Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Massive crowds of demonstrators and supporters gather in Azadi Square, surrounding the iconic Shahyad Tower, to witness the historic return of Ayatollah Khomeini to Tehran. The event marks the end of Khomeini’s 15-year exile and signifies the definitive collapse of the Pahlavi monarchy, serving as a pivotal catalyst for the Islamic Revolution. This momentous assembly represents a sea change in Iran's political landscape, capturing the intense fervor and shifting power dynamics of the era.
Massive crowds of demonstrators and supporters gather in Azadi Square, surrounding the iconic Shahyad Tower, to witness the historic return of Ayatollah Khomeini to Tehran after a 15-year exile and the definitive collapse of the Pahlavi monarchy, serving as a pivotal catalyst for the Islamic Revolution. (Photo: Sharok Hatami. Tehran, Iran – Feb 1979)

The Revolution That Framed Islam: How 1979 Shaped Western Media on Iran

The 1979 Revolution transformed how the Western world views and reports on Islam. What started as a confused attempt to understand a new religious movement has turned into a permanent media habit of framing Iran through the lens of conflict and suspicion.

 

The Iranian Revolution of 1979 thrust Iran into the mainstream discourse of the West, the US particularly, and became a defining moment in how Western media began to frame political Islam and Iran

In the same year as the Revolution, the Siege of Mecca and its aftermath would divert Saudi Arabia away from western-style reforms towards ultra-conservatism and see the Soviet Union Invade Afghanistan. Yet it is the Iranian Revolution that would essentially shape the way in which the media reports on Islam and Iran to this day.

 

The Revolution Comes into Focus

As the soon-to-be Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khomeini sat reclined in his seat on an Air France flight chartered toward Iran it was the end of his over 15 year-long exile. The Shah of Iran had already fled the country a couple of weeks earlier, and Khomeini would go on to spearhead the government that would replace the unbroken two and half millennia chain of kings that presided over Iran. When ABC News Journalist Peter Jennings asked the Ayatollah how he felt returning to Iran after years in exile Khomeini simply replied in Persian, “Hichi” – “Nothing.”

To many in the European and the United States news media the unpierceable and stoic persona of the Shiite Cleric Khomeini was baffling, reflecting the presses and Western Worlds inability to gauge the future for Iran within this man.

President Carter had called Iran an “Island of Stability” a little over a year before Khomeini’s flight, now it was an unclear player in the region for the US, and the media often reflected this.

A report analysing The New York Times coverage between 1968 and 1978, the time of the Shah’s western reforms called the White Revolution, found that on average less than half an editorial a year was dedicated to Iran and Iranian affairs.

When protests began in Iran the NYT published on average 24 times as many editorials on Iran per year during this period than it had in the previous decade. Across much of the European and US media was a gravitational pull towards Khomeini, who at the time of the protests in Iran of 1978/79 was living in exile near Paris, a clear oppositional player to the Shah in the narrative of the Revolution.

There he could speak freely and have access to the press for which family, students and close advisors helped him prepare statements and manage journalists where he downplayed certain aspects of his Islamism when talking about what comes after the Shah. As former French Ambassador to Iran, François Nicoullaud, explained many decades after the event:

Intellectuals in France told him to come here. He wanted to go to a Muslim country, but [they] felt it better for him to be in a country where the international media could capture everything, he would say and get the proper media support and coverage.

To observers Khomeini’s long black robes and clericalism made him a striking, almost caricature, type figure. When Robert MacNiel, PBS, interviewed Khomeini on December 1st, 1978, he first describes him as a man of, “a spartan diet of prayer and little food.

Joan Shore, Junior Correspondent at the Paris Bureau of CBS News, said at the time that, “the French press covered Khomeini's arrival thoroughly and seriously. Finally, two months later, in December, America began to take notice of this bearded old man in France.”

Khomeini’s interaction with the press in Europe not only legitimised himself as the internationally recognised opposition of the Shah but cemented an orientalist image left over from the colonial period of the ‘cleric from the east’. Yet the confusion of what to make of the Islamic Revolution at a time before the US Hostage Crisis was still unclear.

For the NYT in February 1979, Richard Falk, then American Professor at Princeton University wrote an article saying,

“The news media have defamed him in many ways, associating him with efforts to turn the clock back 1,300 years, with virulent anti‐Semitism, and with a new political disorder, “theocratic fascism,” about to be set loose on the world. About the best he has fared has been to be called (by Newsweek) “Iran's Mystery Man.

 

The Hostage Crisis and the Hardening of the Narrative 

The US Hostage Crisis which saw 66 personnel of the US embassy in Tehran held captive by Iranian students was a turning point. No longer was there a ‘man of mystery’ in Khomeini as the narrative from the United States Media began to shift unequivocally against Iran.

Nov 13, 1979; Washington, DC, USA; People in the streets protest against the hostage-taking of 66 Americans in Tehran, Iran, in November 14th, 1979. The so-called 'Iran Hostage Crisis' lasted for 444 days and caused then U.S. President Carter to lose his re-election attempt, and punctued the first Fundamentalist Islamic Revolution of modern times.
Nov 13, 1979; Washington, DC, USA; People in the streets protest against the hostage-taking of 66 Americans in Tehran, Iran, in November 14th, 1979. The so-called 'Iran Hostage Crisis' lasted for 444 days and caused then U.S. President Carter to lose his re-election attempt, and punctued the first Fundamentalist Islamic Revolution of modern times.

 

The NYT coverage of Iran increased by 55 times as much during the 444-day captivity of the hostages compared to the ten years between 1968 and 1978. This is due to the obvious outrage of United States Citizens being held by a foreign power but also due to the sharp rise in gasoline prices globally due to the Revolution in Iran affecting oil shipments.

The Chicago Tribune in November 1979, the same month as the hostage crisis began, wrote “Intolerance grips revolutionary Iran.”, “The New Barbarians are loose in Iran," wrote Hal Gulliver in The Atlanta Constitution on November 13th. ABC News published that “the crescent of crisis, sweeping across the world of Islam like a cyclone hurtling across a prairie," on November 21.

In an article for the Columbia Journalism Review titled ‘Iran and the press: whose holy war?’ Edward Said wrote about the lack of fact checking and the demonisation of Iran during this period. He states The Atlanta Constitution on November 8 alleged that the Palestine Liberation Organization was behind the embassy takeover, sources stated as “diplomatic and European intelligence," with the Washington Post saying, "there is some basis to believe that the whole operation is being orchestrated by well-trained Marxists." He states many others in his article with similar false claims.

Although these allegations were untrue their purpose to associate the Iranian Revolutionaries with cold war rivals and terror groups was, Said wrote:

The hardest thing to understand about the news media is why, almost without exception, they regard the movement that overthrew the Pahlavi regime and brought in different, perhaps more popular groups, with such disdain and suspicion. A partial answer, no doubt, is that the movement employed a dramatically unfamiliar (to Western eyes) idiom of religious, as well as political, resistance to tyranny.

Said’s views come from another aspect of the Western Media also, in the form of the Islamic Revolution being an anti-imperialist movement that breaks the shackles of oppressive powers, invalidating the struggles a new government can place upon Iran also.

As a report by the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change outlines:

Just as in 1979 some Western observers thought Khomeini would liberate the Iranian people. Although there is a perception that such a view is confined to the far left, its proponents can be found across the political spectrum.

 

The Enduring Legacy of 1979

Before the current war between Israel, the United States and Iran, recent media narratives on Iran were focused on protests inside the regime, most notably the Green Revolution of 2009, the Women, Life, Freedom movement in 2022 and the protests at the end of 2025, beginning of 2026.

As Dr. Esmaeil Esfandiary and Dr. Shahab Esfandiary wrote in the book Reporting the Middle East, these protests also became the sole view of many of the West on Iran:

Stories of human rights violations have had a strategic value and function for Western governments in their decades-old battle of narratives with the Islamic Republic of Iran.

Depictions of Islam were also exacerbated following 9/11 and the War on Terror, resulting in Western Media to report on the ideals of the foreign policy of their governments, not necessarily on lived realities. Dr. Ayman Talal Yousef of the Arab-American University spoke of the post-cold war era of media on Islam in a publication about stereotypes of Islam within this period.

That Western media figures, academics, decision-makers and research centres are trying to deliver the idea that Islamic globalism based on extremism and terrorism has become the next threat, replacing Communism

The Western Media’s spontaneous fix on Iran reflects, like most mainstream news, the push and pull of geo-political, geographic and ideological circumstances that shape the world and its apparent spheres of ideological separation. Journalists too have their limits and can only repeat facts of current events, often without being able to give more than a sentence or two on the background of complex issues rooted in history, religion and ideology.

Francis Ghilès, Senior Fellow at the European Institute of the Mediterranean, spoke of the ‘journalist’ when reporting on the MENA Region, saying:

He does not have the time to be an expert in the academic sense. His essential qualification is to produce the right number of words, in television jargon the right “footage”, at the right time. His ability to say some things in an intelligible and entertaining fashion is another essential qualification.

Nearly half a century after Khomeini’s return and the disposure of the Shah, the media today now gives airtime to the son of the Shah as the Iranian diaspora in the West now shout, “Long Live the Shah” instead of “Death to the Shah”. Over 200,000 people came to see the son of the Shah when he spoke in Munich during the Security Conference in February 2026.

The language, imagery and assumptions that emerged in 1979 continue to shape how Iran is reported, suggesting that the revolution did not just transform a nation, but also the lens through which it is still understood.

 

 

Related Articles

Missiles Made of Words: How Western Media Narratives Shape the Iran–Israel–US Conflict

Western media coverage of the Iran–Israel–US conflict often functions as a weapon of war, using selective language that frames US and Israeli strikes as “self-defence” while depicting Iranian actions as "provocation". This linguistic framing normalises civilian casualties and helps manufacture public consent for military aggression by dehumanising certain populations.

Muqeet Mohammed Shah
Muqeet Mohammed Shah, Ifrah Khalil Kawa Published on: 14 Mar, 2026
Bias towards ideology at the expense of truth... Look for the reasons

Donald Trump’s election as US President in 2016 may have represented a key shift in the issue of ‘fake news’.

A picture of the author, Homam Yehya.
Homam Yehya Published on: 19 Jul, 2021
How can we confront Islamophobia in the media?

The events of September 11, 2001 exacerbated anti-Muslim sentiment in the Western media, but Islamophobia had been around for a long time beforehand.

Khawla Nakua
Khawla Nakua Published on: 12 Sep, 2021
Are Netanyahu's and Trump’s Speeches Shaping Western Media Framing?

As political speeches framed the 2026 U.S.–Israeli attack on Iran, segments of Western media echoed their language and narratives, illustrating how strategic rhetoric and news framing can shape public opinion and legitimise military action.

Shaimaa Al-Eisai
Shaimaa Al-Eisai Published on: 6 Mar, 2026
Foreign Funding and Orientalism: On the Need for an "Organic Journalist"

When many North African countries achieved their independence, nationalists began to repeat a sentence of great importance: Colonization will leave out the door, only to come back through the window. The sentence has proved to be prescient, as colonization has come back through the gateway of media, with an orientalist view that detaches reality from its cultural, and socio-political contexts.

Muhammad AlKhamaiseh Published on: 28 Feb, 2021
Orientalism, Imperialism and The Western Coverage of Palestine

Western mainstream media biases and defence of the Israeli narrative are connected to orientalism, racism, and imperialism, serving the interests of Western ruling political and economic elites. However, it is being challenged by global movements aiming to shed light on the realities of the conflict and express solidarity with the Palestinian population.

Joseph Daher
Joseph Daher Published on: 1 Apr, 2024

More Articles

The Challenge of Reporting in Chechnya

Independent journalism no longer exists as a functioning practice inside Chechnya. What remains is a profession rebuilt in exile, forced to operate at a distance from the very place it is meant to cover.

Rushda Fathima Khan
Rushda Fathima Khan Published on: 29 Mar, 2026
How AI Can Clean Messy Data; and Where It Can't

Normalising inconsistent, messy, or incomplete data is tedious and time-consuming, but essential. AI can handle grunt work, but editorial decisions remain with the journalist.

KA
Konstantinos Antonopoulos Published on: 21 Mar, 2026
Missiles Made of Words: How Western Media Narratives Shape the Iran–Israel–US Conflict

Western media coverage of the Iran–Israel–US conflict often functions as a weapon of war, using selective language that frames US and Israeli strikes as “self-defence” while depicting Iranian actions as "provocation". This linguistic framing normalises civilian casualties and helps manufacture public consent for military aggression by dehumanising certain populations.

Muqeet Mohammed Shah
Muqeet Mohammed Shah, Ifrah Khalil Kawa Published on: 14 Mar, 2026
How the Ethiopian Civil War Unleashed a Lethal Media Crackdown

There has been a widening crackdown on the media in Ethiopia since war erupted between the central government and Tigray’s regional authorities in 2020, and the pressure appears set to intensify as the country prepares for general elections in June.

Nalova Akua
Nalova Akua Published on: 9 Mar, 2026
Are Netanyahu's and Trump’s Speeches Shaping Western Media Framing?

As political speeches framed the 2026 U.S.–Israeli attack on Iran, segments of Western media echoed their language and narratives, illustrating how strategic rhetoric and news framing can shape public opinion and legitimise military action.

Shaimaa Al-Eisai
Shaimaa Al-Eisai Published on: 6 Mar, 2026
The Taboos of Journalism: A Fragility No One Dares to Expose

Does a journalist have the right to critique their own employer? It is a striking irony that they report on global crises while remaining silent about their own industry's fragility: stagnant wages, eroding professional values, and profit-driven ownership. Journalists must realize that confronting this internal rot is not just a right, but a necessity to save the profession from extinction.

Diana López Zuleta
Diana López Zuleta Published on: 24 Feb, 2026
Bilingual on Paper, Unbalanced on Air: English Journalism in a Francophone Cameroon

In a media landscape where French dominance dictates policy and airtime, English-speaking reporters in Cameroon are forced into a relentless cycle of improvisation, translation, and professional exhaustion. From the "desert-like" scarcity of English-speaking experts to newsrooms that offer no institutional support, this analysis explores how linguistic inequality hollows out the journalistic process, leaving vital stories untold and the promise of a bilingual nation unfulfilled.

Akem
Akem Nkwain Published on: 15 Feb, 2026
Reporting the Spectacle: Myanmar’s Manufactured Elections

Myanmar’s recent elections posed a profound challenge for journalists, who were forced to navigate between exposing a sham process and inadvertently legitimising it. With media repression intensifying, reporting became an act of resistance against the junta’s effort to control information and silence independent voices.

Annie Zaman
Annie Zaman Published on: 7 Feb, 2026
Public Hostility Toward Legacy Media in Bangladesh

The December 2025 arson attacks on Prothom Alo and The Daily Star marked a turning point for journalism in Bangladesh. As public anger replaces state control as the primary threat, reporters are reassessing personal safety, editorial judgement, and professional credibility in a political transition where journalism itself is increasingly treated as an enemy.

Arsalan Bukhari, an independent journalist based in India
Arsalan Bukhari Published on: 4 Feb, 2026
Migration Issues and the Framing Dilemma in Western Media

How does the Western press shape the migration narrative? Which journalistic frames dominate its coverage? And is reporting on anti-immigration protests neutral or ideologically charged? This analysis examines how segments of Western media echo far-right rhetoric, reinforcing xenophobic discourse through selective framing, language, and imagery.

Salma Saqr
Salma Saqr Published on: 31 Jan, 2026
Polarised, Intimidated, Silenced: The Media Under Siege in Cameroon’s Election

Cameroon’s 2025 presidential election exposed a troubling paradox: a nation voting under the watchful eye of power, while its press remained silenced. From the arrest of a teenage reporter to bans on political debate and digital manipulation, freedom of expression is under siege, and journalism is on trial.

Shuimo Trust Dohyee
Shuimo Trust Dohyee, Ngweh Rita Published on: 22 Jan, 2026
What Image of Gaza Will the World Remember?

Will the story of Gaza be reduced to official statements that categorise the Palestinian as a "threat"? Or to images of the victims that flood the digital space? And how can the media be transformed into a tool for reinforcing collective memory and the struggle over narratives?

Hassan Obeid
Hasan Obaid Published on: 13 Jan, 2026
Journalism in Mauritania: Behind the Facade of Press Freedom Indicators

Mauritania holds the top position in the Arab world in the Press Freedom Index published by Reporters Without Borders. However, behind this favourable ranking, the media and journalists face significant challenges, chief among them the ambiguity surrounding the definition of a "journalist" and the capacity of media professionals to fulfil their roles in accountability and oversight. Despite official efforts, the defining feature of Mauritania’s media landscape remains its persistent state of fluctuation.

 Ahmed Mohamed El-Moustapha
Ahmed Mohamed El-Moustapha Published on: 6 Jan, 2026
How Can Journalism Make the Climate Crisis a People’s Issue?

Between the import of Western concepts and terminology that often fail to reflect the Arab context, and the denial of the climate crisis, or the inability to communicate it in clear, accessible terms, journalism plays a vital role in informing the public and revealing how climate change directly affects the fabric of daily life in the Arab world.

Bana Salama
Bana Salama Published on: 19 Dec, 2025
Freelancers in Kashmir Fear Losing Access as Verification Tightens

Kashmir’s new “verification drive” claims to root out impostors, yet its heavy bureaucratic demands mainly sideline the independent freelancers who still dare to report in a shrinking media landscape. But here’s the unsettling question that hangs over the Valley like fog at dawn: who really benefits when the storytellers without institutional shields are pushed out of the frame?

Tauseef Ahmad
Tauseef Ahmad, Sajid Raina Published on: 11 Dec, 2025
Journalists in Maldives Enter New Phase of Government-Controlled Media Repression

As journalists weigh the costs of their work against threats to their lives and families, the fight for press freedom in the Maldives enters a dangerous new chapter, one where the stakes have never been higher.

Sumaiya Ali
Sumaiya Ali Published on: 8 Dec, 2025
Reporting Under Fire: The Struggle of African Journalists Facing Intimidation

African journalists who expose corruption and power now face a brutal mix of arrests, torture, digital surveillance, and lawsuits meant to drain their resources and silence them. From Ethiopia, Nigeria, Malawi, Benin, Sudan, Uganda, and Kenya to exile in Canada, reporting the truth has become an act of personal survival as much as public service.

Nigerian freelance Journalist John Chukwu
John Chukwu Published on: 4 Dec, 2025
Shipwrecked Narratives: How to Keep Migration Stories Afloat

Migration stories don’t become real until you meet people in the journey: the carpenter carrying photos of his fantasy coffins, or the Libyan city worker burying the forgotten dead, or the Tatar woman watching her livelihood collapse at a militarised border. Following these surprising human threads is the only way journalism can cut through collective exhaustion and make readers confront a crisis they’ve been trained to ignore.

Karlos Zurutuza, a freelance journalist and a media trainer. His work has been published in The Guardian, Al Jazeera English, POLITICO, The Middle East Eye and The Independent, among others.
Karlos Zurutuza Published on: 30 Nov, 2025
In-Depth and Longform Journalism in the AI Era: Revival or Obsolescence?

Can artificial intelligence tools help promote and expand the reach of longform journalism, still followed by a significant audience, or will they accelerate its decline? This article examines the leading AI tools reshaping the media landscape and explores the emerging opportunities they present for longform journalism, particularly in areas such as search and content discovery.

. سعيد ولفقير. كاتب وصحافي مغربي. ساهم واشتغل مع عددٍ من المنصات العربية منذ أواخر عام 2014.Said Oulfakir. Moroccan writer and journalist. He has contributed to and worked with a number of Arab media platforms since late 2014.
Said Oulfakir Published on: 24 Nov, 2025
Zapatismo and Citizen Journalism in Chiapas, Mexico

In Chiapas, independent journalists risk their lives to document resistance, preserve Indigenous memory, and challenge state and cartel violence. From Zapatista films to grassroots radio, media becomes a weapon for dignity, truth, and survival.

Ana Maria Monjardino
Ana Maria Monjardino Published on: 26 Oct, 2025
Lost in Translation: The Global South and the Flaws of Content Moderation

Global Rules, Local Consequences: How Biased Moderation Fuels Disinformation in the Global South. Unequal systems of AI and human oversight are failing to protect and often silencing non-Western voices online.

Lucia Bertoldini
Lucia Bertoldini Published on: 22 Oct, 2025
Propaganda: Between Professional Conscience and Imposed Agendas

When media institutions first envisioned editorial charters and professional codes of conduct, their primary goal was to safeguard freedom of expression. However, experience has shown that these frameworks have often morphed into a "vast prison", one that strips journalists of their ability to confront authority in all its forms. In this way, Big Brother dons velvet gloves to seize what little space remains for the practice of true journalism.

فرح راضي الدرعاوي Farah Radi Al-Daraawi
Farah Radi Al-Daraawi Published on: 17 Oct, 2025
Journalists Under Occupation; Palestinian Journalists in the West Bank

Palestinian journalists in the West Bank face extreme physical danger, psychological trauma, and systemic targeting under Israeli occupation, yet continue to report with resilience, amplifying the voices of their people despite global indifference and media bias.

Synne Furnes Bjerkestrand
Synne Bjerkestrand Published on: 13 Oct, 2025
Narrative Without Debate: The Telegraph’s Comment Ban on Gaza Coverage

What does it mean for readers when their voices are deliberately cut off? This content analysis of The Telegraph, a UK-based conservative newspaper known for its pro-establishment stance and alignment with right-leaning narratives, shows it systematically disabled Instagram comments on Israel-Gaza posts, blocking dissent and shaping a one-sided, pro-Israel narrative.

Mohammed Ramees
Mohammed Ramees Published on: 9 Oct, 2025