Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Gitmo
GUANTANAMO BAY, CUBA: Razor wire tops the fence of the US prison at Guantanamo Bay, also known as 'Gitmo' on October 23, 2016 . The US military's Joint Task Force Guantanamo is still currently holding 39 detainees, most without charge, for indefinite periods without trial at the prison, down from a previous total of 780 - the rest of whom have been released. In 2008, then-President Obama issued an executive order to close the prison, but this has failed to be enacted because of political opposition in the US [John Moore/Getty Images]

Human rights lessons from a ‘terrorist’ journalist

It has ever been the case that when a journalist reports crimes by a despot, militant group or even, these days, a so-called democratic state, he is liable to be labelled a criminal.

 

 

One of the early ironies in 2022 must be that Bilal Abdul Kareem, an American journalist deemed by the US to be such a dangerous terrorist that he merits assassination-by-drone, is this week launching a new initiative to bring human rights to the war-torn wasteland of Syria.

Bilal has, along with a number of allies, created a new organisation called Istiqama which denotes a blend of integrity, honesty and justice. Their “Prisoner’s Covenant” which proposes rules compliant with various UN conventions to bind the actions of Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), the Islamist militant group holding sway over the area around Idlib.

I find myself representing too many journalists these days – in Guantánamo, one of my clients was Sami el Haj, who was interrogated endlessly about his work with Al Jazeera, rather than any terrorist activity. Meanwhile Bilal is the main mover behind On the Ground News (OGN) in Syria. 

The common thread stitching Sami and Bilal together is that where journalism questions the American narrative in our Post-9/11 world, the journalist is deemed a “terrorist” himself. “Either you are with us or you are with the terrorists,” as President George W Bush announced on September 20, 2001.

The Iraq War was advertised as a modern crusade to liberate the people from Saddam Hussein, and put a stop to his nuclear ambitions. Al Jazeera told some unhappy truths about what was happening, and in some Western eyes that made the station a latter-day Josef Goebbels for terror. Indeed, the British Home Secretary at the time that Al Jazeera’s office in Bagdad was bombed publicly said as much. 

Sami was a victim of this and, ultimately, when we freed him from Guantánamo, he recognised that he had to lead a new Human Rights Bureau for the station, fighting for others to receive the legal rights he had been denied.

Bilal has continued this tradition of reporting from the front lines, where the “Arab Spring” in Syria is the step-child of the “Arab Spring” in Iraq. This is not the democracy and freedom the West promised, but chaos created by proxy wars between the US and Russia, with little thought given to the people who must live through it. Thus Bilal founded OGN, “committed to delivering accurate English language news to a Western audience regarding the Syrian crisis.”

Yet “accurate news”, at least through Bilal’s eyes, is not what Western governments want to hear. Hence, in 2016, many believe the US targeted him for assassination at least five times. This was an extraordinary departure from human rights norms, essentially the death penalty without trial. We can never know for sure – the US won’t admit publicly what they are doing and why – but it seemed that Bilal was presumed guilty of being a propaganda agent for HTS. 

Because the Western narrative seeks to preclude the possibility that the West tramples on human rights, the journalist who reports instances of Western torture and abuse is tarred a terrorist

 

I must declare a professional interest here: I was one of the lawyers who brought suit against then-President Donald Trump on Bilal’s behalf. Our initial demand was not even that they should stop trying to kill him; we just wanted them to state what he was supposed to have done wrong, so that we would have the chance to prove his innocence. The Trump Administration resisted vigorously, saying this was all secret, a matter of national security. They ultimately prevailed in court but our litigation cooled their heels, and they have not tried to kill Bilal in more than five years. 

Yet the threat to journalists comes from all sides. HTS, far from seeing him as a cosy extremist ally, arrested him for publishing information about their mistreatment of prisoners. When he was a prisoner himself, Bilal was denied basic legal rights. As his lawyer, I found myself negotiating with the HTS public relations officer to ensure Bilal’s humane treatment. Eventually they let him go.

It has ever been the case that when a journalist reports crimes by a despot – or by a group like HTS – he is liable to be labelled a criminal and (if he is lucky) locked away in Sednaya, the military prison outside Damascus, after a farcical trial. One of my pitches to the HTS authorities has been that, if they want any legitimacy in the wider world, they need to adopt some basic legal principles.

It used to be that Western countries would decry the injustice. Yet Bilal’s history, along with Sami’s, illustrates how endangered journalists are in the wake of 9/11. Because the Western narrative seeks to preclude the possibility that the West tramples on human rights, if the journalist reports instances of Western torture and abuse, he is tarred a terrorist. He is then rendered to Guantánamo, where he loses all his rights; or he is turned into a “bugsplat” by an American Hellfire missile. 

Journalists must therefore now fight for their own rights, as well as those of others. Sami and I have often discussed his plans with Al Jazeera. Bilal ran Istiqama’s Covenant by me before it was finalised. I made a few suggestions, and if HTS could be persuaded to adopt the Covenant it would be a great leap forward. 

To be sure, there are a few elements with which I cannot agree – for example, Bilal feels unable to call for the elimination of the death penalty. Yet how can any American be too critical when we retain capital punishment ourselves in 28 of the 50 states, along with the federal government? Perfection is often the enemy of the good, and we must take steps forward even when we cannot immediately reach our final goal.

“No one from HTS even talks about the Islamic justice that was promised to the Syrian people. It seems that was nothing more than an empty promise from HTS leader Abu Mohammed al-Jolani,” says Bilal, seemingly still intent on irritating the local authorities. "The Prisoner's Covenant enshrines the rights of detainees: No torture, no torture confessions and no indefinite detention.”

Thus Bilal and Istiqama present an early irony in 2022: the supposed terrorist presenting a human rights Covenant that will, if adopted, make HTS more compliant with international law than the US Government. If Bilal succeeds here, I hope he will turn both his camera and his persuasive powers on President Joe Biden.

Clive Stafford Smith is a human rights lawyer
 

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera Journalism Review’s editorial stance

 

More Articles

Western Media’s Double Standards on Muslim Women’s Suffering

When an Iranian student publicly protested against security forces by undressing, the moment garnered widespread attention in Western media. Meanwhile, even as 70 percent of those killed in Palestine are women and children, this ongoing violence—including the systematic killing, torture, and detention of Palestinian women—receives minimal coverage. This disparity raises urgent questions: How do Western media represent women’s issues in the Islamic world, and to what extent are such portrayals shaped by double standards?

Shaimaa Al-Eisai
Shaimaa Al-Eisai Published on: 24 Apr, 2025
Western Media Has Failed Their Palestinian Colleagues

A 2024 CPJ report revealed that nearly 70% of journalists killed that year were targeted by Israel, yet major Western media outlets largely ignored or downplayed the findings. The muted response to these targeted attacks and escalating press restrictions highlights a troubling double standard in the West’s commitment to press freedom.

Assal Rad
Assal Rad Published on: 21 Apr, 2025
Weaponizing the Law: SLAPPs Against Journalists and Press Freedom

SLAPPs—abusive lawsuits designed to silence journalists and activists—are surging across Southeast Asia, exploiting vague laws and weak protections to punish those who speak truth to power. As legal harassment intensifies, journalists face not only imprisonment and censorship but also emotional trauma, exile, and long-term damage to their careers.

AJR Contributor Published on: 17 Apr, 2025
Predicting the Future of Media in 2025

The rise of citizen journalism, the rethinking of long-form content, the evolution of video, and the exploration of AI opportunities are key elements of the media landscape forecast for 2025, according to a report from Harvard University's Nieman Lab.

Othman Kabashi
Othman Kabashi Published on: 15 Apr, 2025
Revisioning Journalism During a Genocide

Western media’s coverage of the Gaza genocide has revealed fundamental cracks in the notion of journalistic objectivity. Mainstream outlets have frequently marginalized or discredited Palestinian perspectives, often echoing narratives that align with Israeli state interests. In stark contrast, Palestinian journalists—reporting from within a besieged landscape—have become frontline truth-tellers. Through raw, emotional storytelling, they are not only documenting atrocities but also redefining journalism as a form of resistance and a reclaiming of ethical purpose.

Ana Maria Monjardino
Ana Maria Monjardino Published on: 4 Apr, 2025
How Media Drives Collective Adaptation During Natural Disasters in Oman

This paper highlights how Omani media, during times of natural disasters, focused on praising government efforts to improve its image, while neglecting the voices of victims and those affected by the cyclones. It also examines the media’s role in warning against and preventing future disasters.

Shaimaa Al-Eisai
Shaimaa Al-Eisai Published on: 31 Mar, 2025
Systematic Bias: How Western Media Framed the March 18 Massacre of Palestinians

On March 18, Israel launched a large-scale assault on Gaza, killing over 412 Palestinians and injuring more than 500, while Western media uncritically echoed Israel’s claim of “targeting Hamas.” Rather than exposing the massacre, coverage downplayed the death toll, delayed key facts, and framed the attacks as justified pressure on Hamas—further highlighting the double standard in valuing Palestinian lives.

Mei Shigenobu مي شيغينوبو
Mei Shigenobu Published on: 18 Mar, 2025
Misinformation in Syria: Natural Chaos or Organised Campaign?

Old videos inciting “sectarian strife,” statements taken out of context attacking Christians, scenes of heavy weaponry clashes in other countries, fabricated stories of fictitious detainees, and a huge amount of fake news that accompanied the fall of Bashar al-Assad’s regime: Is it the natural chaos of transition or a systematic campaign?

Farhat Khedr
Farhat Khedr Published on: 11 Mar, 2025
Trump and the Closure of USAID: A Candid Conversation on "Independent Media"

The impact of U.S. President Donald Trump's decision to halt foreign funding through the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) on Arab media platforms has largely gone undiscussed. Some of these platforms have consistently labelled themselves as "independent" despite being Western-funded. This article examines the reasons behind the failure of economic models for Western-funded institutions in the Arab world and explores the extent of their editorial independence.

Ahmad Abuhamad Published on: 9 Mar, 2025
The Sharp Contrast: How Israeli and Western Media Cover the War on Gaza

Despite being directly governed by Israeli policies, some Israeli media outlets critically report on their government’s actions and use accurate terminology, whereas Western media has shown complete bias, failing to be impartial in its coverage of Israel’s aggression in Gaza.

Faras Ghani Published on: 5 Mar, 2025
International Media Seek Gaza Access; What Do Palestinian Journalists Say?

As international media push for access to Gaza, Palestinian journalists—who have been the primary voices on the ground—criticize their Western counterparts for failing to acknowledge their contributions, amplify their reports, or support them as they risk their lives to document the war. They face systemic bias and exploitation, and continue to work under extreme conditions without proper recognition or support.

NILOFAR ABSAR
Nilofar Absar Published on: 26 Feb, 2025
Journalism and Artificial Intelligence: Who Controls the Narrative?

How did the conversation about using artificial intelligence in journalism become merely a "trend"? And can we say that much of the media discourse on AI’s potential remains broad and speculative rather than a tangible reality in newsrooms?

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 23 Feb, 2025
The Whispers of Resistance in Assad’s Reign

For more than a decade of the Syrian revolution, the former regime has employed various forms of intimidation against journalists—killing, interrogations, and forced displacement—all for a single purpose: silencing their voices. Mawadda Bahah hid behind pseudonyms and shifted her focus to environmental issues after a "brief session" at the Kafar Soussa branch of Syria’s intelligence agency.

Mawadah Bahah
Mawadah Bahah Published on: 18 Feb, 2025
Culture of silence: Journalism and mental health problems in Africa

The revealing yet underreported impact of mental health on African journalists is far-reaching. Many of them lack medical insurance, support, and counselling while covering sensitive topics or residing in conflicting, violent war zones, with some even considering suicide.

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 13 Feb, 2025
Tweets Aren’t News: Why Journalism Still Matters

Twitter, once key for real-time news, has become a battleground of misinformation and outrage, drowning out factual journalism. With major newspapers leaving, the challenge is to remind audiences that true news comes from credible sources, not the chaos of social media.

Ilya
Ilya U Topper Published on: 10 Feb, 2025
Will Meta Become a Platform for Disinformation and Conspiracy Theories?

Meta’s decision to abandon third-party fact-checking in favor of Community Notes aligns with Donald Trump’s long-standing criticisms of media scrutiny, raising concerns that the platform will fuel disinformation, conspiracy theories, and political polarization. With support from Elon Musk’s X, major social media platforms now lean toward a "Trumpian" stance, potentially weakening global fact-checking efforts and reshaping the online information landscape.

Arwa Kooli
Arwa Kooli Published on: 5 Feb, 2025
October 7: The Battle for Narratives and the Forgotten Roots of Palestine

What is the difference between October 6th and October 7th? How did the media distort the historical context and mislead the public? Why did some Arab media strip the genocidal war from its roots? Is there an agenda behind highlighting the Israel-Hamas duality in news coverage?

Said El Hajji
Said El Hajji Published on: 21 Jan, 2025
Challenges of Unequal Data Flow on Southern Narratives

The digital revolution has widened the gap between the Global South and the North. Beyond theories that attribute this disparity to the North's technological dominance, the article explores how national and local policies in the South shape and influence its narratives.

Hassan Obeid
Hassan Obeid Published on: 14 Jan, 2025
Decolonise How? Humanitarian Journalism is No Ordinary Journalism

Unlike most journalism, which involves explaining societies to themselves, war reporting and foreign correspondence explain the suffering of exoticised communities to audiences back home, often within a context of profound ignorance about these othered places. Humanitarian journalism seeks to counter this with empathetic storytelling that amplifies local voices and prioritises ethical representation.

Patrick Gathara
Patrick Gathara Published on: 8 Jan, 2025
Mastering Journalistic Storytelling: The Power of Media Practices

Narration in journalism thrives when it's grounded in fieldwork and direct engagement with the story. Its primary goal is to evoke impact and empathy, centering on the human experience. However, the Arab press has often shifted this focus, favoring office-based reporting over firsthand accounts, resulting in narratives that lack genuine substance.

AJR logo
Zainab Tarhini Published on: 7 Jan, 2025
I Resigned from CNN Over its Pro-Israel Bias

  Developing as a young journalist without jeopardizing your morals has become incredibly difficult.

Ana Maria Monjardino
Ana Maria Monjardino Published on: 2 Jan, 2025
Digital Colonialism: The Global South Facing Closed Screens

After the independence of the Maghreb countries, the old resistance fighters used to say that "colonialism left through the door only to return through the window," and now it is returning in new forms of dominance through the window of digital colonialism. This control is evident in the acquisition of major technological and media companies, while the South is still looking for an alternative.

Ahmad Radwan
Ahmad Radwan Published on: 31 Dec, 2024
Independent Syrian Journalism: From Revolution to Assad's Fall

Independent Syrian journalism played a pivotal role in exposing regime corruption and documenting war crimes during the 13-year revolution, despite immense risks to journalists, including imprisonment, assassination, and exile. Operating from abroad, these journalists pioneered investigative and open-source reporting, preserving evidence, and shaping narratives that challenged the Assad regime's propaganda.

Ahmad Haj Hamdo
Ahmad Haj Hamdo Published on: 17 Dec, 2024
Bolivia’s Mines and Radio: A Voice of the Global South Against Hegemony

Miners' radio stations in the heart of Bolivia's mining communities, played a crucial role in shaping communication within mining communities, contributing to social and political movements. These stations intersected with anarchist theatre, educational initiatives, and alternative media, addressing labour rights, minority groups, and imperialism.

Khaldoun Shami PhD
Khaldoun H. Shami Published on: 16 Dec, 2024