Al Jazeera Journalism Review

outside image
Members of the head table applaud as comedian Hasan Minhaj finishes his performance at the White House Correspondents' Association dinner in Washington, US, on April 29, 2017 [Jonathan Ernst/Reuters]

‘Emotional truth’ is not a cover for fabricating stories

Comedians who engage with the news should not be free to ignore the rules of ethical journalism

 

In an interview published by the New Yorker on September 15 this year, the popular comedian Hasan Minhaj who is known for his political satire show "Patriot Act", admitted he had lied about an anthrax scare involving his own daughter. Earlier still, it turns out, Minhaj fabricated a story about his mosque being infiltrated by an FBI informant as a teenager, during which he claimed to have been subjected to assault by law enforcement. In the interview with the New Yorker, Minhaj defends himself, suggesting these stories were grounded in “emotional truth” and insists that “the punchline is worth the fictionalised premise".

Except it’s not. Not just because there are some things one just doesn’t lie about, but, as the article points out: "Minhaj's projects blur the lines between entertainment and opinion journalism." Distancing themselves from the “journalist” label, comedians like Minhaj, who proactively engage with the news for a living, evade any and all accountability.

In other words: there are baseline levels of truth and journalistic standards we need to expect from comedians who build their brands commenting on current affairs in the manner opinion journalists do. Like it or not, these comedic journalists owe their viewers factual truths over “emotional” ones.

Like Minhaj, comedians such as Jon Stewart, John Oliver, Stephen Colbert, Trevor Noah and Samantha Bee, have all engaged in this form of journalism. Whether you call what they do “infotainment”, “satirical news anchoring”, or “humour journalism”, these people have all brought their audiences news after collecting it and processing it (with the aid of teams) in an exceptionally engaging form. People want to watch this mix of politically liberal commentary and comedy – “laughtivism” as it’s been called – it’s good for ratings.

As a journalist, I’m a proponent of the political commentary and public discussion this ambiguous comedy-meets-news space encourages. It widens the potential for news literacy amongst all age groups, but especially the 91 per cent of young people who get their news via social media. News satire, especially, expects intelligence from its informed audience.

What’s more, millennials in particular enjoy this brand of comedic “citizen journalism”, suggest the authors of Is Satire Saving Our Nation? Sophia A. McLennen and Remy M. Maisel. McLennen and Maisel also note satirical journalism enhances democratic culture. It’s really no small feat that Last Week Tonight with John Oliver showcases otherwise sidelined news stories in a manner some academics have called “a form of investigative reporting.”

But in an age of rampant misinformation and disinformation, we simply can’t afford for the people who deliver our news - with or without comedic stylings - to go unchecked because they choose to shun the “journalist” label. For journalists, unethical practices have real world consequences. After news broke that CNN anchor Chris Cuomo had violated the network’s journalistic standards by helping his brother, former New York governor Andrew Cuomo, his firing was no surprise.

In Minhaj’s case, he did a sit down tele-interview with Amanpour and Company’s Hari Sreenivasan where he referenced the anthrax incident as a “factual truth”. The unfortunate truth is that we live in a world where no one needs to manufacture stories that portray hate crimes. 

To be clear, I’m not asking the everyday comic, mic in hand, political hot-takes at the ready, to tell the truth (even if there are some lines one doesn’t cross). I’m speaking solely of people whose comedic stylings sit at the intersection of entertainment, profit and news and journalism. Knowing that this genre of comedy has real-world implications - the potential to raise awareness and change politically-rigid beliefs - those who partake in it need to be subject to standards we wouldn’t apply to everyday comedians.

A lot of these comedian-anchor-commentators do have journalistic power. They hold political figures to account in a manner everyday journalists and news anchors don’t (or sometimes can’t). The headlines can be glorious: Trevor Noah “grilled” Chris Christie and Tomi Lahren, Hasan Minhaj “grilled” Canadian PM Justin Trudeau, Jon Stewart “grilled” Judith Miller. But who holds them to account, beyond a few angry voices on the internet?

Moreover, is Minhaj qualified to hold anyone in power to account after this? Reportedly, Minhaj’s “emotional truths” débacle disqualifies him from hosting the much-coveted Daily Show, which is still in need of an anchor following Trevor Noah’s departure last year. This is certainly a step toward accountability, but is it enough? 

As one would expect, these shows hire newsgathering and fact-checking teams. Why, then, don’t they have any sort of concrete regulated journalistic standards? Perhaps, as this comedy-meets-political commentary genre evolves further, it’s something the journalism community can consider. We know Minhaj went too far, but where, exactly, is the compromise between journalism and comedic entertainment here? 

Akanksha Singh is an independent journalist based between Mumbai, India and Lisbon, Portugal

 

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera Journalism Review’s editorial stance

 

More Articles

What It Means to Be an Investigative Journalist Today

A few weeks ago, Carla Bruni, wife of former French president Nicolas Sarkozy, was seen removing the Mediapart logo from view. The moment became a symbol of a major victory for investigative journalism, after the platform exposed Gaddafi’s financing of Sarkozy’s election campaign, leading to his prison conviction. In this article, Edwy Plenel, founder of Mediapart and one of the most prominent figures in global investigative journalism, reflects on a central question: what does it mean to be an investigative journalist today?

Edwy Plenel
Edwy Plenel Published on: 27 Nov, 2025
In-Depth and Longform Journalism in the AI Era: Revival or Obsolescence?

Can artificial intelligence tools help promote and expand the reach of longform journalism, still followed by a significant audience, or will they accelerate its decline? This article examines the leading AI tools reshaping the media landscape and explores the emerging opportunities they present for longform journalism, particularly in areas such as search and content discovery.

. سعيد ولفقير. كاتب وصحافي مغربي. ساهم واشتغل مع عددٍ من المنصات العربية منذ أواخر عام 2014.Said Oulfakir. Moroccan writer and journalist. He has contributed to and worked with a number of Arab media platforms since late 2014.
Said Oulfakir Published on: 24 Nov, 2025
Leaked BBC Memo: What Does the Crisis Reveal?

How Should We Interpret the Leak of the “BBC Memo” on Editorial Standards? Can we truly believe that the section concerning U.S. President Donald Trump was the sole reason behind the wave of resignations at the top of the British broadcaster? Or is it more accurately seen as part of a broader attempt to seize control over editorial decision-making? And to what extent can the pressure on newsrooms be attributed to the influence of the Zionist lobby?

 Mohammed Abuarqoub. Journalist, trainer, and researcher specializing in media affairs. He holds a PhD in Communication Philosophy from Regent University in the United States.محمد أبو عرقوب صحفي ومدرّب وباحث متخصص في شؤون الإعلام، حاصل على درجة الدكتوراه في فلسفة الاتّصال من جامعة ريجينت بالولايات المتحدة الأمريكية.
Mohammed Abuarqoub Published on: 20 Nov, 2025
Crisis of Credibility: How the Anglo-American Journalism Model Failed the World

Despite an unprecedented global flood of information, journalism remains strikingly impotent in confronting systemic crises—largely because the dominant Anglo-American model, shaped by commercial imperatives and capitalist allegiances, is structurally incapable of pursuing truth over power or effecting meaningful change. This critique calls for dismantling journalism’s subordination to market logic and imagining alternative models rooted in political, literary, and truth-driven commitments beyond the confines of capitalist production.

Imran Muzaffar
Imran Muzaffar, Aliya Bashir, Syed Aadil Hussain Published on: 14 Nov, 2025
Why Has Arab Cultural Journalism Weakened in the Third Millennium?

The crisis of cultural journalism in the Arab world reflects a deeper decline in the broader cultural and moral project, as well as the collapse of education and the erosion of human development. Yet this overarching diagnosis cannot excuse the lack of professional training and the poor standards of cultural content production within newsrooms.

Fakhri Saleh
Fakhri Saleh Published on: 10 Nov, 2025
Podcasters, content creators and influencers are not journalists. Are they?

Are podcasters, content creators, and influencers really journalists, or has the word 'journalist' been stretched so thin that it now covers anyone holding a microphone and an opinion? If there is a difference, where does it sit? Is it in method, mission, accountability, or something else? And in a media landscape built on noise, how do we separate a journalist from someone who produces content for clicks, followers or sponsors

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 7 Nov, 2025
The Power to Write History: How Journalism Shapes Collective Memory and Forgetting

What societies remember, and what they forget, is shaped not only by historians but by journalism. From wars to natural disasters, the news does not simply record events; it decides which fragments endure in collective memory, and which fade into silence.

Daniel Harper
Daniel Harper Published on: 30 Oct, 2025
Journalism in Spain: Why Omitting Ethnicity May Be Doing More Harm Than Good

In Spain, a well-intentioned media practice of omitting suspects’ ethnic backgrounds in crime reporting is now backfiring, fuelling misinformation, empowering far-right narratives, and eroding public trust in journalism.

Ilya إيليا توبر 
Ilya U Topper Published on: 10 Sep, 2025
Interview with Zina Q. : Digital Cartography as a Tool of Erasure in Gaza

Amid Israel’s war on Gaza, Zina Q. uncovers how Google Maps and satellite imagery are being manipulated; homes relabelled as “haunted,” map updates delayed, and evidence of destruction obscured, revealing digital cartography itself as a weapon of war. By exposing these distortions and linking them to conflicts from Sudan to Ukraine, she demonstrates how control over maps and AI surveillance influences not only what the world sees, but also what it remembers.

Al Jazeera Journalism Review
Al Jazeera Journalism Review Published on: 6 Sep, 2025
Canadian Journalists for Justice in Palestine: A Call to Name the Killer, Not Just the Crime

How many journalists have to be killed before we name the killer? What does press freedom mean if it excludes Palestinians? In its latest strike, Israel killed an entire Al Jazeera news crew in Gaza—part of a systematic campaign to silence the last witnesses to its crimes. Canadian Journalists for Justice in Palestine (CJJP) condemns this massacre and calls on the Canadian government to end its complicity, uphold international law, and demand full accountability. This is not collateral damage. This is the targeted erasure of truth.

Samira Mohyeddin
Samira Mohyeddin Published on: 14 Aug, 2025
Protecting Palestinian Journalists Should be First Priority - Above Western Media Access

Why demand entry for foreign reporters when Palestinian journalists are already risking—and losing—their lives to tell the truth? Real solidarity means saving journalists' lives, amplifying their voices, and naming the genocide they expose daily.

Synne Furnes Bjerkestrand
Synne Bjerkestrand, Kristian Lindhardt Published on: 10 Aug, 2025
The Washington Post: When Language Becomes a Veil for Pro-Israel Bias

How did The Washington Post's coverage differ between Israel’s bombing of Gaza hospitals and Iran’s strike on an Israeli hospital? Why does the paper attempt to frame Palestinian victims within a “complex operational context”? And when does language become a tool of bias toward the Israeli narrative?

Said Al-Azri
Said Al-Azri Published on: 6 Aug, 2025
In the War on Gaza: How Do You Tell a Human Story?

After nine months of genocidal war on Palestine, how can journalists tell human stories? Which stories should they focus on? And does the daily, continuous coverage of the war’s developments lead to a “normalisation of death”?

Yousef Fares
Yousef Fares Published on: 8 Jul, 2025
How Much AI is Too Much AI for Ethical Journalism

As artificial intelligence transforms newsrooms across South Asia, journalists grapple with the fine line between enhancement and dependency

Saurabh Sharma
Saurabh Sharma Published on: 1 Jul, 2025
How to Tell the Stories of Gaza’s Children

Where does compassion end and journalism begin? How can one engage with children ethically, and is it even morally acceptable to conduct interviews with them? Palestinian journalist Reem Al-Qatawy offers a profoundly different approach to human-interest reporting. At the Hope Institute in Gaza, she met children enduring the harrowing aftermath of losing their families. Her experience was marked by intense professional and ethical challenges.

Rima Al-Qatawi
Rima Al-Qatawi Published on: 26 Jun, 2025
Do Foreign Journalists Matter in Covering Genocide? A Look into Bosnia, Rwanda, and Gaza

How did foreign journalists cover the killings in both Bosnia-Herzegovina and Rwanda? Did they contribute to conveying the truth and making an impact? Would the entry of foreign journalists into the Gaza Strip change the reality of the ongoing genocide? And would their coverage of the famine and massacres add to the daily coverage of local journalists? Why is the local press's coverage of wars seen as deficient compared to Western journalism, even though they incur greater losses and casualties?

Saber Halima
Saber Halima Published on: 20 Jun, 2025
How Palestine Is Forcing Journalists to Reexamine Objectivity and Decolonize

This article argues that the Palestinian context exposes the colonial roots of traditional journalism and calls for a decolonial approach that centers marginalized voices, promotes collaborative reporting, and demands structural change within newsrooms to uphold journalistic integrity.

Sanne Breimer
Sanne Breimer Published on: 12 Jun, 2025
The Role of Social Science Tools in Enhancing Journalism

When French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu was asked about the contribution of the suburbs to elections, he replied that decades of colonialism and complex problems cannot be summarised in 10 minutes. The value of social sciences in supporting journalism is demonstrated when they address issues of society, power, and identity for the sake of better journalism.

Rehab Zaheri
Rehab Zaheri Published on: 6 Jun, 2025
Digital Dependency: Unpacking Tech Philanthropy’s Grip on Local News in the MENA

AI-driven journalism initiatives in the Middle East, often backed by philanthropic media development projects, are reshaping local newsrooms under the influence of global tech giants. These efforts, while marketed as support, risk deepening power asymmetries, fostering digital dependency, and reactivating colonial patterns of control through algorithmic systems and donor-driven agendas.

Sara Ait Khorsa
Sara Ait Khorsa Published on: 3 Jun, 2025
Journalism Colleges in Somalia: A Battle for Survival

Journalism colleges in Somalia are struggling to survive due to outdated curricula, lack of practical training, insufficient funding, and a shortage of qualified educators, leading to declining student enrollment and interest. Despite efforts by institutions like Mogadishu University and Hormuud University to revive journalism education, these challenges persist, threatening the future of journalism in the country.

Al-Shafi Abtidon
Al-Shafi Abtidon Published on: 30 May, 2025
Philippine Activists Fight Archive Erasure and Revive Dictatorship-Era Memories

In the Philippines, archivists fight to preserve evidence of the country’s bloodied past, in hope that it will provide lessons for the future.

Tristan James Biglete
Tristan James Biglete Published on: 27 May, 2025
News Fatigue and Avoidance: How Media Overload is Reshaping Audience Engagement

A study conducted on 12,000 American adults revealed that two-thirds feel “exhausted” by the overwhelming volume of news they receive. Why is the public feeling drained by the news? Are audiences actively avoiding it, and at what psychological cost? Most importantly, how can the media rebuild trust and reconnect with its audience?

Othman Kabashi
Othman Kabashi Published on: 25 May, 2025
Weaponized Artificial Intelligence: The Unseen Threat to Fact-Checking

How has artificial intelligence emerged as a powerful tool during wartime, and what strategies are fact-checkers adopting to confront this disruptive force in newsrooms? The work of fact-checkers has grown significantly more challenging during the genocide in Palestine, as the Israeli occupation has relied heavily on artificial intelligence to disseminate misinformation.

Ahmad Al-Arja
Ahmad Al-Arja Published on: 18 May, 2025
Reporting from the Ruins; Why We Must Keep Myanmar’s Journalists Alive and Online

In Myanmar, journalism has become a courageous act of resistance. As the military junta tightens its grip on information, journalists face growing technological, political, and security barriers. This article explores the urgent need to support Myanmar’s embattled media workers before the country slides into a full information blackout.

Annie Zaman
Annie Zaman Published on: 13 May, 2025