Al Jazeera Journalism Review

outside image
Delhi Police arrest Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Newsclick, Prabir Purkayastha, at his office on October 3, 2023 in New Delhi, India [Raj K Raj/Hindustan Times via Getty Images]

How the New York Times fuelled a crackdown on journalists in India

Vague reporting and a piece ‘laden with innuendo’ by the New York Times gave Indian authorities the excuse they needed to crack down on news website Newsclick

 

On the morning of October 3, New Delhi police raided the homes and offices of more than three dozen journalists and executives associated with NewsClick, a privately funded news portal, and arrested its editor, Prabir Purakayastha, and the head of the Human Rights department, Amit Chakraborty. 

The action came more than a month after the police in New Delhi registered a case against the portal, under India’s anti-terror law, the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act. The police charged the outlet and its executives of fomenting criminal conspiracy and funding terror activities in the country. 

The case followed an investigative report by the New York Times which alleged that Newsclick was part of a network of media outlets that received money from a business run by an American entrepreneur, Neville Roy Singham, with alleged links to the Chinese government, with the aim of promoting pro-China propaganda. Journalists close to the power corridors cited anonymous officials saying that the police action against Newsclick was prompted directly by the New York Times story, which had been published on August 5. 

NewsClick 1
The New York Times's investigation which was published on August 5, just two months before Indian authorities raided Newsclick in New Delhi

The story highlighted the role of the network in creating a shield around the Chinese government from criticism over its repression of Uyghur Muslims in Xinjiang region. But the Indian government has no love lost for Muslims, either in China or in India. The condition of Muslims in India under Modi is for everyone to see. News reports of  violence by police and Hindutva mobs against ordinary Muslims frequently dominate headlines in the country. 

The Chinese links, therefore, are seen by many as just an excuse. The real reason for the raids and arrests, critics say, is that Newsclick is one of only a few spaces left on the media scene in India that still platform critical journalism which aims to hold the government to account. This interpretation of events seems to have been substantiated by the fact that Newsclick journalists say they were asked questions about the platform’s coverage of the 2021 farmers’ protests and the 2019/2020 protests against a controversial citizenship law. 

The raids and arrests sparked renewed concerns about dwindling press freedom in the country as press freedom bodies issued statements condemning the police action. At the same time journalists and independent commentators also slammed New York Times for its shoddy and biassed reporting. 

 

New York Times should have done better 

While making a reference to Newsclick, the New York Times did not suggest that the portal had committed a crime or violated any laws. It did not go into detail to substantiate the claims  of Newsclick’s role in promoting the Chinese government’s propaganda. It said that the portal “sprinkled its coverage with Chinese government talking points” and mentioned an innocuous line from a random video report, as an example, which said: “China’s history continues to inspire the working classes.” 

NewsClick 2
The short passage mentioning Newsclick did not give any detail or context

The story should have either delved deeper to back up the claims against the Newsclick or made no reference to the portal at all.

The story did not quote Singham or any Newsclick executives on the matter. In fact, on October 17, the American entrepreneur issued a statement denying the allegations made in the NYT report and accused the American paper of running a “misleading and innuendo-laden hit” piece. He further alleged that the paper “intentionally chose not to publish all the factual rebuttals that I provided to them on July 22, 2023, prior to their publication date”. 

Given that it had chosen to name Newsclick in its article, the newspaper could have provided some context to explain the portal's reporting, its editorial positions and the stifling environment it operates in - it did none of these things.

When the New York Times report was published, NewsClick was already being hounded by the country’s investigative agencies on allegations of financial irregularities. 

The circumstances at the time should have been enough for the New York reporters and editors to be extra circumspect before publishing the piece. However, they failed to assess the potential impact the story could have on dwindling press freedoms in India despite being clearly warned of this when one of the authors of the story approached Kavita Krishnan, a prominent left-leaning Indian activist. 

She told them that their story could fuel the crackdown on free press in India. In her column for Indian News Website Scroll, Krishnan wrote that she explained to the NYT reporter that even though Newsclick might form a small part  of the story, its impact “would be outsized” in India. 

 

Swift fallout

As soon as the story came out, the fallout was swift. The story provided ballast to rightwing trolls and the pro-government media to intensify the smear campaign against Newsclick. The demonisation of Newsclick on social and mainstream media enabled the government to tighten its noose around the portal.  

Under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, press freedom has diminished in India. The 2023 Press Freedom Index by Reporters Without Borders (RSF) places India at 161 out of 180 countries. This is 11 slots lower than it was in 2022. 

Modi’s government has been accused of using repressive means to silence journalists. Right now, at least seven journalists are in jail - some held under anti-terror laws. The New York Times itself has published reports that explain how governments in many countries including India have used Israeli spyware Pegasus to attack the phones of  journalists and activists.

Within such a climate of fear for journalists, it is unfortunate to find that a story in one of the world’s most powerful newspapers has helped to worsen the crackdown on free press in the world's largest democracy.

Meer Faisal is an independent multimedia journalist based in New Delhi

 

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera Journalism Review’s editorial stance

 

More Articles

The Whispers of Resistance in Assad’s Reign

For more than a decade of the Syrian revolution, the former regime has employed various forms of intimidation against journalists—killing, interrogations, and forced displacement—all for a single purpose: silencing their voices. Mawadda Bahah hid behind pseudonyms and shifted her focus to environmental issues after a "brief session" at the Kafar Soussa branch of Syria’s intelligence agency.

Mawadah Bahah
Mawadah Bahah Published on: 18 Feb, 2025
Invisible Crisis: The Deteriorating Mental Health Among African Journalists

The revealing yet underreported impact of mental health on African journalists is far-reaching. Many of them lack medical insurance, support, and counselling while covering sensitive topics or residing in conflicting, violent war zones, with some even considering suicide.

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 13 Feb, 2025
Tweets Aren’t News: Why Journalism Still Matters

Twitter, once key for real-time news, has become a battleground of misinformation and outrage, drowning out factual journalism. With major newspapers leaving, the challenge is to remind audiences that true news comes from credible sources, not the chaos of social media.

Ilya
Ilya U Topper Published on: 10 Feb, 2025
Will Meta Become a Platform for Disinformation and Conspiracy Theories?

Meta’s decision to abandon third-party fact-checking in favor of Community Notes aligns with Donald Trump’s long-standing criticisms of media scrutiny, raising concerns that the platform will fuel disinformation, conspiracy theories, and political polarization. With support from Elon Musk’s X, major social media platforms now lean toward a "Trumpian" stance, potentially weakening global fact-checking efforts and reshaping the online information landscape.

Arwa Kooli
Arwa Kooli Published on: 5 Feb, 2025
October 7: The Battle for Narratives and the Forgotten Roots of Palestine

What is the difference between October 6th and October 7th? How did the media distort the historical context and mislead the public? Why did some Arab media strip the genocidal war from its roots? Is there an agenda behind highlighting the Israel-Hamas duality in news coverage?

Said El Hajji
Said El Hajji Published on: 21 Jan, 2025
Challenges of Unequal Data Flow on Southern Narratives

The digital revolution has widened the gap between the Global South and the North. Beyond theories that attribute this disparity to the North's technological dominance, the article explores how national and local policies in the South shape and influence its narratives.

Hassan Obeid
Hassan Obeid Published on: 14 Jan, 2025
Decolonise How? Humanitarian Journalism is No Ordinary Journalism

Unlike most journalism, which involves explaining societies to themselves, war reporting and foreign correspondence explain the suffering of exoticised communities to audiences back home, often within a context of profound ignorance about these othered places. Humanitarian journalism seeks to counter this with empathetic storytelling that amplifies local voices and prioritises ethical representation.

Patrick Gathara
Patrick Gathara Published on: 8 Jan, 2025
Mastering Journalistic Storytelling: The Power of Media Practices

Narration in journalism thrives when it's grounded in fieldwork and direct engagement with the story. Its primary goal is to evoke impact and empathy, centering on the human experience. However, the Arab press has often shifted this focus, favoring office-based reporting over firsthand accounts, resulting in narratives that lack genuine substance.

AJR logo
Zainab Tarhini Published on: 7 Jan, 2025
I Resigned from CNN Over its Pro-Israel Bias

  Developing as a young journalist without jeopardizing your morals has become incredibly difficult.

Ana Maria Monjardino
Ana Maria Monjardino Published on: 2 Jan, 2025
Digital Colonialism: The Global South Facing Closed Screens

After the independence of the Maghreb countries, the old resistance fighters used to say that "colonialism left through the door only to return through the window," and now it is returning in new forms of dominance through the window of digital colonialism. This control is evident in the acquisition of major technological and media companies, while the South is still looking for an alternative.

Ahmad Radwan
Ahmad Radwan Published on: 31 Dec, 2024
Independent Syrian Journalism: From Revolution to Assad's Fall

Independent Syrian journalism played a pivotal role in exposing regime corruption and documenting war crimes during the 13-year revolution, despite immense risks to journalists, including imprisonment, assassination, and exile. Operating from abroad, these journalists pioneered investigative and open-source reporting, preserving evidence, and shaping narratives that challenged the Assad regime's propaganda.

Ahmad Haj Hamdo
Ahmad Haj Hamdo Published on: 17 Dec, 2024
Bolivia’s Mines and Radio: A Voice of the Global South Against Hegemony

Miners' radio stations in the heart of Bolivia's mining communities, played a crucial role in shaping communication within mining communities, contributing to social and political movements. These stations intersected with anarchist theatre, educational initiatives, and alternative media, addressing labour rights, minority groups, and imperialism.

Khaldoun Shami PhD
Khaldoun H. Shami Published on: 16 Dec, 2024
How Does Misinformation Undermine Public Trust in Journalism?

Reports reveal a growing loss of trust in the media, driven by the extent of misinformation that undermines professional journalism's ability to influence public discourse. The platforms of misinformation, now supported by states and private entities during conflicts and wars, threaten to strip the profession of its core roles of accountability and oversight.

Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 13 Nov, 2024
Challenging the Narrative: Jeremy Scahill on the Need for Adversarial Journalism

Investigative journalist Jeremy Scahill calls for a revival of "adversarial journalism" to reinstate crucial professional and humanitarian values in mainstream Western media, especially regarding the coverage of the Gaza genocide.

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 10 Nov, 2024
Freedom of the Press in Jordan and Unconstitutional Interpretations

Since the approval of the Cybercrime Law in Jordan, freedom of opinion and expression has entered a troubling phase marked by the arrest of journalists and restrictions on media. Musab Shawabkeh offers a constitutional reading based on interpretations and rulings that uphold freedom of expression in a context where the country needs diverse opinions in the face of the Israeli ultra right wing politics.

Musab Shawabkeh
Musab Al Shawabkeh Published on: 8 Nov, 2024
Voting in a Time of Genocide

The upcoming U.S. presidential election occurs against the backdrop of the ongoing genocide in Gaza, with AJ Plus prioritising marginalised voices and critically analysing Western mainstream media narratives while highlighting the undemocratic aspects of the U.S. electoral system.

Tony Karon Published on: 22 Oct, 2024
Journalists Should Not Embrace the Artificial Intelligence Hype

What factors should journalists take into account while discussing the use of AI in the media?

Jorge Sagastume Muralles
Jorge Sagastume Published on: 16 Oct, 2024
A Year of Genocide and Bias: Western Media's Whitewashing of Israel's Ongoing War on Gaza

Major Western media outlets continue to prove that they are a party in the war of narratives, siding with the Israeli occupation. The article explains how these major Western media outlets are still refining their techniques of bias in favor of the occupation, even a year after the genocide in Palestine.

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 9 Oct, 2024
A Half-Truth is a Full Lie

Misinformation is rampant in modern conflicts, worsened by the internet and social media, where false news spreads easily. While news agencies aim to provide unbiased, fact-based reporting, their focus on brevity and hard facts often lacks the necessary context, leaving the public vulnerable to manipulation and unable to fully grasp the complexities of these issues.

Ilya
Ilya U Topper Published on: 30 Sep, 2024
Testimonies of the First Witness of the Sabra & Shatila Massacre

The Sabra and Shatila massacre in 1982 saw over 3,000 unarmed Palestinian refugees brutally killed by Phalangist militias under the facilitation of Israeli forces. As the first journalist to enter the camps, Japanese journalist Ryuichi Hirokawa provides a harrowing first-hand account of the atrocity amid a media blackout. His testimony highlights the power of bearing witness to a war crime and contrasts the past Israeli public outcry with today’s silence over the ongoing genocide in Gaza.

Mei Shigenobu مي شيغينوبو
Mei Shigenobu Published on: 18 Sep, 2024
Anonymous Sources in the New York Times... Covering the War with One Eye

The use of anonymous sources in journalism is considered, within professional and ethical standards, a “last option” for journalists. However, analysis of New York Times data reveals a persistent pattern in the use of “anonymity” to support specific narratives, especially Israeli narratives.

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 8 Sep, 2024
India and Pakistan; Journalists building Bridges for Understanding

Amid decades of tension, journalists from India and Pakistan are uniting to combat hostile narratives and highlight shared challenges. Through collaboration, they’re fostering understanding on pressing issues like climate change and healthcare, proving that empathy can transcend borders. Discover how initiatives like the Journalists' Exchange Programme are paving the way for peace journalism and a more nuanced narrative.

Safina
Safina Nabi Published on: 12 Aug, 2024
From TV Screens to YouTube: The Rise of Exiled Journalists in Pakistan

Pakistani journalists are leveraging YouTube to overcome censorship, connecting with global audiences, and redefining independent reporting in their homeland.

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 28 Jul, 2024
How AI Synthesised Media Shapes Voter Perception: India's Case in Point

The recent Indian elections witnessed the unprecedented use of generative AI, leading to a surge in misinformation and deepfakes. Political parties leveraged AI to create digital avatars of deceased leaders, Bollywood actors

Suvrat Arora
Suvrat Arora Published on: 12 Jun, 2024