Al Jazeera Journalism Review

A user views the Xinhua News Agency (@XHNews) account on X—displaying an "Account withheld" notice—in Guwahati, India, following the Indian government's ban on the news agency (May 17, 2025 / Photo by Hafiz Ahmed).
A user views the Xinhua News Agency (@XHNews) account on X—displaying an "Account withheld" notice—in Guwahati, India, following the Indian government's ban on the news agency (May 17, 2025 / Photo by Hafiz Ahmed).

When Journalism Disappears: How Social Media Takedowns Are Reshaping What the World Can See

Governments do not need to shut down a newsroom to silence its reporting: repeated social media takedowns can sever its access to audiences, deprive journalists of sources and evidence, and leave gaps in the historical record. 

 

 

Srinagar, India — When a journalism post disappears from a social media platform within hours of publication, what disappears is not simply a headline, a link or a piece of content. It can also mean the loss of information from the places where audiences discover news, journalists find stories and public conversations develop. In some cases, it can remove testimony, images, video and context that may later become part of the historical record. 

For journalists, the consequences can extend beyond the immediate loss of an audience. As social media increasingly becomes part of the infrastructure through which journalism is distributed and discovered, repeated removals and restrictions can shape what journalists are able to see, research and report. At scale, they can create gaps in the information available to both journalists and the public, even when a government has not formally banned a news organisation. 

For a 21-year-old freelance journalist from Kashmir, social media is more than a place to publish his work. It is a window to events and reporting beyond his immediate surroundings. He has requested anonymity, fearing that speaking publicly about government-ordered content removals could have serious consequences for both him and his work. 

“For young journalists who rely on social media to discover stories, follow conflicts and understand what is happening across borders, government-ordered takedowns and restrictions can leave us with a filtered view of the world,” he says. 

For journalists beginning their careers, the loss can mean more than a missing post or video. If important reporting disappears from the platforms where young reporters discover news, they can lose access to context, perspectives, sources and opportunities to understand an issue before reporting on it themselves. 

“It’s not just about what is taken down. It is also about what young journalists never get to see. It can create an information blackout, not just for journalists but for the public as well,” he says. 

It’s not just about what is taken down. It is also about what young journalists never get to see. It can create an information blackout, not just for journalists but for the public as well 

 

When journalism becomes harder to find 

India provides one example of how this broader problem plays out. India issued nearly 195,000 government blocking orders to social media platforms between March and July 2026, according to report by The Indian Express. 

Government takedown requests and platform restrictions have increasingly shaped what journalists and independent media organisations can publish and circulate online. But the implications extend beyond India, as journalists in different countries face decisions by governments and technology platforms that can determine whether their reporting remains visible. 

Pragya Singh, a journalist at The Wire, an independent Indian news platform, says that when journalism is removed from the platforms where audiences get their news, the impact goes beyond losing a post. It can amount to “censorship”, cutting off reporting from the people it was intended to reach. 

When that material disappears, journalists can lose not only published reporting but also leads, sources and evidence that could inform future work. 

“Social media increasingly drives readership and viewership. When journalists’ work is removed from these platforms, they are effectively denied the opportunity for their reporting to be read, discussed and debated,” she says. 

Her own experience illustrates how quickly that loss can occur. The Wire published a story by Singh featuring three people from Kashmir who had suffered pellet-gun injuries during earlier protest uprisings in Kashmir. The story documented their experiences alongside the use of pellet guns during recent protests in Delhi, giving survivors an opportunity to speak about the physical and social consequences of their injuries and how those injuries affected their families. 

Within minutes of publication, the story was removed from both Instagram and Facebook. 

“My immediate reaction to the removal of my news article was one of surprise and shock, followed by the question: why?” she says. 

The notice The Wire received said the content had been restricted “through an automated system” implemented pursuant to legal requirements under India’s information technology guidelines. 

For Singh, the explanation raises a broader question about how journalism is assessed online. If automated systems make decisions based on keywords or other signals, she questions whether the journalism itself is being understood before it is removed. 

“Journalists work very hard. Their organisations put in a lot of effort. Their labor cannot be treated so casually,” she says. 

The case points to the growing influence of automated systems and government requests over what journalism remains visible to the public. 

Large-scale content removals can create information gaps or “information blackouts” even when governments do not formally ban news organisations. This is especially true in situations where the information ecosystem is heavily controlled and the only source of information available is through people or journalists reporting from the ground. 

 

A global information problem 

The concern over automated systems and government requests is part of a broader global debate over who determines what remains visible online. 

Freedom House's Freedom on the Net 2025 found that global internet freedom declined for the 15th consecutive year. Of the 72 countries assessed, conditions deteriorated in 28, while 17 registered overall gains. The report describes an online environment increasingly shaped by censorship, legal measures and pressure on digital platforms, while highlighting the growing use of online controls to influence information and public discourse. 

For journalism, the significance of these restrictions goes beyond whether a particular post violates a platform's rules. It is also about who gets to decide what information remains available, how transparent those decisions are and whether journalists and audiences have meaningful ways to challenge them. 

Marwa Fatafta, MENA Policy and Advocacy Director at Access Now, an international non-profit organisation focused on digital rights and civil liberties, says platform censorship directly undermines journalists who rely on social platforms to publish their reporting. The impact is especially acute for independent and citizen journalists operating under oppressive regimes where traditional media is state-controlled or even barred. Ultimately, censoring journalists starves the public of critical news on the very platforms they rely on most to access information. 

Fatafta says large-scale content removals can create information gaps or “information blackouts” even when governments do not formally ban news organisations. This is especially true in situations where the information ecosystem is heavily controlled and the only source of information available is through people or journalists reporting from the ground. 

“We see states resorting to draconian laws, such as cybercrime or anti-terrorism legislations, to order platforms to censor human rights defenders, journalists, and civil society organizations with little resistance,” Fatafta says. 

The issue is therefore not limited to traditional censorship, in which a government directly shuts down a newspaper or television station. It can also emerge through platform restrictions, legal requests, automated moderation and the removal of individual pieces of reporting. 

Once a government can ask a platform to take something down and get compliance without a court order or any real check on the request, censorship moves out of the legal system and into a backroom deal between an official and a company that has every incentive to say yes. 

American Kuwaiti journalist Ahmed Shihab-Eldin, an Emmy-nominated journalist and producer, says government requests to remove or restrict content can move decisions about censorship away from formal legal processes and into the relationship between governments and technology companies. 

“Once a government can ask a platform to take something down and get compliance without a court order or any real check on the request, censorship moves out of the legal system and into a backroom deal between an official and a company that has every incentive to say yes,” Shihab-Eldin says. 

The consequences become particularly significant during conflicts and other moments when access to information is critical. Shihab-Eldin points to coverage from Gaza, where he says footage and testimony have disappeared from platforms at a time when journalists were prevented from entering Israel. 

“Once that record is gone from people’s feeds, it’s effectively gone from public memory, even if a copy survives somewhere else,” he says. 

That distinction between journalism technically remaining online and journalism remaining accessible is increasingly important. 

“A website nobody visits aren’t reaching an audience. Most people encounter journalism because it showed up in their feed, not because they typed a URL into a browser,” Shihab-Eldin says. 

For journalists, visibility is therefore also about discovery which stories are encountered, which sources are found and which events enter public discussion. 

The consequences become particularly significant during conflicts and other moments when access to information is critical… where [Gaza] footage and testimony have disappeared from platforms at a time when journalists were prevented from entering Israel. Once that record is gone from people’s feeds, it’s effectively gone from public memory, even if a copy survives somewhere else. 

 

The effect of thousands of small restrictions 

The loss does not always come through one dramatic ban. “It happens through thousands of small actions an account restricted, a post taken down, live-streaming disabled quietly for a handful of accounts,” he says. 

Individually, each decision may appear limited. Collectively, however, such restrictions can change the information environment in which journalists and audiences operate. Stories can become harder to discover, sources harder to find and public discussions fragmented. 

A government may never need to formally shut down a news organisation if the channels through which its reporting reaches audiences are repeatedly restricted. This creates a different kind of censorship, one that can be difficult to see because no single action necessarily amounts to a complete information blackout. 

For journalists working in conflict zones, under authoritarian governments or in places where traditional media is already restricted, the consequences can be particularly serious. Social platforms may provide access to eyewitnesses, local reporters, activists and communities that are otherwise difficult to reach. 

When that material disappears, journalists can lose not only published reporting but also leads, sources and evidence that could inform future work. 

Individually, each decision may appear limited. Collectively, however, such restrictions can change the information environment in which journalists and audiences operate. Stories can become harder to discover, sources harder to find and public discussions fragmented. 

 

What disappears from the historical record? 

The problem is also not limited to what disappears today. It can affect what journalists are able to find tomorrow. 

In Kashmir, many politically sensitive articles published by local news organisations over the past 15–20 years have disappeared from their websites, making it harder for young journalists to research past events and build on earlier reporting. 

For journalists, such gaps can have consequences beyond historical memory. Earlier reporting can provide timelines, identify sources, document previous claims and help reporters understand how an issue has developed. When those records become inaccessible, journalists may have to reconstruct events without the reporting that originally documented them. 

This creates another dimension of the information blackout not only information that audiences cannot see in the present, but information that future journalists may be unable to find when they try to understand the past. 

Journalism is not only produced for the moment in which it is published. News reports can later become sources for investigations, historical research, accountability efforts and new reporting. 

When those records disappear, become inaccessible or are pushed out of the places where journalists normally search for information, the loss can extend across generations of reporters. 

Earlier reporting can provide timelines, identify sources, document previous claims and help reporters understand how an issue has developed. When those records become inaccessible, journalists may have to reconstruct events without the reporting that originally documented them. 

 

When visibility becomes a livelihood 

For independent and freelance journalists, the consequences can also extend from access to information to their livelihoods. Shihab-Eldin says restrictions can mean losing an audience built over years, along with assignments, speaking opportunities or subscriptions that depend on that reach. 

“For a lot of journalists, especially freelancers, the platform account isn’t just a distribution channel, it’s the income itself.” 

For journalists whose work depends on social media to reach audiences, losing access to an account or seeing reporting repeatedly removed can affect both their ability to publish and their ability to sustain their work. 

The dependence is particularly significant for freelancers and independent journalists who may not have the institutional distribution networks of large news organisations. A newsroom may have a website, newsletter, television broadcast or print edition to fall back on. An individual journalist may have built an audience almost entirely through a platform. When that channel disappears, the consequences can therefore extend from editorial reach to professional survival. 

 

A problem larger than any single country 

Shihab-Eldin sees developments in India, Meta’s handling of Palestinian and Arabic-language content, and similar cases elsewhere as part of a broader pattern. 

“The same pattern is emerging elsewhere, as governments test how far they can push platforms to remove content without attracting public scrutiny,” Shihab-Eldin says. 

That pattern matters for journalists globally because the power to determine what remains visible online is increasingly shared between governments and private technology companies. The implications are therefore larger than any single takedown, platform or country. 

Related Articles

A wall of silence - investigating ‘quacks’ in India

REPORTER'S NOTEBOOK: ‘Quacks’ - illegal, non-registered healers - are a subject worthy of scrutiny by the media in India. But what do you do when the communities they operate in don’t want you to talk about it?

Saurabh Sharma
Saurabh Sharma Published on:
‘Leading the voiceless’ - how low-caste Indian journalists are crowdfunding their own newsrooms

Dalit representation in Indian media organisations is very low. Some journalists from the lowest Hindu caste are finding innovative ways to start up their own news platforms

Saurabh Sharma
Saurabh Sharma Published on:
‘It takes courage to be a journalist in India’ - charting the collapse of press autonomy

THE LONG READ: With a rising number of journalists in India receiving ‘summons’ from the police and even finding themselves in prison just for doing their jobs, we ask - why has the profession come under so much pressure in recent years?

Abeer Khan Published on:
How misinformation in the media wreaked havoc on an Indian village

When journalists - and social media ‘influencers’ claiming to be journalists - aimed for sensationalism and did not check their facts about the outbreak of the HIV virus in an Indian village, the results were devastating

Saurabh Sharma
Saurabh Sharma Published on:

More Articles

How Has Social Media Affected Television in Yemen?

Social media has transformed television in Yemen from a one-way broadcast medium into a more interactive, audience-driven system in which viewers help shape, source and even produce the content they watch.

Mohammed Alragawi Published on:
Bangladesh: Crackdown on Reporting on Indigenous Communities

In newsrooms across Bangladesh, the word "Indigenous" has become too dangerous to put in print. Editors quietly strike it from the copy, wary that a single mention could invite the wrath of the state.

Marzia Hashmi Momo Published on:
Why should journalists be cautious with Israeli sources?

Journalists should treat Israeli sources with particular scrutiny because anonymous briefings, military censorship, strategic leaks and recycled analysis can blur the line between verified information, speculation and propaganda, with real consequences for audiences on the ground.

Ahmad Al-Agha
Ahmad Al-Agha Published on:
The economics of truth: How Lack of Funding is Compromising Quality Journalism in Africa

Reporting and newsgathering cost money; they require time, patience and experienced personnel. However, globally limited funding is leading to a generally compromised journalism output.

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on:
Who Decides the News? Inside India's Algorithm-Driven Newsrooms 

Editors once decided which stories mattered based on evidence, public interest and ethics. Today, recommendation algorithms and engagement metrics increasingly shape editorial decisions, prioritising what keeps audiences scrolling.

Seerat-Un-Nisa Published on:
Asif Hamidi: Journalism Must Not Hide Crimes Behind 'Balance'

Asef Hamidi, Managing Director of Al Jazeera Arabic Channel, says the Gaza coverage was a professional duty, not activism, and that true objectivity means reporting crimes clearly rather than hiding behind false “balance”.

Mohammed Ahddad
Ahdad Mohamed Published on:
How Journalists Report on Insurgency in Nigeria Without Access or Safety

Journalists covering Nigerian conflicts increasingly use remote reporting methods that rely on local fixers and open-source data, forcing a dependence on digital tools that limits direct physical context. Reporters share these difficult realities, exposing how safety risks change the way conflict is documented and asking how the media can keep news accurate when journalists cannot reach the ground.

Nigerian freelance Journalist John Chukwu
John Chukwu Published on:
Anthropomorphising AI in War: How Click-Bait Headlines Humanise Algorithms and Dehumanise Civilians

North American mainstream journalists covering US and Israel-led algorithmic warfare frequently use anthropomorphic language that humanises technologies like machine learning, forcing a reliance on tech-elite jargon that sanitises the immense human cost and removes accountability from the state actors and weapon developers.

Sarah Samuel-Ayyash
Sarah Samuel-Ayyash Published on:
Reporting on People Who Cannot Leave

The arrest of an Afghan female athlete after appearing in a Dutch documentary highlights the dangers of reporting under authoritarian rule. It underscores a growing dilemma in journalism regarding how to amplify the voices of vulnerable people without accidentally turning them into targets for the regime.

Sayed Jalal
Sayed Jalal Shajjan Published on:
The Vanishing Foreign Desk: What U.S. Media Cuts Mean for South Asia

Recent restructuring at Voice of America and The Washington Post marks a significant withdrawal from global journalism, particularly affecting coverage in South Asia. As these major institutions cut staff and close foreign bureaus, the loss of experienced expertise threatens the visibility of critical regional issues like human rights and climate change. This shift forces a move toward narrative independence for local media, yet leaves a dangerous gap in the global conversation that smaller newsrooms struggle to fill.

Sajid Raina
Tauseef Ahmad, Sajid Raina Published on:
Why Anonymous Sources Are Fading from Indian Journalism

A generation of reporters-built careers on confidential sources, many now write without them.

Kamran Yousuf
Kamran Yousuf Published on:
AI, Copyright Reform and the Fragile Reinvention of Indian Journalism

India’s proposed AI copyright framework risks turning independent journalism into a pooled data resource, undermining the subscription-based models that sustain it. At a moment of political and economic fragility, the struggle over AI licensing is ultimately a struggle over who controls, values, and profits from journalistic work.

Arsalan Bukhari, an independent journalist based in India
Arsalan Bukhari Published on:
How AI Can Clean Messy Data; and Where It Can't

Normalising inconsistent, messy, or incomplete data is tedious and time-consuming, but essential. AI can handle grunt work, but editorial decisions remain with the journalist.

KA
Konstantinos Antonopoulos Published on:
Why Editorial Planning is Key in Today's Relentless News Cycle

In the past, having a detailed editorial plan was something extra that only some newsrooms did, but today it is a necessary part of surviving the non-stop news cycle. As newsrooms move away from old paper deadlines and into a digital world run by social media and search engines, having a clear plan is what keeps a team organised instead of stressed.

Faras Ghani Published on:
Investigating the Assassination of My Own Father

As a journalist, reporting on the murder of my father meant answering questions about my own position as an objective observer.

Diana López Zuleta
Diana López Zuleta Published on:
Propaganda: Between Professional Conscience and Imposed Agendas

When media institutions first envisioned editorial charters and professional codes of conduct, their primary goal was to safeguard freedom of expression. However, experience has shown that these frameworks have often morphed into a "vast prison", one that strips journalists of their ability to confront authority in all its forms. In this way, Big Brother dons velvet gloves to seize what little space remains for the practice of true journalism.

فرح راضي الدرعاوي Farah Radi Al-Daraawi
Farah Radi Al-Daraawi Published on:
Narrative Without Debate: The Telegraph’s Comment Ban on Gaza Coverage

What does it mean for readers when their voices are deliberately cut off? This content analysis of The Telegraph, a UK-based conservative newspaper known for its pro-establishment stance and alignment with right-leaning narratives, shows it systematically disabled Instagram comments on Israel-Gaza posts, blocking dissent and shaping a one-sided, pro-Israel narrative.

Mohammed Ramees
Mohammed Ramees Published on:
Bild Newspaper: The Story of Israel’s Propaganda Machine Specializing in Anti-Palestinian Incitement

It labelled Al Jazeera journalist Anas Al-Sharif, killed by the occupation, a “terrorist”; denies famine in Gaza; trains its journalists in Israel to promote the Zionist narrative; published forged documents leaked from Netanyahu’s office; and belongs to a media group whose charter affirms “support for Israel’s right to exist”. This is Bild, Germany’s newspaper of incitement against Palestinians, cited by Israel’s president.

Al Jazeera Journalism Review
Al Jazeera Journalism Review Published on:
Mental Health in Newsrooms

Newsrooms, long lauded as bastions of information, are quietly grappling with a mental health crisis, underscoring an urgent need for systemic support, emotional safety, and sustainable practices to protect those telling the world’s stories.

Faras Ghani Published on:
The Continent Experience: A New Kind of Newspaper for the Future of Journalism

The Continent is a new way of empowering people through quality journalism, blending the authority of newspapers with the reach of 21st-century distribution. Readers love it. That’s why we built it. It’s a model other newsrooms can learn from and one that comes with its own set of challenges.

Sipho Kings
Sipho Kings Published on:
Anas Al-Sharif’s Killing and the Israeli Media Narrative

Following the assassination of journalist Anas Al-Sharif, Palestinian journalists have been framed in Israeli media as legitimate military targets—part of a deliberate strategy to silence those who bear witness to the truth. This article explores how Hebrew-language media outlets have engaged in rhetoric that incites and legitimises the killing of journalists in Gaza.

Anas Abu Arqoub
Anas Abu Arqoub Published on:
Canadian Journalists for Justice in Palestine: A Call to Name the Killer, Not Just the Crime

How many journalists have to be killed before we name the killer? What does press freedom mean if it excludes Palestinians? In its latest strike, Israel killed an entire Al Jazeera news crew in Gaza—part of a systematic campaign to silence the last witnesses to its crimes. Canadian Journalists for Justice in Palestine (CJJP) condemns this massacre and calls on the Canadian government to end its complicity, uphold international law, and demand full accountability. This is not collateral damage. This is the targeted erasure of truth.

Samira Mohyeddin
Samira Mohyeddin Published on:
Monitoring of Journalistic Malpractices in Gaza Coverage

On this page, the editorial team of the Al Jazeera Journalism Review will collect news published by media institutions about the current war on Gaza that involves disinformation, bias, or professional journalistic standards and its code of ethics.

A picture of the Al Jazeera Media Institute's logo, on a white background.
Al Jazeera Journalism Review Published on:
From "Death Announcement" to "Eulogy": The Obituary as a Journalistic Genre

Obituaries for influential public figures have become a recognised journalistic genre, handled by seasoned reporters in major media outlets. How did this practice evolve, what defines it professionally, and how ethically acceptable is writing obituaries in advance?

Mahfoud G. Fadili
Mahfoud G. Fadili Published on: