Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Governor General of Canada Mary Simon attends the Indigenous Reflection Ceremony, as Canada celebrates its 155th anniversary since 1867, at LeBreton Flats Park in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, July 1, 2022. REUTERS/Blair Gable

Should artists have a say about who gets to review their work?

Sometimes journalists and media organisations need to consider who should cover certain issues in order to improve reporting - as coverage of Indigenous affairs in Canada shows

 

 

When Yolanda Bonnell (Ojibwe-South Asian) and Cole Alvis (Métis), theatre artists with North American Indigenous heritage, came together for their first production, bug, written and performed by Bonnell in Canada in 2020, they made an unusual request. 

They asked all Canadian media organisations to hire only BIPOC (a term used in North America to refer to Black, Indigenous and People of Colour) theatre critics to review their play. 

While this request was unusual, it wasn’t unprecedented. Similar requests had been made in the past, some barring theatre critics from attending the opening night, with others refusing all reviewers completely. In 2018, Kim Senklip Harvey, a playwright and Bonnell’s collaborator, requested “love letters” from Indigenous women instead of inviting theatre critics to her play. 

Making a request, however, doesn’t mean that it will always be respected. 

A 60-minute solo show, bug is a multi-generational story of women of an Indigenous family navigating addiction and intergenerational trauma. In the play, their addictions manifest as Manidoons, which is the Ojibwe word for bug, a creature that burrows beneath the skin. 

bug was the first production by Bonnell and Alvis, as part of their artist collective, the Manidoons Collective. The play weaves together stories of these different women using movement, poetry and prose. The play has been successful, receiving four nominations for the prestigious Dora Mavor Moore Award, and its published version has been nominated for the Governor General’s Award for English-language drama. 

Indigenous Canada 4
Yolanda Bonnell performs in the production of bug, a play about intergenerational addiction and trauma in an Indigenous family in Canada, which requested reviews by Indigenous theatre critics only in 2020. The request was met by a storm of protest from predominantly white, male theatre critics. Set and costume design by Jay Havens; lighting design by Michel Charbonneau [Gilad Cohen and Dahlia Katz]

In an interview, Bonnell spoke about how she felt the need to protect the lived experiences of the Indigenous women whose stories she was recalling. 

“To have a white person come in and say ‘it didn’t feel grounded to me.’ It just didn’t feel good,” she said. It wasn’t just the stories of these women that Bonnell was protecting. Part of Manidoons Collective’s agenda is to move away from a Eurocentric approach to storytelling and performance. 

The play was designed as an artistic ceremony - a ceremony that brought together storytellers and witnesses (audiences). Performed in a circle, with healers present in the room, the witnesses were informed that they were welcome to enter or leave the space as they liked. 

Both Bonnell and Alvis are particularly critical of the Eurocentric framework of story-telling, interpreted as universal standards of excellence. The problem with Canadian theatre reviewers as they identify is that most of them approach culturally specific performances through this Eurocentric lens. bug, with its intergenerational story and no central character, deliberately moves away from this Eurocentric lens. Movement plays an important role in storytelling. “It is like the body is saying something the voice cannot,” said Bonnell. However, having this nuanced, subtle cultural expression referred to as “interpretive dance”, as it was in one review by a white theatre critic, was problematic according to Bonnell. For Bonnell it is a problem when reviewers who have no experience or cultural competency about Indigenous theatre write about an Indigenous play. 

Both Bonnell and Cole say that they see art criticism as being dominated by white male reviewers who are intrinsically connected to the continued experience of colonialism in Canada, as well as the “under-reporting and misrepresentation of the #LandBack movement in the (Canadian and American) media”. Land Back is an Indigenous-led movement in North America that seeks to get Indigenous lands back in Indigenous hands. 

Indigenous Canada 5
Yolanda Bonnell performs in White Girls in Mocassins, a play which also requested Indigenous theatre critics only in 2022 - two years after bug. This time, there was no protest - media organisations happily complied. Set design by Trevor Schwellnus, video design by Trevor Schwellnus & Rihkee Strapp, costume design by Rachel Forbes , lighting design by Echo Zhou [Jeremy Mimnagh & Dahlia Katz]

There is a long and problematic history of the depiction of Indigenous peoples in Canadian and American media, from Hollywood movies that created narratives of “uncivilised savages”, to more recent news reports that perpetuate stereotypes of Indigenous peoples being “drunken” and “child-like” and notions of culture and language dying out, directly connected to 19th Century “moribundity”. It is this colonial worldview from  the Canadian media that Bonnell and Alvis also see reflected in art criticism. 

“We had this one review for bug that was really weird and problematic,” says Bonnell. “There was a comment made about how it needs to be shown on reservations and how it should be shortened. It was very insensitive.” 

Both Bonnell and Alvis identify how this is not something that is endured just by Indigenous artists but also artists from other communities and identities. Bonnell speaks about how just a little before they decided to limit the review of their play to BIPOC reviewers there were a series of transphobic and racist reviews that came from a particular theatre reviewer towards Next Stage Festival - reviews that were incredibly harmful to a particular Asian community. In this review, the white reviewer expressed frustration about why a word in the title hadn’t been translated and wondered if the show was only meant for a Philippine audience, or a “general” audience. 

A few months ago, as Disney released its movie, Turning Red, an animated film about a 13-year old Chinese-Canadian student, a review of the movie, written by Sean O’Connell, the Managing Director of CinemaBlend, for the website, was criticised as being “racist and sexist”. The review claimed that the film’s appeal was limited because of its focus on the Asian community of Toronto. The review has since been pulled offline.

O’Connell’s argument is firmly rooted in a Eurocentric worldview in which everything that is white and European is global, universal and “general”, while everything that is from another community, or culture, is specific and “limiting”. It is the same worldview that is also criticised across universities in Europe and North America, in which humanities departments are dominated by European philosophies, while non-European philosophies are reduced to area-specific studies. 

Indigenous Canada 1
OTTAWA, CANADA - Awema Tendesi takes part in a National Indigenous Peoples Day event at Madahoki Farm in Ottawa, Ontario, on June 21, 2022 [Lars Hagberg/Reuters]

Explaining why it was important for them to have a BIPOC reviewer review their play, Bonnell says: “There is an understanding between BIPOC folks of standing outside, of being othered, of having white gaze on their work. There are often similar common experiences of having to deal with insensitivity and racism. So those reviewers are going to come at it from a different perspective that perhaps a white person would have not been able to.”

Given the success of the play and the attention it was receiving from different theatre organisations, Bonnell and Alvis wanted to use this opportunity to turn the gaze of the Canadian media on its own and address a pressing issue - that of representation. 

Lack of diversity remains an ongoing issue in Canadian media organisations with most Canadian newsrooms overwhelmingly white. “It was a request from us (for Canadian media) to do better, be better,” says Alvis. 

But that is not how the request was interpreted by many reviewers - it was called racist and exclusionary. There were angry op-eds. A prominent theatre critic in one article argued: “It’s a basic principle of mainstream cultural journalism that artists should not pick which critics review them. But should artists be allowed to choose which colour of critic reviews them?” 

“We called this Peak Whiteness,” says Alvis. “To take this request, this agitation, this advocacy around BIPOC representation in the media and make it about ‘me’ - about being denied access. The headline became about white people being denied access as opposed to systemic change.” 

Alvis understands this “white fragility” within the broader context of what is generally happening to arts sections across media organisations, where budgets are being cut, and more and more reviewers and arts critics are losing work. “There was a lot of instability and uncertainty within the prominently white male community of reviewers and then here we come with this audacious request,” she says. 

Despite the push back, a few media organisations respected the request and hired Indigenous critics to review the play. A couple of years later, as Manidoons Collective was preparing to unveil its second production, White Girls in Moccasins, it made a similar request for only BIPOC critics reviewing their play. “Still asking to do better,” says Alvis.

Indigenous Canada 3
WINIPEG, CANADA - Shoes sit on the steps of the provincial legislature, placed there following the discovery of the remains of hundreds of children at former Indigenous residential schools, on Canada Day, July 1, 2021 [Shannon VanRaes/Reuters]

Between February 2020 and March 2022, between the first request and the second, a lot had changed.

There had been major protests all across the world, including Canada, following the brutal murder of George Floyd. Many institutions, at least publicly, became reflective about Black representation and diversity within their organisations. The conversation, it seemed, had changed. 

In Canada, the Black Lives Matter protests were followed by further reckoning of Canada’s historical treatment of Indigenous communities. In May of 2021, in news that shook society, the remains of 215 Indigenous children were found at a former residential school. Many more graves have been found since.

The reaction the second time to the request for BIPOC critics was quite different. “The media just adjusted. They hired differently and it was a non-issue,” says Alvis. The loud and angry voices that had accused them of being exclusionary and discriminatory were silent this time. 

“Sometimes it takes a racial reckoning like the one that occurred in June 2020 to see proactive requests like ours to be put in motion,” says Alvis. 

Of course, racism and representation in Canadian media have not been solved in these two years. Lack of diversity in newsrooms is still a major problem. However, there are journalists, artists and organisations like Manidoons Collective, pushing back for better representation, not just for Indigenous communities but also for other ethnicities, races and genders. The situation today is far from ideal, but there seems to be a greater acceptability of this important conversation. 

 

More Articles

Press Freedom in Multiple EU Countries on the "Verge of Collapse" Reports Show

The European Civil Liberties Union's Media Freedom 2024 report highlights a decline in press freedom and media pluralism in several EU countries, with calls for comprehensive reforms. The report also points out biases in Western media coverage of the Israeli offensive in Gaza, including restrictions on certain terms and unbalanced reporting. It raises concerns about diminishing media pluralism, journalist prosecution and surveillance, and declining public trust in the media.

A picture of the Al Jazeera Media Institute's logo, on a white background.
Al Jazeera Journalism Review Published on: 13 May, 2024
Amid Increasing Pressure, Journalists in India Practice More Self-Censorship

In a country where nearly 970 million people are participating in a crucial general election, the state of journalism in India is under scrutiny. Journalists face harassment, self-censorship, and attacks, especially under the current Modi-led government. Mainstream media also practices self-censorship to avoid repercussions. The future of journalism in India appears uncertain, but hope lies in the resilience of independent media outlets.

Hanan Zaffa
Hanan Zaffar, Jyoti Thakur Published on: 25 Apr, 2024
Journalism in chains in Cameroon

Investigative journalists in Cameroon sometimes use treacherous means to navigate the numerous challenges that hamper the practice of their profession: the absence of the Freedom of Information Act, the criminalisation of press offenses, and the scare of the overly-broad anti-terrorism law.

Nalova Akua
Nalova Akua Published on: 12 Apr, 2024
The Perils of Journalism and the Rise of Citizen Media in Southeast Asia

Southeast Asia's media landscape is grim, with low rankings for internet and press freedom across the region. While citizen journalism has risen to fill the gaps, journalists - both professional and citizen - face significant risks due to government crackdowns and the collusion between tech companies and authorities to enable censorship and surveillance.

AJR Contributor Published on: 6 Apr, 2024
Silenced Voices: The Battle for Free Expression Amid India’s Farmer’s Protest

The Indian government's use of legal mechanisms to suppress dissenting voices and news reports raises questions about transparency and freedom of expression. The challenges faced by independent media in India indicate a broader narrative of controlling the narrative and stifling dissenting voices.

Suvrat Arora
Suvrat Arora Published on: 17 Mar, 2024
Targeting Truth: Assault on Female Journalists in Gaza

For female journalists in Palestine, celebrating international women's rights this year must take a backseat, as they continue facing the harsh realities of conflict. March 8th will carry little celebration for them, as they grapple with the severe risks of violence, mass displacement, and the vulnerability of abandonment amidst an ongoing humanitarian crisis. Their focus remains on bearing witness to human suffering and sharing stories of resilience from the frontlines, despite the personal dangers involved in their work.

Fatima Bashir
Fatima Bashir Published on: 14 Mar, 2024
A Woman's Journey Reporting on Pakistan's Thrilling Cholistan Desert Jeep Rally

A Woman's Voice in the Desert: Navigating the Spotlight

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 8 Mar, 2024
Breaking Barriers: The Rise of Citizen Journalists in India's Fight for Media Inclusion

Grassroots journalists from marginalized communities in India, including Dalits and Muslims, are challenging mainstream media narratives and bringing attention to underreported issues through digital outlets like The Mooknayak.

Hanan Zaffa
Hanan Zaffar, Jyoti Thakur Published on: 3 Mar, 2024
Silenced Voices and Digital Resilience: The Case of Quds Network

Unrecognized journalists in conflict zones face serious risks to their safety and lack of support. The Quds Network, a Palestinian media outlet, has been targeted and censored, but they continue to report on the ground in Gaza. Recognition and support for independent journalists are crucial.

Yousef Abu Watfe يوسف أبو وطفة
Yousef Abu Watfeh Published on: 21 Feb, 2024
Artificial Intelligence's Potentials and Challenges in the African Media Landscape

How has the proliferation of Artificial Intelligence impacted newsroom operations, job security and regulation in the African media landscape? And how are journalists in Africa adapting to these changes?

Derick M
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 18 Feb, 2024
Media Blackout on Imran Khan and PTI: Analysing Pakistan's Election Press Restrictions

Implications and response to media censorship and the deliberate absence of coverage for the popular former Prime Minister, Imran Khan, and his party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), in the media during the 2024 elections in Pakistan.

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 14 Feb, 2024
Digital Battlegrounds: The New Broadcasting Bill and Independent Journalism in India

New legislation in India threatens the freedom of independent journalism. The draft Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill, 2023 grants the government extensive power to regulate and censor content, potentially suppressing news critical of government policies.

Safina
Safina Nabi Published on: 11 Feb, 2024
Pegasus Spyware: A Grave Threat to Journalists in Southeast Asia

The widespread deployment of spyware such as Pegasus in Southeast Asia, used by governments to target opposition leaders, activists, and journalists, presents significant challenges in countering digital surveillance. This is due to its clandestine operations and the political intricacies involved. The situation underscores the urgent need for international cooperation and heightened public awareness to address these human rights infringements.

AJR Contributor Published on: 5 Feb, 2024
Media Monopoly in Brazil: How Dominant Media Houses Control the Narrative and Stifle Criticism of Israel

An in-depth analysis exploring the concentration of media ownership in Brazil by large companies, and how this shapes public and political narratives, particularly by suppressing criticism of Israel.

Al Jazeera Logo
Rita Freire & Ahmad Al Zobi Published on: 1 Feb, 2024
Cameroonian Media Martyrs: The Intersection of Journalism and Activism

Experts and journalists in Cameroon disagree on the relationship between journalism and activism: some say journalism is activism; others think they are worlds apart, while another category says a “very thin” line separate both

Nalova Akua
Nalova Akua Published on: 28 Jan, 2024
Silent Suffering: The Impact of Sexual Harassment on African Newsrooms

Sexual harassment within newsrooms and the broader journalistic ecosystem is affecting the quality and integrity of journalistic work, ultimately impacting the organisation’s integrity and revenue.

Derick M
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 23 Jan, 2024
In the Courtroom and Beyond: Covering South Africa's Historic Legal Case Against Israel at The Hague

As South Africa takes on Israel at the International Court of Justice, the role of journalists in covering this landmark case becomes more crucial than ever. Their insights and reporting bring the complexities of international law to a global audience.

Hala Ahed
Hala Ahed Published on: 12 Jan, 2024
Embedded journalism: Striking a balance between access and impartiality in war zones

The ethical implications of embedded journalism, particularly in the Israeli invasion of Gaza, raise concerns about the compromise of balance and independence in war coverage.

Abeer Ayyoub
Abeer Ayyoub Published on: 19 Dec, 2023
Does international law protect Palestinian journalists?

International humanitarian law provides some protection for journalists, but there is a lack of effective measures against crimes committed against them. The Israeli occupation's impunity and lack of accountability for war crimes against civilians, including journalists, is a crisis for international law.

Badia Al-Sawan
Badia Al-Sawan Published on: 12 Dec, 2023
Through a Mexican lens: Navigating the intricacies of reporting in Palestine

A Mexican journalist's journey through the complexities of reporting on Palestine and gives tips on how to manage this kind of coverage.

Témoris Grecko
Témoris Grecko Published on: 10 Dec, 2023
This Indian fact-checking newsroom is at the forefront of the fight against disinformation on the war in Gaza

In the digital battleground of Gaza's war, a surge of disinformation, primarily from Indian Hindu nationalists, paints Palestinians negatively, fueled by Islamophobia and pro-Israeli sentiments; yet, Alt News emerges as a crucial counterforce, diligently fact-checking and debunking these misleading narratives, even in Arabic, amidst a sea of manipulated social media content.

Meer Faisal
Meer Faisal Published on: 5 Dec, 2023
Echos of Israeli Discourse in Latin American Media on Gaza

Heavily influenced by US and Israeli diplomatic efforts, Latin American media predominantly aligns with and amplifies the Israeli perspective. This divergence between political actions and media representation highlights the complex dynamics shaping Latin American coverage of the Gaza conflict.

Rita Freire Published on: 23 Nov, 2023
Why have opposition parties in India issued a boycott of 14 TV presenters?

Media workers in India argue that boycotts of individual journalists are not the answer to pro-Government reporting bias

Saurabh Sharma
Saurabh Sharma Published on: 23 Oct, 2023
Punishing the popular: the suspension of a youth magazine in Vietnam

Media outlets not directly affiliated with the state are not allowed to produce ‘news’ in Vietnam - but the loose definition of ‘news’ means many fall foul of the rules

headshot
AJR Correspondent Published on: 19 Oct, 2023