Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Outside image
Police officers stand in front of transgender rights protesters at a protest in Melbourne, Australia on March 18, 2023 in this picture obtained from a social media video [Twitter @Aaroncre1/via Reuters]

Is the media responsible for the Auckland violence?

The media is failing to adhere to well-founded principles of journalism in its coverage of transgender issues. Violence is the result

 

Auckland, New Zealand, was rocked by violent protests at the weekend when women's rights activists on a tour called Let Women Speak arrived to hold a rally. 

The campaign group, led by the women’s rights activist, Posie Parker (real name Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull), has been touring Australia and New Zealand to give a platform to women who are worried about self-ID laws which allow people to change their legal sex without the requirement for medical treatment or diagnosis and, therefore, have access to spaces usually reserved for members of the opposite sex.

PP6

Keen-Minshull argues that self-ID places women and girls in danger because it removes all usual safeguarding in place for them, particularly in places like prisons, domestic violence shelters, changing rooms and public toilets. Effectively, if any man can self-ID as a woman, he will have unfettered access to those spaces.

Trans rights activists say that this line of argument is a “dog whistle” for what is actually hatred, transphobia and an assault on the rights of transgender people who just want to live their lives in peace in the gender they identify with.

But why would such a disagreement erupt into the sort of violence that was seen this weekend? One catalyst has undeniably been media coverage of transgender issues generally and the Let Women Speak tour in particular.

Keen-Minshull has been labelled “anti-trans”, and much of the media has reported her as such. Keen-Minshull says she is not anti-trans at all, and is merely speaking up for women’s rights which she sees as being eroded.

PP2

Amidst the backlash against the Let Women Speak tour have been accusations that Keen-Minshull is funded by white supremacist organisations. Indeed, when a white supremacist counter-protest group arrived at her rally in Melbourne, Australia, last week, for example, it was widely reported in the media that they had come to support her.

Despite this assertion being very far from proven as true - and Keen-Minshull herself stating she has no links to the group - on Sunday, the Guardian continued to report it as fact, writing: “An earlier appearance in Australia had been attended and supported by white supremacist groups, who marched the streets, repeatedly performing the Nazi salute.”

The same Guardian article was headlined: “Anti-trans activist Posie Parker ends New Zealand tour after chaotic protests at event”. Others, such as The Western Australian, joined in with this description.

PP1

It is far from clear that Keen-Minshull is, in fact, anything other than a women’s rights campaigner, so these headlines, describing her as “anti-trans” seems designed to inflame tensions between the two sides.

PP7

Another news organisation in New Zealand, NewsHub, reported that Keen-Minshull had “flashed a white supremacist symbol” with a hand gesture in a video - censored by them to avoid discomfort among viewers. However as the journalist, Andy Ngo, senior editor at The Post Millennial, demonstrated in a tweet, Keen-Minshull was merely fiddling with the zipper on her jacket.

The left-wing Western media has been fanning the flames of the transgender rights row for some time now. For example, rulings by major sporting bodies that transgender women should not compete in women’s events have widely been reported as transgender sports people being banned from competitive sports altogether - a false claim.

PP5

This sort of inaccurate reporting, as well as the general labelling of women’s rights groups as “anti trans” has almost certainly contributed to the anger and violence which has erupted over this issue.

While the left-wing media has been misreporting on this issue, some elements of the right-wing media have been stirring up outright hatred towards transgender people. Take this Fox News headline: “Axios: Co Shooting Suspect is Non-Binary”.

PP4

Whether or not one agrees that trans women should be allowed access to women’s spaces, sports and reserved positions is actually besides the point. Journalism should start and end with the facts and should never stray into promoting hate speech in any form.

The Ethical Journalism Network lays out five core values for journalism.

  1. Truth and accuracy
  2. Independence
  3. Fairness and impartiality
  4. Humanity
  5. Accountability

I can see at least three of these principles being flouted by media reporting on transgender issues.

Let’s take principle number 1, Truth and accuracy. As the Ethical Journalism Network states: “Journalists cannot always guarantee ‘truth’, but getting the facts right is the cardinal principle of journalism… When we cannot corroborate information, we should say so.” 

Coverage of the Let Women Speak tour in Australia and New Zealand by news outlets such as the Guardian, The West Australian and NewsHub, for example, clearly falls short of this principle with its labelling of a women’s rights activist as “anti-trans” and the assertion by some that she was supported by a white supremacist group. Neither of these things has been corroborated or shown to be true.

Similarly, news organisations reporting that transgender people have been “banned” from entering competitive sports is false. In the most recent move of this sort, World Athletics has banned transgender women (who are biologically male) from competing in the female category at international events.

PP4

They have not been banned from competing in their own sex class. The difference here is important - in one case, a grievous human rights abuse appears to have been committed against a vulnerable minority group - something that is bound to stir up anger and resentment if it were true. Headlines stating this clearly serve only to cause more division.

Indeed, this is a clear example of why the media must be absolutely accurate in its reporting of any issue. Inaccuracy can have terrible consequences.

PP8

The Guardian’s coverage also fails principle number 3 - Fairness and Impartiality. Of this, the Ethical Journalism Network states: “Most stories have at least two sides. While there is no obligation to present every side in every piece, stories should be balanced and add context... Impartial reporting builds trust and confidence.” It is very clear from their inflammatory reporting on this issue that the Guardian and others are not impartial at all.

In Principle number 4 - Humanity - the EJN states: “Journalists should do no harm. What we publish or broadcast may be hurtful, but we should be aware of the impact of our words and images on the lives of others.” 

To my mind, this principle includes only stating relevant information about people. Fox News flouts this by not just describing a shooter as “non-binary” (so what?), but making this the entire point of a headline. There is no reason to do this other than to make viewers feel negatively towards non-binary and transgender people.

The violence we have seen in New Zealand this weekend is very frightening. It is imperative that the media does its part not to inflame it further.

Nina Montagu-Smith is Editor of the Al Jazeera Journalism Review

 

More Articles

Has the Global South Benefited from the Digital Transformation?

Despite the promise of digital technologies to amplify voices and expand media reach in the Global South, structural barriers, such as political repression, technological dependency, and persistent digital divides, continue to limit their impact. Real progress requires not only technological adoption but also institutional reform, stronger journalistic capacity, and independent ethical frameworks to challenge dominant Western media narratives.

Al-Shafi Abtidon
Al-Shafi Abtidon Published on: 18 Mar, 2026
Missiles Made of Words: How Western Media Narratives Shape the Iran–Israel–US Conflict

Western media coverage of the Iran–Israel–US conflict often functions as a weapon of war, using selective language that frames US and Israeli strikes as “self-defence” while depicting Iranian actions as "provocation". This linguistic framing normalises civilian casualties and helps manufacture public consent for military aggression by dehumanising certain populations.

Muqeet Mohammed Shah
Muqeet Mohammed Shah, Ifrah Khalil Kawa Published on: 14 Mar, 2026
How the Ethiopian Civil War Unleashed a Lethal Media Crackdown

There has been a widening crackdown on the media in Ethiopia since war erupted between the central government and Tigray’s regional authorities in 2020, and the pressure appears set to intensify as the country prepares for general elections in June.

Nalova Akua
Nalova Akua Published on: 9 Mar, 2026
Are Netanyahu's and Trump’s Speeches Shaping Western Media Framing?

As political speeches framed the 2026 U.S.–Israeli attack on Iran, segments of Western media echoed their language and narratives, illustrating how strategic rhetoric and news framing can shape public opinion and legitimise military action.

Shaimaa Al-Eisai
Shaimaa Al-Eisai Published on: 6 Mar, 2026
Journalism in Gaza… A Race Against the Train of Genocide

In the following account, Amira Nassar presents a narrative filled with intricate detail, intimate exchanges, and an unyielding struggle over the meaning of writing amid slaughter and starvation. Part of The Journalism Review’s documentary project recording the testimonies of journalists in Palestine and the Gaza Strip during the ongoing genocide, it stands as a testament against oblivion and the machinery of extermination.

Amira Nassar
Amira Nassar Published on: 27 Feb, 2026
Kukurigo: Revolutionising news in Zimbabwe's WhatsApp era

The emergence of Kukurigo during Zimbabwe’s 2018 elections marked a turning point for digital journalism, transforming WhatsApp from a hub for misinformation into a vital platform for verified news. By leveraging the app’s low data costs, this grassroots initiative bridged the information gap for under-resourced communities, establishing a new model for media credibility and public service within an unstable political landscape.

Enock Muchinjo
Enock Muchinjo Published on: 19 Feb, 2026
The Epstein Files and the Art of Drowning the Truth

The mass release of millions of files related to Jeffrey Epstein serves as a metaphor for a wider crisis of the digital age: an overabundance of information that obscures rather than illuminates the truth. In an era where data floods replace traditional censorship, citizens risk becoming less informed, underscoring the vital role of professional journalism in filtering noise into meaningful knowledge.

Ilya إيليا توبر 
Ilya U Topper Published on: 12 Feb, 2026
Reporting the Spectacle: Myanmar’s Manufactured Elections

Myanmar’s recent elections posed a profound challenge for journalists, who were forced to navigate between exposing a sham process and inadvertently legitimising it. With media repression intensifying, reporting became an act of resistance against the junta’s effort to control information and silence independent voices.

Annie Zaman
Annie Zaman Published on: 7 Feb, 2026
Public Hostility Toward Legacy Media in Bangladesh

The December 2025 arson attacks on Prothom Alo and The Daily Star marked a turning point for journalism in Bangladesh. As public anger replaces state control as the primary threat, reporters are reassessing personal safety, editorial judgement, and professional credibility in a political transition where journalism itself is increasingly treated as an enemy.

Arsalan Bukhari, an independent journalist based in India
Arsalan Bukhari Published on: 4 Feb, 2026
Migration Issues and the Framing Dilemma in Western Media

How does the Western press shape the migration narrative? Which journalistic frames dominate its coverage? And is reporting on anti-immigration protests neutral or ideologically charged? This analysis examines how segments of Western media echo far-right rhetoric, reinforcing xenophobic discourse through selective framing, language, and imagery.

Salma Saqr
Salma Saqr Published on: 31 Jan, 2026
From News Reporting to Documentation: Practical Lessons from Covering the War on Gaza

From the very first moment of the genocidal war waged by Israel on Gaza, Al Jazeera correspondent Hisham Zaqout has been a witness to hunger, devastation, war crimes, and the assassination of his colleagues in the field. It is a battle for survival and documentation, one that goes beyond mere coverage and daily reporting.

Hisham Zakkout Published on: 26 Jan, 2026
Investigating the Assassination of My Own Father

As a journalist, reporting on the murder of my father meant answering questions about my own position as an objective observer.

Diana López Zuleta
Diana López Zuleta Published on: 16 Jan, 2026
What Image of Gaza Will the World Remember?

Will the story of Gaza be reduced to official statements that categorise the Palestinian as a "threat"? Or to images of the victims that flood the digital space? And how can the media be transformed into a tool for reinforcing collective memory and the struggle over narratives?

Hassan Obeid
Hasan Obaid Published on: 13 Jan, 2026
Bridging the AI Divide in Arab Newsrooms

AI is reshaping Arab journalism in ways that entrench power rather than distribute it, as under-resourced MENA newsrooms are pushed deeper into dependency and marginalisation, while wealthy, tech-aligned media actors consolidate narrative control through infrastructure they alone can afford and govern.

Sara Ait Khorsa
Sara Ait Khorsa Published on: 10 Jan, 2026
Generative AI in Journalism and Journalism Education: Promise, Peril, and the Global North–South Divide

Generative AI is transforming journalism and journalism education, but this article shows that its benefits are unevenly distributed, often reinforcing Global North–South inequalities while simultaneously boosting efficiency, undermining critical thinking, and deepening precarity in newsrooms and classrooms.

Carolyne Lunga
Carolyne Lunga Published on: 2 Jan, 2026
Intifada 2.0: Palestinian Digital Journalism from Uprising to Genocide

From underground newsletters during the Intifadas to livestreams from Gaza, Palestinian journalism has evolved into a decentralised digital practice of witnessing under occupation. This article examines how citizen journalists, fixers and freelancers have not only filled gaps left by international media, but fundamentally transformed how Palestine is reported, remembered and understood.

Zina Q.
Zina Q. Published on: 24 Dec, 2025
How Can Journalism Make the Climate Crisis a People’s Issue?

Between the import of Western concepts and terminology that often fail to reflect the Arab context, and the denial of the climate crisis, or the inability to communicate it in clear, accessible terms, journalism plays a vital role in informing the public and revealing how climate change directly affects the fabric of daily life in the Arab world.

Bana Salama
Bana Salama Published on: 19 Dec, 2025
Inside Vietnam’s Disinformation Machine and the Journalists Exposing It from Exile

Vietnam’s tightly controlled media environment relies on narrative distortion, selective omission, and propaganda to manage politically sensitive news. Exiled journalists and overseas outlets have become essential in exposing these practices, documenting forced confessions and smear campaigns, and preserving access to information that would otherwise remain hidden.

AJR Contributor Published on: 15 Dec, 2025
What It Means to Be an Investigative Journalist Today

A few weeks ago, Carla Bruni, wife of former French president Nicolas Sarkozy, was seen removing the Mediapart logo from view. The moment became a symbol of a major victory for investigative journalism, after the platform exposed Gaddafi’s financing of Sarkozy’s election campaign, leading to his prison conviction. In this article, Edwy Plenel, founder of Mediapart and one of the most prominent figures in global investigative journalism, reflects on a central question: what does it mean to be an investigative journalist today?

Edwy Plenel
Edwy Plenel Published on: 27 Nov, 2025
In-Depth and Longform Journalism in the AI Era: Revival or Obsolescence?

Can artificial intelligence tools help promote and expand the reach of longform journalism, still followed by a significant audience, or will they accelerate its decline? This article examines the leading AI tools reshaping the media landscape and explores the emerging opportunities they present for longform journalism, particularly in areas such as search and content discovery.

. سعيد ولفقير. كاتب وصحافي مغربي. ساهم واشتغل مع عددٍ من المنصات العربية منذ أواخر عام 2014.Said Oulfakir. Moroccan writer and journalist. He has contributed to and worked with a number of Arab media platforms since late 2014.
Said Oulfakir Published on: 24 Nov, 2025
Leaked BBC Memo: What Does the Crisis Reveal?

How Should We Interpret the Leak of the “BBC Memo” on Editorial Standards? Can we truly believe that the section concerning U.S. President Donald Trump was the sole reason behind the wave of resignations at the top of the British broadcaster? Or is it more accurately seen as part of a broader attempt to seize control over editorial decision-making? And to what extent can the pressure on newsrooms be attributed to the influence of the Zionist lobby?

 Mohammed Abuarqoub. Journalist, trainer, and researcher specializing in media affairs. He holds a PhD in Communication Philosophy from Regent University in the United States.محمد أبو عرقوب صحفي ومدرّب وباحث متخصص في شؤون الإعلام، حاصل على درجة الدكتوراه في فلسفة الاتّصال من جامعة ريجينت بالولايات المتحدة الأمريكية.
Mohammed Abuarqoub Published on: 20 Nov, 2025
Crisis of Credibility: How the Anglo-American Journalism Model Failed the World

Despite an unprecedented global flood of information, journalism remains strikingly impotent in confronting systemic crises—largely because the dominant Anglo-American model, shaped by commercial imperatives and capitalist allegiances, is structurally incapable of pursuing truth over power or effecting meaningful change. This critique calls for dismantling journalism’s subordination to market logic and imagining alternative models rooted in political, literary, and truth-driven commitments beyond the confines of capitalist production.

Imran Muzaffar
Imran Muzaffar, Aliya Bashir, Syed Aadil Hussain Published on: 14 Nov, 2025
Why Has Arab Cultural Journalism Weakened in the Third Millennium?

The crisis of cultural journalism in the Arab world reflects a deeper decline in the broader cultural and moral project, as well as the collapse of education and the erosion of human development. Yet this overarching diagnosis cannot excuse the lack of professional training and the poor standards of cultural content production within newsrooms.

Fakhri Saleh
Fakhri Saleh Published on: 10 Nov, 2025
Podcasters, content creators and influencers are not journalists. Are they?

Are podcasters, content creators, and influencers really journalists, or has the word 'journalist' been stretched so thin that it now covers anyone holding a microphone and an opinion? If there is a difference, where does it sit? Is it in method, mission, accountability, or something else? And in a media landscape built on noise, how do we separate a journalist from someone who produces content for clicks, followers or sponsors

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 7 Nov, 2025