Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Outside image
Police officers stand in front of transgender rights protesters at a protest in Melbourne, Australia on March 18, 2023 in this picture obtained from a social media video [Twitter @Aaroncre1/via Reuters]

Is the media responsible for the Auckland violence?

The media is failing to adhere to well-founded principles of journalism in its coverage of transgender issues. Violence is the result

 

Auckland, New Zealand, was rocked by violent protests at the weekend when women's rights activists on a tour called Let Women Speak arrived to hold a rally. 

The campaign group, led by the women’s rights activist, Posie Parker (real name Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull), has been touring Australia and New Zealand to give a platform to women who are worried about self-ID laws which allow people to change their legal sex without the requirement for medical treatment or diagnosis and, therefore, have access to spaces usually reserved for members of the opposite sex.

PP6

Keen-Minshull argues that self-ID places women and girls in danger because it removes all usual safeguarding in place for them, particularly in places like prisons, domestic violence shelters, changing rooms and public toilets. Effectively, if any man can self-ID as a woman, he will have unfettered access to those spaces.

Trans rights activists say that this line of argument is a “dog whistle” for what is actually hatred, transphobia and an assault on the rights of transgender people who just want to live their lives in peace in the gender they identify with.

But why would such a disagreement erupt into the sort of violence that was seen this weekend? One catalyst has undeniably been media coverage of transgender issues generally and the Let Women Speak tour in particular.

Keen-Minshull has been labelled “anti-trans”, and much of the media has reported her as such. Keen-Minshull says she is not anti-trans at all, and is merely speaking up for women’s rights which she sees as being eroded.

PP2

Amidst the backlash against the Let Women Speak tour have been accusations that Keen-Minshull is funded by white supremacist organisations. Indeed, when a white supremacist counter-protest group arrived at her rally in Melbourne, Australia, last week, for example, it was widely reported in the media that they had come to support her.

Despite this assertion being very far from proven as true - and Keen-Minshull herself stating she has no links to the group - on Sunday, the Guardian continued to report it as fact, writing: “An earlier appearance in Australia had been attended and supported by white supremacist groups, who marched the streets, repeatedly performing the Nazi salute.”

The same Guardian article was headlined: “Anti-trans activist Posie Parker ends New Zealand tour after chaotic protests at event”. Others, such as The Western Australian, joined in with this description.

PP1

It is far from clear that Keen-Minshull is, in fact, anything other than a women’s rights campaigner, so these headlines, describing her as “anti-trans” seems designed to inflame tensions between the two sides.

PP7

Another news organisation in New Zealand, NewsHub, reported that Keen-Minshull had “flashed a white supremacist symbol” with a hand gesture in a video - censored by them to avoid discomfort among viewers. However as the journalist, Andy Ngo, senior editor at The Post Millennial, demonstrated in a tweet, Keen-Minshull was merely fiddling with the zipper on her jacket.

The left-wing Western media has been fanning the flames of the transgender rights row for some time now. For example, rulings by major sporting bodies that transgender women should not compete in women’s events have widely been reported as transgender sports people being banned from competitive sports altogether - a false claim.

PP5

This sort of inaccurate reporting, as well as the general labelling of women’s rights groups as “anti trans” has almost certainly contributed to the anger and violence which has erupted over this issue.

While the left-wing media has been misreporting on this issue, some elements of the right-wing media have been stirring up outright hatred towards transgender people. Take this Fox News headline: “Axios: Co Shooting Suspect is Non-Binary”.

PP4

Whether or not one agrees that trans women should be allowed access to women’s spaces, sports and reserved positions is actually besides the point. Journalism should start and end with the facts and should never stray into promoting hate speech in any form.

The Ethical Journalism Network lays out five core values for journalism.

  1. Truth and accuracy
  2. Independence
  3. Fairness and impartiality
  4. Humanity
  5. Accountability

I can see at least three of these principles being flouted by media reporting on transgender issues.

Let’s take principle number 1, Truth and accuracy. As the Ethical Journalism Network states: “Journalists cannot always guarantee ‘truth’, but getting the facts right is the cardinal principle of journalism… When we cannot corroborate information, we should say so.” 

Coverage of the Let Women Speak tour in Australia and New Zealand by news outlets such as the Guardian, The West Australian and NewsHub, for example, clearly falls short of this principle with its labelling of a women’s rights activist as “anti-trans” and the assertion by some that she was supported by a white supremacist group. Neither of these things has been corroborated or shown to be true.

Similarly, news organisations reporting that transgender people have been “banned” from entering competitive sports is false. In the most recent move of this sort, World Athletics has banned transgender women (who are biologically male) from competing in the female category at international events.

PP4

They have not been banned from competing in their own sex class. The difference here is important - in one case, a grievous human rights abuse appears to have been committed against a vulnerable minority group - something that is bound to stir up anger and resentment if it were true. Headlines stating this clearly serve only to cause more division.

Indeed, this is a clear example of why the media must be absolutely accurate in its reporting of any issue. Inaccuracy can have terrible consequences.

PP8

The Guardian’s coverage also fails principle number 3 - Fairness and Impartiality. Of this, the Ethical Journalism Network states: “Most stories have at least two sides. While there is no obligation to present every side in every piece, stories should be balanced and add context... Impartial reporting builds trust and confidence.” It is very clear from their inflammatory reporting on this issue that the Guardian and others are not impartial at all.

In Principle number 4 - Humanity - the EJN states: “Journalists should do no harm. What we publish or broadcast may be hurtful, but we should be aware of the impact of our words and images on the lives of others.” 

To my mind, this principle includes only stating relevant information about people. Fox News flouts this by not just describing a shooter as “non-binary” (so what?), but making this the entire point of a headline. There is no reason to do this other than to make viewers feel negatively towards non-binary and transgender people.

The violence we have seen in New Zealand this weekend is very frightening. It is imperative that the media does its part not to inflame it further.

Nina Montagu-Smith is Editor of the Al Jazeera Journalism Review

 

More Articles

How Does Misinformation Undermine Public Trust in Journalism?

Reports reveal a growing loss of trust in the media, driven by the extent of misinformation that undermines professional journalism's ability to influence public discourse. The platforms of misinformation, now supported by states and private entities during conflicts and wars, threaten to strip the profession of its core roles of accountability and oversight.

Muhammad Khamaiseh 1
Muhammad Khamaiseh Published on: 13 Nov, 2024
Challenging the Narrative: Jeremy Scahill on the Need for Adversarial Journalism

Investigative journalist Jeremy Scahill calls for a revival of "adversarial journalism" to reinstate crucial professional and humanitarian values in mainstream Western media, especially regarding the coverage of the Gaza genocide.

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 10 Nov, 2024
Freedom of the Press in Jordan and Unconstitutional Interpretations

Since the approval of the Cybercrime Law in Jordan, freedom of opinion and expression has entered a troubling phase marked by the arrest of journalists and restrictions on media. Musab Shawabkeh offers a constitutional reading based on interpretations and rulings that uphold freedom of expression in a context where the country needs diverse opinions in the face of the Israeli ultra right wing politics.

Musab Shawabkeh
Musab Al Shawabkeh Published on: 8 Nov, 2024
Voting in a Time of Genocide

The upcoming U.S. presidential election occurs against the backdrop of the ongoing genocide in Gaza, with AJ Plus prioritising marginalised voices and critically analysing Western mainstream media narratives while highlighting the undemocratic aspects of the U.S. electoral system.

Tony Karon Published on: 22 Oct, 2024
Journalists Should Not Embrace the Artificial Intelligence Hype

What factors should journalists take into account while discussing the use of AI in the media?

Jorge Sagastume Muralles
Jorge Sagastume Published on: 16 Oct, 2024
A Year of Genocide and Bias: Western Media's Whitewashing of Israel's Ongoing War on Gaza

Major Western media outlets continue to prove that they are a party in the war of narratives, siding with the Israeli occupation. The article explains how these major Western media outlets are still refining their techniques of bias in favor of the occupation, even a year after the genocide in Palestine.

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 9 Oct, 2024
A Half-Truth is a Full Lie

Misinformation is rampant in modern conflicts, worsened by the internet and social media, where false news spreads easily. While news agencies aim to provide unbiased, fact-based reporting, their focus on brevity and hard facts often lacks the necessary context, leaving the public vulnerable to manipulation and unable to fully grasp the complexities of these issues.

Ilya
Ilya U Topper Published on: 30 Sep, 2024
Testimonies of the First Witness of the Sabra & Shatila Massacre

The Sabra and Shatila massacre in 1982 saw over 3,000 unarmed Palestinian refugees brutally killed by Phalangist militias under the facilitation of Israeli forces. As the first journalist to enter the camps, Japanese journalist Ryuichi Hirokawa provides a harrowing first-hand account of the atrocity amid a media blackout. His testimony highlights the power of bearing witness to a war crime and contrasts the past Israeli public outcry with today’s silence over the ongoing genocide in Gaza.

Mei Shigenobu مي شيغينوبو
Mei Shigenobu Published on: 18 Sep, 2024
Anonymous Sources in the New York Times... Covering the War with One Eye

The use of anonymous sources in journalism is considered, within professional and ethical standards, a “last option” for journalists. However, analysis of New York Times data reveals a persistent pattern in the use of “anonymity” to support specific narratives, especially Israeli narratives.

Mohammad Zeidan
Mohammad Zeidan Published on: 8 Sep, 2024
India and Pakistan; Journalists building Bridges for Understanding

Amid decades of tension, journalists from India and Pakistan are uniting to combat hostile narratives and highlight shared challenges. Through collaboration, they’re fostering understanding on pressing issues like climate change and healthcare, proving that empathy can transcend borders. Discover how initiatives like the Journalists' Exchange Programme are paving the way for peace journalism and a more nuanced narrative.

Safina
Safina Nabi Published on: 12 Aug, 2024
From TV Screens to YouTube: The Rise of Exiled Journalists in Pakistan

Pakistani journalists are leveraging YouTube to overcome censorship, connecting with global audiences, and redefining independent reporting in their homeland.

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 28 Jul, 2024
How AI Synthesised Media Shapes Voter Perception: India's Case in Point

The recent Indian elections witnessed the unprecedented use of generative AI, leading to a surge in misinformation and deepfakes. Political parties leveraged AI to create digital avatars of deceased leaders, Bollywood actors

Suvrat Arora
Suvrat Arora Published on: 12 Jun, 2024
The Rise of Podcasting: How Digital Audio Is Revolutionising Journalism

In this age of digital transformation and media convergence, podcasts stand out as a testament to the enduring power of journalism—a medium that transcends borders, sparks conversations, and brings the world closer together.

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 6 Jun, 2024
Under Fire: The Perilous Reality for Journalists in Gaza's War Zone

Journalists lack safety equipment and legal protection, highlighting the challenges faced by journalists in Gaza. While Israel denies responsibility for targeting journalists, the lack of international intervention leaves journalists in Gaza exposed to daily danger.

Linda Shalash
Linda Shalash Published on: 9 May, 2024
Your Words Are Your Weapon — You Are a Soldier in a Propaganda War

Narrative warfare and the role of journalists in it is immense; the context of the conflict, the battleground has shifted to the realm of narratives, where journalists play a decisive role in shaping the narrative.

Ilya
Ilya U Topper Published on: 21 Apr, 2024
The Privilege and Burden of Conflict Reporting in Nigeria: Navigating the Emotional Toll

The internal struggle and moral dilemmas faced by a conflict reporter, as they grapple with the overwhelming nature of the tragedies they witness and the sense of helplessness in the face of such immense suffering. It ultimately underscores the vital role of conflict journalism in preserving historical memory and giving a voice to the voiceless.

Hauwa Shaffii Nuhu
Hauwa Shaffii Nuhu Published on: 17 Apr, 2024
Journalism in chains in Cameroon

Investigative journalists in Cameroon sometimes use treacherous means to navigate the numerous challenges that hamper the practice of their profession: the absence of the Freedom of Information Act, the criminalisation of press offenses, and the scare of the overly-broad anti-terrorism law.

Nalova Akua
Nalova Akua Published on: 12 Apr, 2024
The Perils of Journalism and the Rise of Citizen Media in Southeast Asia

Southeast Asia's media landscape is grim, with low rankings for internet and press freedom across the region. While citizen journalism has risen to fill the gaps, journalists - both professional and citizen - face significant risks due to government crackdowns and the collusion between tech companies and authorities to enable censorship and surveillance.

AJR Contributor Published on: 6 Apr, 2024
Orientalism, Imperialism and The Western Coverage of Palestine

Western mainstream media biases and defence of the Israeli narrative are connected to orientalism, racism, and imperialism, serving the interests of Western ruling political and economic elites. However, it is being challenged by global movements aiming to shed light on the realities of the conflict and express solidarity with the Palestinian population.

Joseph Daher
Joseph Daher Published on: 1 Apr, 2024
Ethical Dilemmas of Photo Editing in Media: Lessons from Kate Middleton’s Photo Controversy

Photoshop—an intelligent digital tool celebrated for enhancing the visual appearance of photographs—is a double-edged sword. While it has the power to transform and refine images, it also skillfully blurs the line between reality and fiction, challenging the legitimacy of journalistic integrity and the credibility of news media.

Anam Hussain
Anam Hussain Published on: 26 Mar, 2024
Breaking Barriers: The Rise of Citizen Journalists in India's Fight for Media Inclusion

Grassroots journalists from marginalized communities in India, including Dalits and Muslims, are challenging mainstream media narratives and bringing attention to underreported issues through digital outlets like The Mooknayak.

Hanan Zaffa
Hanan Zaffar, Jyoti Thakur Published on: 3 Mar, 2024
Silenced Voices and Digital Resilience: The Case of Quds Network

Unrecognized journalists in conflict zones face serious risks to their safety and lack of support. The Quds Network, a Palestinian media outlet, has been targeted and censored, but they continue to report on the ground in Gaza. Recognition and support for independent journalists are crucial.

Yousef Abu Watfe يوسف أبو وطفة
Yousef Abu Watfeh Published on: 21 Feb, 2024
Artificial Intelligence's Potentials and Challenges in the African Media Landscape

How has the proliferation of Artificial Intelligence impacted newsroom operations, job security and regulation in the African media landscape? And how are journalists in Africa adapting to these changes?

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on: 18 Feb, 2024
Media Monopoly in Brazil: How Dominant Media Houses Control the Narrative and Stifle Criticism of Israel

An in-depth analysis exploring the concentration of media ownership in Brazil by large companies, and how this shapes public and political narratives, particularly by suppressing criticism of Israel.