Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Should foreign laborers in Oman have their own media outlets?

There are more than 2.5 million foreign workers living in the Sultanate of Oman, not counting those working illegally. In 2011, the government announced plans to nationalize the workforce and employ some 40,000 Omani citizens as part of political and administrative reforms following demonstrations across the country. But, this has not checked the growth of Oman’s Asian workforce, particularly in the construction and service sectors.

There is a paucity of official information about the origin countries of these workers, but sources suggest that the most common nationalities of workers are Bangladeshi, Indian, Pakistani and Filipino. Regardless of their nationalities however, the state is increasingly unable to absorb this ever-growing number of people and meet all their needs throughout their stay, even as the various challenges and dangers of non-integration in local society become greater and greater.

Why Asian minority media?

Official Omani statistics suggest that the “minorities” who make up the foreign workforce in Oman constitute approximately 45% of the total population. We might ask ourselves whether it is really appropriate to describe them as “minorities” when they represent almost half those living in Oman today. But the use of the term is justified –if somewhat journalistic – because of the obvious plurality of cultures and ways of life among the different groups included in this figure.

I have a long-standing interest in the relationship between the inhabitants of a wealthy, high-income region with high standards of living and those who arrive in Gulf airports every day seeking better economic conditions and wages that allow them some basic minimum of life. I am interested in how these workers are represented in the Gulf generally, and in Oman specifically, both in their representations as a societal group and them as individuals. This includes forming understandings of their growing numbers, as well as their immersion in our society, and how they are affected by new ways of living and their struggles with problems of language and integration.

At first glance, a journalist wanting to cover the issue of cultural integration of Asian minorities in Oman expects to adopt a narrative driven by personal testimonies and stories about the difficulties of adjusting to a new country and the increasingly challenging living conditions, especially given falling wages coupled with rising inflation. 

However, as soon as you start looking for voices and stories that support this idea, you run into a surprising wall of silence. Many refuse to talk about these problems as a result of common day-to-day anxieties – chief among them, the absence of a shared language between the journalist and the interviewee. They see all this as a natural and inevitable result of the immigrant experience. The expectation is the experience, hard as it is, will eventually lead to better living conditions in their home countries. 

But even those who believe that the issue is more than just language and media coverage of the immigrant experience, have to admit that the two dominant languages—English and Arabic—function as important linguistic mediums to convey media messaging.

According to Oliver Allan, the managing editor of the English edition of the Omani newspaper Atheer, Omani and Gulf media should not use Asian languages in their coverage. ‘The government performs certain basic tasks, like keeping consumers informed. It uses English, which is the global language. We have to take into account the fact that those who come here as laborers and who don’t speak English or Arabic well don’t stay here long-term like their compatriots with degrees do.”

But what about the basic need to provide newcomers with information about their new home and its laws? 

Allan suggests that this is the only case in which we should use Asian languages. The workers that arrive every day in the country need to familiarise themselves with the laws and sociocultural norms of the country and how to respect, preserve and coexist with them in a peaceful and orderly fashion. 

Jinesh Kiji, an Indian who has lived in Oman for two years and works in marketing, agrees that it is absolutely necessary to inform newcomers of labour laws and especially how to file complaints in case of  labor violations.

The struggles of many Asian migrants in Oman remain hidden because of their poor grasp of their basic rights or their fear of reporting abuses. “The media needs to get closer to them, given that they are new communities,” Kiji said. 

“The media should help keep people up to date on labour regulations and working environments in the country. Why not create social media groups for immigrants from our countries, like a Facebook group for discussion of issues we face in Oman? We might find a decent solution to the problems that face us immigrants here and an alternative to the role the government expects the media to play,” Kiji suggested.

Combatting social isolation

After extensive research, I found that only a few journalists support the creation of an Asian media in Oman. One of these supporters is Desmond Priyanka, a Sri Lankan who has been living in Oman for three years. “Our experiences have allowed us to get to know whole neighbourhoods in Oman that speak only Asian languages like Hindi or Baloch,” Priyanka said. According to him, this means that we should think seriously about the need for multilingual media including radio, television and newspapers.

However, a potential challenge for such multilingual projects would be a shortage of workers from these nationalities in the media sector, in addition to the Omani state’s lack of support for local media.

Potential Asian media outlets in Oman could focus on issues facing these workers. This includes “the continual problems that domestic workers face, workers’ rights in low-skilled professions, job loss and non-payment of wages. In addition, there is an opportunity to cover social and religious issues resulting from cultural difference, such as the establishment of places of worship for different religions, legalisation of extramarital sex and the freedom to practise religious rituals,” Priyanka added.

Allan, for his part, was against this idea, which he described as aimed at “penetrating the cultural identity of [Omani] society.” He agrees that “media will allow these workers to achieve a greater sense of community and better living standards by improving their relationship with the new country. But this could also represent a danger to society’s cultural identity and help the spread of foreign languages and behaviours unacceptable to individuals here.”

Most journalists and workers in Oman agree that media coverage of Asian workers’ issues should meet their basic needs. It should provide them with local news on the weather, traffic, exchange rates, the economy and other daily developments. Ultimately, it should create an environment which allows them to express their aspirations, needs, and daily problems, ensuring greater contact with the society they live in.

The social isolation of this growing demographic should be a source of public worry, regardless of the problem posed by the linguistic barrier. Priyanka notes that “we get daily news about our own countries from the internet. But what about the place that we live? There’s nothing wrong with Asian media being subject to constant oversight from the government. They should be subject to all of the same publication controls to strengthen them as media platforms for the thousands of Asians working in the country.”

*Picture: A shopkeeper waits for business in the al-Dhalam Souk on December 9, 2010 in Muscat Oman. (Mark Kolbe-Getty Images).

Related Articles

Why I’ve had to launch my own magazine about Pakistan

Western media is full of negative stereotypes about my birth country. My job as a diaspora journalist is to challenge those tired old tropes.

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 12 Oct, 2021
Will Zimbabwe’s journalists be harmed by new cyber laws? 

Zimbabwe’s Cybersecurity and Data Protection Bill aims to protect privacy and guard against child sexual abuse depicted online. But it could also seriously hamper a free press.

Derick M
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 28 Sep, 2021
Secrecy is journalism's deadliest foe

When journalists unquestioningly swallow the narrative put forward by governments in the name of 'secrecy', it serves no-one

Clive Stafford Smith
Clive Stafford Smith Published on: 12 Sep, 2021
Professional Integrity: The Cornerstone of Protection

Propaganda and censorship are as old as war itself, but that has generally been a struggle to control the story rather than targeting

Peter Greste Published on: 29 Jul, 2021
The West forms a new Arab “Imaginary”

Years ago, the Moroccan thinker Hassan Aourid published his book titled "The Refracted Mirror of the West". Among its major topics was his seeking for media intervention to shape a new public opinion. The article brought a detailed explanation of compatibility of media visions between the West and the Arab regimes' orientations after September 11, 2001 events.

A picture of the author, Hassan Aourid
Hassan Aourid Published on: 30 Jun, 2021
The Palestinian struggle to be seen in the media

Does the global media treat Palestinian lives as inherently less valuable?

A picture of the author, Abeer alNajjar
Abeer al-Najjar Published on: 30 May, 2021
In coverage of Palestine, biases and irresponsible journalism emerge

In the coverage of events in Jerusalem and Gaza, mainstream media outlets are failing to report on the situation fairly.

A picture of the author, William Christou.
William Christou Published on: 13 May, 2021
Journalism and sociology; uneasy bedfellows

Journalism and sociology cannot be at odds since they are based on the same principle, and they use the same tools to construct social analyses. Still, the two disciplines do not see eye to eye. The sociologist sees the journalist as superficial, while the journalist sees the sociologist as cloistered in an ivory tower.

A picture of the author, Mohammad Ahdad.
Mohammad Ahdad Published on: 10 May, 2021
Slow versus instant journalism: Is digital media the answer?

Digital media might be the answer to a question gripping the journalism industry: Slow or instant journalism?

The Al Jazeera Media Institute logo.
Muhammad Ahmed Published on: 25 Apr, 2021
Beyond objectivity: The rise of reformist news

The core mission of the news industry is telling viewers the day's events. But another core mission of journalism is to make the world a better place, which means going beyond the facts to change what’s wrong and defend what’s right. Those two missions are in conflict today.

A picture of the author, Mark Lee Hunter.
Mark Lee Hunter Published on: 23 Mar, 2021
Importing credibility: Why does foreign private media invest in the Arab media market?

Why are western media companies all of a sudden interested in opening channels in the Arab World?

A picture of the author, Ahmad Abu Hamad
Ahmad Abu Hamad Published on: 1 Mar, 2021
Foreign funding and orientalism: On the need for an organic journalist

When many North African countries achieved their independence, nationalists began to repeat a sentence of great importance: Colonization will leave out the door, only to come back through the window. The sentence has proved to be prescient, as colonization has come back through the gateway of media, with an orientalist view that detaches reality from its cultural, and socio-political contexts.

Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 28 Feb, 2021
Close up and personal

Can Arabs accurately report their own affairs? Can Muslims be reliable sources of objective information about their daily lives and historic changes? We from the Arab and Muslim world are rethinking the news.

Hamid Dabashi Published on: 15 Feb, 2021