Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Outside image
The entrance to the village of Prem Ganj, which was boycotted for six months following an outbreak of HIV. Misinformation in the media contributed to the village being shunned by its neighbours [Saurabh Sharma]

How misinformation in the media wreaked havoc on an Indian village

When journalists - and social media ‘influencers’ claiming to be journalists - aimed for sensationalism and did not check their facts about the outbreak of the HIV virus in an Indian village, the results were devastating

 

In the winter of 2018, 58 people were found to have been infected with the deadly Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) in Bangarmau town, Uttar Pradesh. The town is 326 miles from the national capital of New Delhi.

The village of Prem Ganj was the most affected area and a “quack” - unlicensed doctor - was blamed for the outbreak. It was reported that he may have used the same syringe to administer medicines to multiple people who went to him for treatment.

Prem Ganj has a population of around 5,000 people - most from the dalit caste which faces routine discrimination from other sectors of society - and the outbreak of HIV created panic, fear and also a social boycott of the village by outsiders for a period of time. The residents of Prem Ganj blame misleading news, Youtubers and then Tiktokers for spreading false and incomplete news about the village.

Councillor Sunil Kumar of the Prem Ganj ward who is now running for his second term explains that there is still a great deal of stigma associated with HIV. “People only understand that HIV is AIDS, they do not understand the difference and believe that it is only caused by unprotected sex. This was the point the media should have made clear - that HIV can also be caused by the use of the same syringe,” he says.

“When the news of a large number of people infected with HIV broke in the local media people started thinking that something illegal was being practised in the village and also that the infection was brought by the men who hailed from the ward but were working in other cities which also resulted in rumour mongering.”

Kumar says that the instant reaction of people in the neighbouring villages, where no cases were found, was to cease all contact with the residents of Prem Ganj. For a period of six months, few people from outside would set foot in the village - including cart pullers, vegetable sellers and fruit sellers.

boycott
Councillor Sunil Kumar talks to Al Jazeera Journalism Review from his home in Prem Ganj, the village boycotted following an outbreak of the AIDS virus [Saurabh Sharma]

A sense of shame

A sense of shame about the incident prevents most of the residents of Prem Ganj from opening up much about the kind of discrimination they faced. They prefer to dismiss it now as a “thing of the past”. 

After digging a bit deeper, however, Kaushal Goyal, a local news reporter who works as a stringer for a couple of regional news channels, says he managed to get some people to open up about their experience of being boycotted. 

Besides being unable to buy fresh fruit and vegetables from the sellers who would normally come to the village, some people said their own relatives refused to see them. The village was cruelly dubbed “AIDS wala Gaon” by outsiders, which roughly translates to “the village with AIDS”.

Goyal believes this would not have happened if reporters had exercised greater caution and sensitivity. He explains: “The fact is that there was a lot of talk around about how HIV must have spread in the area. Everyone who did not belong to the village had his or her own version. Some people were of the view that it happened due to unprotected sex, some said it could have spread because the ward was situated adjacent to a national highway (hinting that brothels operating nearby might be responsible) and a few blamed the quack for using the same syringe on every patient.

“When this happened, every reporter here was in a hurry to get a new angle for reporting this. There was little sense of how sensitive the issue was or what could have been the repercussions. Everyone tried to make the best package for their respective news outlets so in that rat race, we forgot how fragile this issue was,” says the reporter.

The local reporter further adds that had the editors of national and regional news outlets not created “sensational packages” on the subject, the news would not have had such a devastating impact on the lives of the Prem Ganj residents.

Goyal adds that the affected residents were so angry with the media that for a brief period of time they blocked media workers from entering the village. “The affected residents were fed up with the influx of media persons and their sea of illogical questions for finding a new angle to the story.”

A 'sea of illogical questions'

Satendra Gautam, the village headman of Nasirpur Bhikann village, about 5km from Prem Ganj, blames the toxic situation on the media stoking up panic and fear when the news broke. He explains that reporters were asking “illogical” questions which stirred up fear, such as “are there any brothels here?” and “are the women of this village involved in any kind of illegal flesh trade?”

“It looked like everyone was in a hurry to report, which was good. But coming to the village, asking unreasonable and insensitive questions and making illogical comments while standing in front of the camera made no sense. It just created fear amongst us. As a result, the neighbours stopped talking to each other for weeks, and everyone tried to distance himself/herself from the other person. 

“A marriage of a girl in the neighbouring village had to be postponed. People started asking about medical certificates when they came to the village to see a girl or boy for marriage purposes and people started treating others like ‘untouchables’,” he adds.

boycott
Satendra Gautam is headman of neighbouring village Nasirpur Bhikann. He says reporters asking insensitive questions such as 'are the women of this village involved in any kind of illegal flesh trade?' contributed to the stigma suffered by the residents of Prem Ganj [Saurabh Sharma]

The village headman also blames “influencers” on the social media platform, Tiktok (which has since been banned in India), for stirring up rumours and misinformation about the situation. 

Ankita Anand, editor at Unbias The News, the platform for journalists, says in cases like this the reporters should first thoroughly check the guidelines about a particular subject. 

“In the case of the HIV breakout, there is a history of stigma attached to it,” she says. “So the reporter should go through all the guidelines set by media groups and incorporate them into their reporting. Luckily we are in an age where a lot of literature is available both online and offline so reporters should adhere to the guidelines because one never knows what kind of impact his/her report will fetch. It is always recommended to report subjects like these with great sensitivity,” she adds.

'novice' journalists and bloggers

The HIV media guide on ethics and principles for HIV reporting states: “Discrimination, prejudice and stigma are very harmful, and journalists should avoid fuelling them. Journalists should seek informed consent before intruding on anyone’s privacy. They should seek to understand the possible consequences for individuals who participate in their report, and to ensure those individuals are clear about the consequences. Care should be taken to ensure language, cultural norms and traditional practices relating to, for example, inheritance and sex are understood and accurately reported. Journalists should be particularly careful to get scientific and statistical information right. Facts should be painstakingly checked, using credible sources to interpret information, verify facts and make statistics and science accessible and relevant to wide  audiences.”

Rajendra Gautam, a senior dalit journalist based in the north Indian state of Uttar Pradesh, says that many “novice” journalists who have joined the profession recently as well as those on social media such as bloggers and YouTubers are not sufficiently trained in standard reporting practices. 

“Incidents like a mass outbreak of HIV or the spread of COVID happen very rarely and for small-town reporters it becomes a big news event and then there is a race to break the news first. So the reporter gets stuck in this cycle and forgets about the sensitivity of the matter,” says Gautam. “During events like this, it becomes the responsibility of editors, be it regional or national, to tell their reporters how to handle the case.”

“For Youtubers or Tiktokers, there should be guidelines from the platform itself on how to report or not report on a sensitive issue, especially like this case of HIV and when it has happened in a Dalit-dominated village. 

“While reporting events like these, history should be kept in mind because Dalits have faced discrimination in the past and are still facing discrimination. For example, one should not just reveal the identity of HIV patients so people should think about the repercussions before making any conclusion in his/her report,” Gautam concludes. 

 

 

More Articles

Analysis: The media’s coverage of the Pakistan cable car incident

It was a roller coaster ride with news organisations all over the world giving minute-by-minute reports on the daring rescue. How does the media create suspense and is this sort of coverage useful?

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 21 Sep, 2023
How to use data to report on earthquakes

Sifting through data sounds clinical, but journalists can use it to seek out the human element when reporting on natural disasters such as earthquakes

Arwa
Arwa Kooli Published on: 19 Sep, 2023
‘I had no idea how to report on this’ - local journalists tackling climate change stories

Local journalists are key to informing the public about the devastating dangers of climate change but, in India, a lack of knowledge, training and access to expert sources is holding them back

Saurabh Sharma
Saurabh Sharma Published on: 13 Sep, 2023
Ethical reporting - how to cover suicide responsibly

Sensationalist reporting of suicide cases has been shown to cause a rise in the numbers of people taking their own lives in affected communities. Journalists must take great care

Abeer Ayyoub
Abeer Ayyoub Published on: 7 Sep, 2023
‘Don’t let someone else narrate your stories for you’ - travel journalists in the global south

THE LONG READ: Life as a travel journalist isn’t just for privileged Westerners ‘discovering’ quaint parts of south-east Asia and Africa

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 1 Sep, 2023
‘People need to stop blindly obeying the law’ - journalists fighting on the fringes in Vietnam

THE LONG READ: Imprisoned, exiled and forced to base themselves overseas, independent journalists in Vietnam are punished harshly if they publish the ‘wrong’ sort of content. Some, such as Luật Khoa tạp chí, are fighting back

headshot
Al Jazeera Journalism Review Correspondent Published on: 25 Aug, 2023
Ethics and safety in OSINT - can you believe what you see?

OSINT is increasingly important for journalists in a digital world. We take a look at ethics, safety on the internet and how to spot a ‘deepfake’

Sara
Sara Creta Published on: 15 Aug, 2023
‘Other journalists jeer at us’ – life for mobile journalists in Cameroon

Journalists in Cameroon are using their phones in innovative ways to report the news for many different types of media, but major news organisations have still not caught up

Akem
Akem Nkwain Published on: 1 Aug, 2023
‘Life of journalists is cheap’ - how the Philippines became deadly for reporters

Forging ahead with a career in journalism is fraught with difficulty in the Philippines - and many are walking away. What went so wrong?

Ana
Ana P Santos Published on: 19 Jul, 2023
Analysis: Could AI replace humans in journalism?

Recent advances in AI are mind-blowing. But good journalism requires certain skills which, for now at least, only humans can master

Mei Shigenobu
Mei Shigenobu Published on: 17 Jul, 2023
Analysis: Comparing coverage of the Titanic submersible and migrant boat disasters

Two disasters costing human lives have occurred at sea in the past two weeks, but the media coverage of each was markedly different. How and why?

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 28 Jun, 2023
The silencing of Sudan's journalists - again

THE LONG READ: Detained, beaten and their cameras smashed - Sudan’s journalists are enduring a renewed crackdown on the media

Philip Obaji Jr
Philip Obaji Jr Published on: 7 Jun, 2023
'Rebuilt memory by memory' - recreating a Palestinian village 75 years after the Nakba

REPORTER'S NOTEBOOK: How it took the collective memories of several generations, painstaking interviews and a determined search through tall grass and prickly plants to recreate a destroyed community

Amandas
Amandas Ong Published on: 4 Jun, 2023
Suffering in silence - the Kashmiri journalists facing a mental health crisis

THE LONG READ: Al Jazeera Journalism Review has interviewed more than 20 journalists in India-controlled Kashmir who are facing exhausting, insurmountable obstacles to doing their jobs safely every single day

Adil Akhoon
Adil Amin Akhoon, Khalid Bashir Gura Published on: 29 May, 2023
How to analyse satellite imagery

When you have a story, but still need to tie up loose ends to answer where or when a particular event occurred, satellite imagery can point you in the right direction

Sara
Sara Creta Published on: 25 May, 2023
OSINT: Tracking ships, planes and weapons

Tracking ships and planes is an increasingly valuable technique in open-source investigations carried out by journalists. In part 4 of our special series, we examine how it works

Sara
Sara Creta Published on: 18 May, 2023
How social media bans have crippled journalism in India’s Punjab

The Indian government has ordered social media platforms to block hundreds of accounts of journalists and activists

Meer Faisal
Meer Faisal Published on: 16 May, 2023
Tear gas and internet blackouts - reporting on protests in Pakistan

REPORTER'S NOTEBOOK: Following the arrest of former Prime Minister Imran Khan, violence has erupted across Pakistan. For journalists, it is like reporting from the centre of a storm

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 14 May, 2023
Remembering Shireen; my colleague and a 'role model for professionalism'

On the eve of the first anniversary of the killing of Shireen Abu Akleh, Al Jazeera's Senior Correspondent in Palestine, her colleague commemorates the compassion, integrity and professionalism which made her the extraordinary journalist and human being that she was

Walid
Walid Omary Published on: 10 May, 2023
Planning and carrying out an open-source investigation

Part three of our special series of articles on using OSINT in journalism. This time, follow our four steps to completing an open-source investigation

Sara
Sara Creta Published on: 9 May, 2023
What is an open-source investigation?

In the second part of our special series on using open-source intelligence in journalism, we look at what constitutes and open-source investigation

Sara
Sara Creta Published on: 4 May, 2023
Using open-source intelligence in journalism

Where once journalists relied on sources for information - also known as ‘human intelligence’ (HUMINT) - they now increasingly rely on ‘open-source’ intelligence (OSINT) gathered from the internet, satellite imagery, corporate databases and much, much more

Phil
Phil Rees Published on: 12 Apr, 2023
Why is life so dangerous for Pakistani journalists?

Pakistani journalists face huge danger in the course of carrying out their work. Why is so little being done to address this?

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 6 Apr, 2023
Investigating the assassination of my own father

As a journalist, reporting on the murder of my father meant answering questions about my own position as an objective observer

Diana Lopez
Diana Lopez Zuleta Published on: 3 Apr, 2023