on what gets the attention of the audience as well as what engages them through comments, likes and sharing. 

For journalists, the paid service Chartbeat can be found in newsrooms all over the world. Chartbeat is useful in understanding which stories are getting attention, who is reading a site, how long they spend there, where they came from and sometimes where they go after they leave. Chartbeat can help drive a social media strategy and establish priorities for coverage. 

There also are paid services like Hootsuite and Talkwalker. They offer some of the same insights as the free, in-app tools, as well as word clouds and data on trending topics. These programmes typically provide a snapshot of what is happening at a particular time but do not offer historical context. 

Using artificial intelligence

There are also more powerful - and more expensive - programmes like Brandwatch Consumer Research, NetBaseQuid and Sprnklr. They go beyond single platforms to include news websites, forums and blogs. By working across platforms, they provide a fuller picture of what is being said about a given topic. The obvious challenge is making sense of all the data these programmes are collecting and analysing. That’s where artificial intelligence (AI) comes in. 

AI programmes can gauge the emotional tone of conversations by using auto-sentiment technology, which is useful for identifying patterns within large sets of social media data. AI has its limitations, however. For example, it generally cannot detect sarcasm and nuance. That’s where the human element comes in. A human analyst must constantly analyse and revise a search, training the AI what to look for. 

“The key point is not the technology, which certainly is impressive, but rather how we use the technology,” says Tom Reichert, Dean of the University of South Carolina College of Information and Communications. “For journalists as with commerce, social media analytics can provide context and understanding to the stories we cover.” 

While there is much to be learned from social media, it is worth noting that most people are not making comments on Twitter. Analytics provide insights, but not necessarily the entire story. There still is an important role for journalists. 


*The Arab countries in this analysis include Algeria, Bahrain, the Comoros Islands, Djibouti, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Libya, Morocco, Mauritania, Oman, Palestine, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, Tunisia, the United Arab Emirates and Yemen.



More Articles

Deploying news teams to dangerous places - what media organisations need to know

Reporting from the heat of battle or covering the tragedy and desolation of a humanitarian disaster can be perilous, but the risks are less if media professionals are prepared for the task. 

Aidan White Published on: 27 Jan, 2022
Can you spot the fake news? Steering clear of conspiracies in science journalism

The world is full of fake news, nowhere more so than when it comes to scientific issues, so science journalists must develop a keen sense of scepticism. We look at why it’s so important to keep a clear head and search out the facts.

Ali Shehab Published on: 12 Jan, 2022
How to do science journalism - and do it right

THE LONG READ: With a new variant of COVID-19 sweeping the world, putting healthcare systems under strain, good science journalism has never been more important. This is our guide to how to report responsibly, accurately and ethically on scientific issues.

Ali Shehab Published on: 9 Jan, 2022
‘Kill the rented journalists’ - the reality of life for local journalists and fixers left behind in Afghanistan

THE LONG READ: The recent takeover of Afghanistan by the Taliban shines a light on the often exploitative relationship between Western foreign correspondents and the Afghan ‘fixers’ they leave behind.

Sayed Jalal
Sayed Jalal Shajjan Published on: 4 Jan, 2022
Investigative journalism in the digital age

Data-driven journalism is an increasingly integral part of investigative reporting. We look at the ways to put it to best use. 

Malak Khalil Published on: 21 Dec, 2021
How to avoid stirring up hate through your reporting

In part two of our series on how the media can propagate hate speech, we look at ways that journalists can ensure their work is balanced and objective, to avoid this.

Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 16 Dec, 2021
The problem with hate speech: How the media has fuelled its rise

Across the world, media organisations are guilty of misrepresenting the stories of refugees and other vulnerable minorities, stirring up panic and outrage within their respective countries. We look at some examples.

Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 9 Dec, 2021
Why language matters when we report refugee stories

As tragedy strikes in the English Channel and the refugee crisis mounts at the Polish border, we examine why it is so important to use the correct language when covering refugee stories. Part two of our series.

Kareem Shaheen Published on: 25 Nov, 2021
How to cover refugee stories ethically 

As Poland grapples with a migrant and refugee crisis at its borders, we examine best practice for journalists covering refugee stories. Part one of our series.

Kareem Shaheen Published on: 23 Nov, 2021
Verifying video - how to spot the fakes

It's often seemingly impossible to tell what's fake and what's not on social media. We look at the tools journalists can use to verify video sourced online. How can you spot fake videos from hate groups to terrorist organisations on social media? Is it even possible? What tools can you use to verify the authenticity of these videos?

Mahmoud Ghazayel Published on: 15 Nov, 2021
Is slow journalism the cure for fast-food thinking?

ANALYSIS: Journalists require time and space to provide the depth readers need to make sense of an endless stream of instant news.

Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 10 Nov, 2021
Digital Sherlocks: Open-source investigation and news verification during wartime

THE LONG READ: From proving the existence of a seven-year-old girl in Syria to fact-checking locations of aerial bombings, how do you verify ‘open-source’ information in a war zone?

Christiaan Triebert
Christiaan Triebert Published on: 1 Nov, 2021
How to use social media for newsgathering

Social media platforms are too easily dismissed as ‘not serious’ when it comes to newsgathering. But you can use them as you would the news wires - here’s how.

Majd Khalifeh Published on: 28 Sep, 2021
Leaks - a badly behaved guest in the newsroom

The recent 'Facebook Files' - revelations about the inner workings of the tech giant published by the Wall Street Journal - were based on leaked internal information. But while leaks can be a valuable source of information for journalists, they can also be used to manipulate them.

A picture of the author, Ayuob Errimi.
Ayoub Errimi Published on: 21 Sep, 2021
Have you been hacked? - What Pegasus spyware revelations mean for journalists

How to protect yourself following the news that sophisticated spyware has been used to hack the smartphones of journalists, activists and politicians around the world.

Mei Shigenobu
Mei Shigenobu Published on: 19 Sep, 2021
Protecting Newsgathering through the Sustainable Use of Social Media

All journalists old enough to have worked in a pre-social media world, will have had that moment.

Sam Dubberley Published on: 16 Aug, 2021
War Stories on Social Media: Audience Engagement and Ethical Hiring Practices

The horrific scenes became more accessible than ever before.

Sakhr Al-Makhadhi Published on: 23 Jun, 2021
Antixenophobic media: An impossible goal?

Current media coverage in Jordan and Lebanon tend to demonize refugees and migrants. How can newsrooms prevent this sort of generalization and demonization?

A picture of the author, Muhammad Shamma
Muhammad Shamma Published on: 2 Jun, 2021
How to bring more balance to western media coverage of Israel and Palestine

How can journalists accurately cover Palestine without becoming unbalanced or biased? Here are some concrete tools and techniques for reporters to keep in mind.

A picture of the author, Megan O'Toole
Megan O'Toole Published on: 17 May, 2021
Arab Investigative Journalism: Good Intentions Are Not Enough

What should young journalists in the Middle East know about investigative journalism before they jump into the field? Veteran reporter Yasser al-Zayyat clarifies misconceptions and gives advice in his latest piece.

A picture of the author, Yasser.
Yasser al-Zayyat Published on: 12 Apr, 2021
Beyond objectivity: The rise of reformist news

The core mission of the news industry is telling viewers the day's events. But another core mission of journalism is to make the world a better place, which means going beyond the facts to change what’s wrong and defend what’s right. Those two missions are in conflict today.

A picture of the author, Mark Lee Hunter.
Mark Lee Hunter Published on: 23 Mar, 2021