Al Jazeera Journalism Review

LAHORE, PAKISTAN: Pigeons fly over the Wazir Khan Mosque in the walled city of Old Lahore on July 9, 2010 in Lahore, Pakistan. (Photo by Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images)

Why I’ve had to launch my own magazine about Pakistan

Western media is full of negative stereotypes about my birth country. My job as a diaspora journalist is to challenge those tired old tropes.


Met by silence or disappeared into a black hole - I've received my fourth in a row of rejected pitches from editors within the past month, after offering counter-narratives not traditionally associated with Pakistan in the Western media.

"I love this, but unfortunately we're avoiding countries which border Afghanistan at the moment," said an editor at the Telegraph, in response to my travel feature idea, which had a timely news angle - when the UK announced it was removing Pakistan from its travel red list on September 22, 2021.

As a diaspora journalist, born in Pakistan and now living in the United Kingdom, I've always felt the need to build a bridge of knowledge between my countries of origin and residence, to bring in different perspectives wherever I can, through my niche, hybrid-identity.

My retort to editors in the past month has been the same: "Why do conflicts in the neighbourhood have severe negative spillover effects on the whole of Pakistan?" "Why do you focus on the troubled spots and not on the positive stories?" "Why search out the most miserable angles and continue portraying Pakistan as a nest of problems?"

KARACHI, PAKISTAN - Road shop furniture burns as Shiite Muslim demonstrators protest over the killing of a doctor, a Shiite Muslim, in August 2003. Images like this are commonly used in Western media as "typical" of Pakistan. (Photo by Syed Zargahm/Getty Images)

In exasperation, I have decided to launch my own print magazine which will aim to highlight the real face of Pakistan and put right some of these negative stereotypes that we can’t seem to shrug off.

Of course, I understand that the current state of emergency in neighbouring Afghanistan could destroy borders. The US media depiction of Pakistan as a culprit of the Afghanistan conflict is also unavoidable. In his op-ed for The Washington Post on August 25, 2021, columnist Josh Rogin admits: "To the extent that Pakistan is mentioned in US media coverage of the Afghanistan crisis, it is mostly indicted for its alleged support of the Taliban over the years."

But that's not the only reason editors refuse to accept “happy” stories on Pakistan.

A ‘theatre of terror’

Take a glance at Western media coverage from over the years and, more often than not, you will notice that Pakistan's narratives continue to be told through the same persistent and negative stereotypes.

Most reporting refers to the country as a theatre of "terror" with nothing to offer except "violence" and "security threats". While overlooking the region’s many political and economic success stories, the coverage is time and again crisis-driven, repeatedly associating Pakistan with references to and images of shotguns, rifles and bombs.

This sort of media coverage is not new. Examples of biased headlines from years past include: "What Next for Pakistan? Terror, Nukes and an Uncertain Future" from German News Outlet Der Spiegel on December 31, 2007, in which the paper made unfair predictions and judgements. 

Journalist David Rohde's article in the New York Times in February 2003 titled: "Threats and responses" Out in the world - Pakistan; Most Dangerous Spot For Americans" created feelings of fear. 

More recently, when reporting on the book, Call Sign Chaos: Learning to Lead by General Jim Mattis, Business Insider used this headline: "Mattis says the most dangerous country in the world is Pakistan," on September 4, 2019.

Most reporting refers to Pakistan as a theatre of "terror" with nothing to offer except "violence" and "security threats" 


Like every other country, Pakistan has its problems. But whether or not Pakistan is really that bad, the nature of such reporting will combine with the nature of our cognition to make us think that it is.

Consider media framing theory, an extension of agenda-setting, which indicates that the way the media reports on an issue - what they choose to report and how they choose to report it - shapes our perceptions on how to think about those issues. In this process, with repeated exposure to a certain angle, they set the agenda. 

Murder rate 'worse than Pakistan’

The dominant frame given when reporting on Pakistan is that of a “problematic” country, characterised by political instability, corruption, disaster, crime, plane crashes and, more recently, sexual harassment. Everything is negative. When there is a positive aspect, it becomes questionable and almost hard to believe.

This also leads to disproportionate associations and comparisons of Pakistan with extreme levels of criminality and risk factors in other parts of the world. The Los Angeles Times, for instance, published an op-ed on July 13, 2021, about the rise of homicide in the US, which mentions: "The nation is ranked in the global murder rate index worse than Pakistan..." 

In fact, Pakistan is nowhere near the top of the list for murders. It reports 3.88 murders per 100,000 people, compared to the US, which reports 4.96. And there are plenty of far riskier places in the world - look at El Salvador with 52 murders per 100,000 people or even Jamaica - still considered a popular holiday destination - at 43.85.

A travel piece published by Condé Nast Traveler on January 31, 2018, with the following headline: "Yes, You Can Still Visit Cuba Legally - and It's Safe" stated in the opening sentence: "On Sunday, I flew to a place that the US State Department considers as risky as Pakistan..." How do you think editors would respond if I replaced 'Cuba' with 'Pakistan' and pitched this story to Western media outlets right now - while they continue finger-pointing at the security of Pakistan, because of the Taliban takeover in Afghanistan and after New Zealand abandoned a cricket tour?

What I find most worrying is that this distorted, one-dimensional view, adopted by the West, is also accepted by many people of Pakistani descent living overseas - those who also don't see their ancestral homeland beyond the mud huts, and only through the prism of poverty, as a backward-looking, unprogressive country.

LAHORE, PAKISTAN - OCTOBER 17: Prince William, Duke of Cambridge and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge visit Badshahi Mosque during their royal tour of Pakistan on October 17, 2019 in Lahore, Pakistan. (Photo by Owen Humphreys - Pool/Getty Images)

In February this year, the Telegraph carried an interview feature with Adil Ray, a UK TV star, on exploring his roots in 1980s Pakistan. It describes Pakistan through terms such as "old" and "rickety", where "televisions were few and far" between, and to go to the lavatory, his father would take him to a "field". Even now, in 2021, such old-fashioned notions have not been fully abandoned. There is a severe image imbalance at play. A balanced story would also mention how Pakistan has undergone a massive transformation during these last four decades, with its rapid changes in education and technology, modern-day facilities, architecture and well-developed road networks. But these things are usually absent in the mindsets of Western media audiences.

Even when Western coverage of Pakistan appears more positive, it repeatedly refers to tales of terrorism and the Taliban, along with advice from the UK’s Foreign Office against all travel to Pakistan. For example, on the first day of the royal visit to Pakistan by the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge - October 14, 2019 - the Telegraph published an article titled: "In search of the real Pakistan" with the following opening sentence: "Terrorism, Taliban, Osama Bin Laden." The use of hopeful words, further on in the article, like "prosper", is immediately weakened. The same old repetitive cliches of a situation involving exposure to danger, routinely written through the same outsider perspective like a camera lens that doesn’t quite zoom in beyond the surface and a snapshot that remains blurry.

The role of the diaspora journalist

In the UK, 94 percent of journalists are white, according to the National Council of Training for Journalists (NCTJ). Only 1 percent of journalists are Black, with roughly the same level for Asians. Therefore, it is easy to see why the Western media is not always a reflection of people like me, and why rejection is a frequent part of journalism.

It is not just the Western media that lacks in diversity. The Pakistani media, too, commits many of the same sins. Although most of the coverage caters to the audiences at home, it prefers to broadcast the say of white influencers when it comes to a global representation, with the firm belief that foreign faces appeal to the international crowd.

Western coverage of Pakistan repeatedly refers to tales of terrorism and the Taliban, along with advice from the UK’s Foreign Office against all travel there


The Pakistani diaspora appears mostly on Instagram feeds advertising money transfer services and in remittance adverts. But there is considerably more value in creating a diasporic journalism platform than merely portraying us as investors who connect foreign firms to the social networks in a developing country.

I argue for diversifying newsrooms and building stronger bridges between diaspora journalists and the established Western and Pakistani press. A case study of the African diasporic press in the UK, published November 12, 2018, on SAGE Journals, demonstrates that when diaspora journalists write about conflicts in the homeland, "they show a preference for a factual style and a governing frame, and less preference for a judgmental style". 

Indeed, the diaspora community can be unbiased and resourceful, serving as agents of change for the homeland and the country of residence. Diaspora journalists can help bring together varying perspectives, fact-checking and knowledge exchange, to combat sensational reporting. I, too, travelling back and forth, between the UK and Pakistan, as both an insider and an outsider, gravitate towards narrating the unsung narratives.

PESHAWAR, PAKISTAN: A carpet featuring an image of the Kaaba hangs above a street after Friday prayers on April 16, 2021 in Peshawar as Pakistan began observing the Islamic holy month of Ramadan. (Photo by Danial Shah/Getty Images)

However, it isn't easy to write as a diaspora journalist because it is precious, sensitive and unique. It means admitting that I'm different to the white editors who commission me and probably different, as well, from those Pakistanis who will read my work. But now, more than ever, we must challenge uneven histories and presentations, to find new audiences.

Launching our own platforms

To address all these issues and tell Pakistani stories and those of its diaspora in a more authentic way, I launched Capra Falconeri Traveller, a print magazine with an online presence.

The first edition is dedicated to covering diverse landscapes and humans, rather than issues, and telling stories that celebrate Pakistan's creativity and innovation through travel, culture, people, wildlife and places.

In today's digital world, a well-designed print publication helps break through that unbalanced digital noise and is considered more reliable. The print has an established timeless staying power as the most credible medium. When you have something important to say, say it with print. Neuroscience research also suggests that print content connects more with our brains and has a memory-changing power.

Seeing Pakistan from this fresh perspective, a source of fact-checked and copy-edited stories may help to change the old negative perceptions.


Anam Hussain is a freelance diaspora journalist born in Pakistan and based in the UK

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera Journalism Review’s editorial stance




More Articles

How should we talk about Pakistan?

How do journalists report accurately about a country which suffers sectarian violence without reinforcing Islamophobic tropes?

Haroon Khalid
Haroon Khalid Published on: 24 Jan, 2022
'Both sides’ journalism does not always show us the truth

Journalists are bound to tell the truth, not give platforms to positions which are demonstrably wrong in a misguided attempt to be ‘impartial’.

Sakhr Al-Makhadhi Published on: 17 Jan, 2022
Forget superheroes - science journalists will save the world

Science journalism is not just about test tubes, it's about everything. And the past few years have shown that the world needs science journalists more than ever before.

Osama Abu El Rub Published on: 16 Jan, 2022
The media must stop obsessing about ‘economic migrants’

The use of the term ‘economic migrants’ to describe desperate people trying to find a better life for themselves and their families conceals the reality of the brutality they face at Europe’s borders.

Lucy Papachristou Published on: 13 Dec, 2021
Life as a journalist on a US ‘kill list’

The US continues to shroud policies for the ‘War on Terror’ behind a veil of secrecy. This undermines democracy and a free press, and means no justice for one American journalist who claims he has been targeted for assassination on five separate occasions, nor for countless civilian casualties of US drone attacks.

Pauline Canham
Pauline Canham Published on: 28 Nov, 2021
No, you are NOT the story

A writer reflects on the absurdity - and naivety - of journalists who place themselves at the centre of the stories they cover.

Noe Zavaleta Published on: 21 Nov, 2021
It’s time to put an end to ‘parachute’ journalism

While global media organisations continue to fly in their own correspondents, relying on local journalists only for translation and ‘fixing’, the world will never get to know the real stories happening in the Global South.

Dina Aboughazala
Dina Aboughazala Published on: 7 Nov, 2021
Julian Assange and Wikileaks are no model for responsible journalism

Punishing journalists who publish leaked information is an assault on democracy, but journalists still need to handle such information with care and integrity.

Julie Bindel Published on: 31 Oct, 2021
When journalists are blind to their privilege, the ‘true’ story may not be told

It took me years to see how my privilege would influence the outcome of interviews with minority Hindus in Pakistan. This ‘positionality’ is something journalists should pay closer heed to.

Haroon Khalid
Haroon Khalid Published on: 24 Oct, 2021
Will Zimbabwe’s journalists be harmed by new cyber laws? 

Zimbabwe’s Cybersecurity and Data Protection Bill aims to protect privacy and guard against child sexual abuse depicted online. But it could also seriously hamper a free press.

Derick M
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 28 Sep, 2021
Secrecy is journalism's deadliest foe

When journalists unquestioningly swallow the narrative put forward by governments in the name of 'secrecy', it serves no-one.

Clive Stafford Smith
Clive Stafford Smith Published on: 12 Sep, 2021
Professional Integrity: The Cornerstone of Protection

Propaganda and censorship are as old as war itself, but that has generally been a struggle to control the story rather than targeting

Peter Greste Published on: 29 Jul, 2021
The West forms a new Arab “Imaginary”

Years ago, the Moroccan thinker Hassan Aourid published his book titled "The Refracted Mirror of the West". Among its major topics was his seeking for media intervention to shape a new public opinion. The article brought a detailed explanation of compatibility of media visions between the West and the Arab regimes' orientations after September 11, 2001 events.

A picture of the author, Hassan Aourid
Hassan Aourid Published on: 30 Jun, 2021
The Palestinian struggle to be seen in the media

Does the global media treat Palestinian lives as inherently less valuable?

A picture of the author, Abeer alNajjar
Abeer al-Najjar Published on: 30 May, 2021
In coverage of Palestine, biases and irresponsible journalism emerge

In the coverage of events in Jerusalem and Gaza, mainstream media outlets are failing to report on the situation fairly.

A picture of the author, William Christou.
William Christou Published on: 13 May, 2021
Journalism and sociology; uneasy bedfellows

Journalism and sociology cannot be at odds since they are based on the same principle, and they use the same tools to construct social analyses. Still, the two disciplines do not see eye to eye. The sociologist sees the journalist as superficial, while the journalist sees the sociologist as cloistered in an ivory tower.

A picture of the author, Mohammad Ahdad.
Mohammad Ahdad Published on: 10 May, 2021
Should foreign laborers in Oman have their own media outlets?

Asian migrant workers in Oman face a host of challenge in adjusting to their host country. Could media outlets in their native languages ameliorate those challenges?

A picture of the author, Summayya al-Yakubi
Sumayya al-Yakubi Published on: 2 May, 2021
Slow versus instant journalism: Is digital media the answer?

Digital media might be the answer to a question gripping the journalism industry: Slow or instant journalism?

The Al Jazeera Media Institute logo.
Muhammad Ahmed Published on: 25 Apr, 2021
Beyond objectivity: The rise of reformist news

The core mission of the news industry is telling viewers the day's events. But another core mission of journalism is to make the world a better place, which means going beyond the facts to change what’s wrong and defend what’s right. Those two missions are in conflict today.

A picture of the author, Mark Lee Hunter.
Mark Lee Hunter Published on: 23 Mar, 2021
Importing credibility: Why does foreign private media invest in the Arab media market?

Why are western media companies all of a sudden interested in opening channels in the Arab World?

A picture of the author, Ahmad Abu Hamad
Ahmad Abu Hamad Published on: 1 Mar, 2021
Foreign funding and orientalism: On the need for an "organic journalist"

When many North African countries achieved their independence, nationalists began to repeat a sentence of great importance: Colonization will leave out the door, only to come back through the window. The sentence has proved to be prescient, as colonization has come back through the gateway of media, with an orientalist view that detaches reality from its cultural, and socio-political contexts.

Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 28 Feb, 2021
Close up and personal

Can Arabs accurately report their own affairs? Can Muslims be reliable sources of objective information about their daily lives and historic changes? We from the Arab and Muslim world are rethinking the news.

Hamid Dabashi Published on: 15 Feb, 2021