Al Jazeera Journalism Review

Fact-Checking and the Material Burden Imposed by Geography

Geographical inequalities in mapping, imagery and language resources make open-source verification significantly more difficult and costly in conflict zones such as Sudan, leaving important evidence vulnerable to delays and doubt. Addressing this imbalance requires sustained investment in local archives, proactive mapping, language technologies and editorial transparency.

 

Open-source verification tools are not geographically neutral. They depend on layers of imagery, maps and linguistic data that are readily available in some places and scarce in others. This disparity becomes most evident where armed conflict coincides with limited visual and linguistic coverage.

In the early days of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, something unusual happened in war reporting: verification sometimes preceded publication rather than following it.

As videos poured in from Lutsk, Kharkiv and the suburbs of Kyiv, a decentralised community of researchers was examining them in real time, exchanging footage, geolocating it and identifying models of armoured vehicles. ABC News described the phenomenon in revealing terms: an “army” of geolocation specialists was publicly posting coordinates, and their findings were largely accurate.

Since then, a particular perception has become firmly established in the professional imagination: open-source verification is a borderless tool available to any journalist with a computer and patience. This perception is accurate, but incomplete, as this article will demonstrate.

 

The Paradox of Two Countries’ Digital Environments

The central technique in modern visual verification — geolocation — relies on matching. It involves comparing landmarks visible in footage, such as buildings, lampposts, skylines and signs, with an independent source confirming that those features exist in that precise location. Matching always requires a second point of reference.

In Ukraine, that second point of reference was available in several forms: extensive street-level imagery, highly detailed open maps, a substantial visual archive accumulated before the war, and a large volunteer community. ABC highlighted another, often overlooked, human factor: Ukrainians who could recognise a landmark from their home city in a single frame.

Verification skills do not operate in a vacuum. They require material against which footage can be compared, a map that can be searched, an archive that can be consulted, and people familiar with the location. The question, therefore, is not so much whether a journalist knows how to verify something, but whether the reference material needed for verification existed in the first place.

In Sudan, videos have been emerging from Khartoum, Omdurman and Darfur since the outbreak of war in 2023. The editorial standards governing their publication are the same as those applied to Ukraine, but the cost of meeting those standards is different. This is not necessarily because Sudanese footage is less clear, but because the tools needed to obtain independent corroborating evidence are extremely limited.

Here, “cost” does not refer only to time. It encompasses the number of tools that must be tried, the number of alternative sources that must be consulted when the first source fails, the amount of local expertise that must be secured, and the degree of uncertainty that remains after all these efforts have been exhausted. In Sudan, all these costs rise simultaneously.

In Sudan, videos have been emerging from Khartoum, Omdurman and Darfur since the outbreak of war in 2023. The editorial standards governing their publication are the same as those applied to Ukraine, but the cost of meeting those standards is different. This is not necessarily because Sudanese footage is less clear, but because the tools needed to obtain independent corroborating evidence are extremely limited.

 

The Consequences of Absence: Imagery and Language

According to available data on Google Street View coverage, official coverage is available in Jordan, Lebanon, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Türkiye and Israel. Oman was added in October 2024.

In Iraq, coverage extends to no more than a handful of selected tourist sites. Sudan, Syria, Yemen and Libya, meanwhile, lack extensive official street-level coverage that can be relied upon in the same way.

This does not mean that verification is impossible in these countries. Street-level photography is not the only source available. There are satellite images, OpenStreetMap, crowdsourced photography projects such as Mapillary and KartaView, photojournalism archives, and scattered images uploaded by users.

However, the absence of an extensive, openly accessible visual layer means that one of the richest and most easily searchable sources becomes scarce. Investigators must compensate by turning to sources that are less detailed, updated less frequently, more expensive, or all three.

This compensatory approach is visible in published investigations. When BBC Verify examined footage documenting the resumption of civilian flights at Khartoum Airport, it explained that its method involved matching prominent landmarks visible in the footage against satellite imagery, followed by a reverse image search to establish that the footage had not previously been published.

The method was entirely sound. But consider what was unavailable to the team: it had to look down from above because street-level coverage was lacking.

And because BBC Verify is a specialist unit within a major media organisation, it has access to time, subscriptions and staff that a Sudanese newsroom operating under bombardment does not.

One of the most valuable elements of any investigation is also among the hardest to replace: the human element. The existence of a large volunteer community specialising in geolocation, alongside people who recognise their cities through the smallest details, is not simply an additional advantage. These people are themselves part of the infrastructure.

One of the most prominent such communities is GeoConfirmed, a volunteer collective specialising in geolocating footage recorded in conflict zones.

Here, “cost” does not refer only to time. It encompasses the number of tools that must be tried, the number of alternative sources that must be consulted when the first source fails, the amount of local expertise that must be secured, and the degree of uncertainty that remains after all these efforts have been exhausted.

 

The Second Gap Is Less Visible but More Consequential

Evidence is not confined to images. It also includes what is said in recordings, what is written on signs, and what witnesses publish. Each of these layers requires automated processing tools.

An important distinction is necessary here: Modern Standard Arabic is not a low-resource language. Numerous tools have been developed for it, and their results are reasonably reliable. The problem lies with dialects, particularly those that are less well represented.

An ACM survey covering a decade of research between 2014 and 2024 found that Gulf, Saudi, Sudanese and Emirati dialects appeared only sporadically compared with other varieties.

This disparity can be measured.

A study published in January 2026 established the first benchmark for automatic speech recognition in Sudanese Arabic. When models trained on Modern Standard Arabic were applied to the Sudanese dialect, they recorded word error rates ranging from 73.8% to 123%.

The second figure is not a typographical error. A word error rate exceeding 100% means that the system's output contains more errors than the number of words in the original speech.

Even the best-performing model, following specialised training, recorded a word error rate of 57.1%.

In other words, the best model in that benchmark made errors in more than half the words. This does not make transcription impossible, but it means that the resulting text requires extensive human review before it can be accepted as a reliable transcript.

The problem is further complicated by linguistic diglossia: official documents are written in Modern Standard Arabic, while witnesses write and speak in their local dialects. Many also write these dialects using Latin characters, a practice known as “Arabizi”.

The immediate practical consequence is that it becomes difficult to establish the likely location of a recording from the speaker's dialect. Searches for witness posts are also hindered because keywords in Modern Standard Arabic do not match the words actually used.

 

An Unequal Burden of Proof

At this point, the issue shifts from the technical to the professional.

On the surface, the editorial standard is the same: nothing should be published unless it has been verified.

Yet applying a single standard to two environments with vastly different resources produces different outcomes. The longer verification takes, the less likely the evidence is to reach the public while a story is at the height of its news value. Footage that takes days to verify may never be published once the news cycle has moved on.

More troubling still, the phrase “we have been unable to verify” does not reach audiences merely as a description of the limitations of available tools. Instead, it is understood as a judgement on the material itself.

In the audience's mind, inadequate infrastructure is transformed into doubt about the account.

This is not a deficiency in the competence of Arab journalists or their commitment to professional standards. It is a disparity in resources that exists before the journalistic work even begins.

In an article entitled “The Political and Digital Roots of the Invisibility of Sudan's War”, published in Al Jazeera Journalism Review, the author examines the marginalisation of the war in Sudan and attributes the silence surrounding it to three factors: algorithmic preferences, geopolitical marginalisation and the destruction of local media infrastructure.

These are real and convincing factors. But a fourth can be added, one that operates before all the others: cost.

Even when footage reaches journalists, and even when someone is willing to publish it, the cost of verifying it remains higher.

Silence, therefore, is not simply a question of attention. It is also a question of proof.

The Ukrainian experience demonstrates that having someone who can recognise their city from a small detail is not an additional advantage, but part of the infrastructure itself.

This particular human element has also been tested in Sudan. The Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team worked with organisers from Sudan to build a mapping community among Sudanese people in the diaspora and those outside the country.

The essential requirement, therefore, is not physical presence inside the country, but knowledge of the location, organisation and mutual trust.

 

What Can Be Built?

The purpose of this assessment is not to complain, but to identify shortcomings that can be addressed. This gap is neither natural nor permanent. It is the result of decisions concerning documentation and investment made years before the war.

Archiving: An Established Model, but Who Owns It?

Since 2019, Sudanese Archive, a programme of the Germany-based organisation Mnemonic, has been collecting and archiving material documenting violations in Sudan. Its collection has grown to more than half a million records, and it has submitted evidence files to official bodies for accountability purposes.

Similarly, since April 2023, Sudan Witness, a project run by the UK-based Centre for Information Resilience, has been monitoring, verifying and archiving incidents related to the conflict. It publishes open maps and databases documenting village fires and air strikes.

These two examples carry a dual significance.

First, the model is both feasible and proven. It is not merely a theoretical proposal.

Second, the infrastructure through which the events of this war will be documented and established is being built, funded and managed from outside the region.

This raises questions extending beyond which organisation collects the archive to who will own its knowledge infrastructure in the future: Where will it be located? Who will decide what remains in it? And who will control access to it?

What an Arab newsroom can begin doing is less ambitious but more realistic: archiving the material it publishes, recording publication dates, links and descriptions of locations wherever possible.

Verification does not require an official source. It requires an independent, pre-existing and retrievable source.

There is, however, a limitation: an archive without descriptive information cannot be used effectively. Its value lies in indexing, not merely in storage.

 

Proactive Mapping

Street-level photography is not the exclusive preserve of any single organisation. Crowdsourced photography projects such as Mapillary and KartaView make imagery available under open licences, with material that can be uploaded using ordinary mobile phones.

As for mapping data, Sudan itself illustrates the problem.

According to research published in Frontiers in Climate, cited by the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team (HOT), 83% of the buildings currently recorded in OpenStreetMap within Sudan were edited between August 2021 and August 2024 — a period spanning the outbreak of the war.

In other words, the map was drawn because the war happened.

By contrast, the idea behind Missing Maps, a collaborative initiative established by the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team and humanitarian organisations, is to map areas vulnerable to crises before those crises occur, rather than afterwards.

The role available to Arab newsrooms and universities is specific and inexpensive: photograph routes through their cities and upload the imagery, while also contributing data about those cities to open maps before they become front lines.

The limitations are clear. This approach cannot cover areas that are already inaccessible, nor does it help someone seeking to verify footage recorded today.

It is an investment in verification that may take place years later — and that is precisely why it is constantly postponed.

 

The Human Element

The Ukrainian experience demonstrates that having someone who can recognise their city from a small detail is not an additional advantage, but part of the infrastructure itself.

This particular human element has also been tested in Sudan. The Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team worked with organisers from Sudan to build a mapping community among Sudanese people in the diaspora and those outside the country.

The essential requirement, therefore, is not physical presence inside the country, but knowledge of the location, organisation and mutual trust.

However, the model cannot simply be transferred unchanged.

Publicly sharing coordinates during an ongoing conflict can carry serious risks for people on the ground. What is appropriate for a volunteer community working remotely may not be appropriate for someone filming from their window.

Organisation and safety in the field must therefore take priority.

Language: Computing Power Is Not the Obstacle

The benchmark for Sudanese Arabic was developed using free and experimental computing resources.

This helps redefine the obstacle: the problem is not computing capacity, but the availability of annotated audio data.

Newsrooms possess something that research laboratories often lack: hours of speech in authentic local dialects, preserved in archives of interviews and field reports.

Making some of this material available to researchers, even in limited samples, could bring about a qualitative improvement in automatic speech-recognition tools.

This must, however, take into account the need for legal consent and guarantees of safety for the people whose voices appear in the recordings.

 

Editorial Transparency

This requires neither substantial funding nor years of preparation. It requires an editorial decision.

Instead of simply stating, “We have been unable to verify”, newsrooms could publish the steps they have completed, explain what could not be established, and clarify why.

Was an attempt at matching made but unsuccessful? Or was there no reference material available against which the footage could be matched in the first place?

Such a decision would shift attention towards the limitations of the tools rather than casting doubt on the credibility of the event itself.

 

Who Should Bear the Cost?

A Sudanese newsroom operating under fire cannot reasonably be expected to build an archive of cities being bombarded or collect linguistic data while struggling to publish the news.

The responsibility falls instead on better-equipped regional institutions and Arab universities operating at a safe distance from the war.

This capacity is not hypothetical.

On 31 August 2025, when reports emerged of a landslide in the village of Tersin in Darfur, claiming that the entire village population had been killed, an Al Jazeera report investigated the incident using the same methods described here.

Despite the scale of the reported disaster, witness-generated content was unavailable.

Investigators therefore turned to satellite imagery, which showed that the village covered an area of no more than approximately 2.7 square kilometres and contained relatively few houses.

This evidence challenged the widely circulated death toll, while subsequent findings confirmed that the landslide itself had occurred.

What is missing, therefore, is not proof that such verification is possible, but sustained foundational investment in archives, maps and language resources.

It is often said that open-source verification has given journalism tools it did not previously possess. That is true.

But the question worth asking is not about the tools themselves. It is about the ground on which they stand.

When verification tools are built on data from one part of the world but not another, what is implicitly determined is not merely the level of accuracy, but the distribution of doubt.

Which accounts are accepted quickly? And which will remain unresolved?

The question facing Arab newsrooms is not, “Were they capable of verifying the evidence?”

They have already demonstrated that they are, even with fewer resources.

Rather, the question is:

“How much evidence will remain in the ‘unconfirmed’ category before Arab newsrooms and universities build the foundations on which their verification work depends?”

 

This article was originally published in Arabic on 08/11/2026

 

Related Articles

How to Bring more Balance to Western Media Coverage of Israel and Palestine

How can journalists accurately cover Palestine without becoming unbalanced or biased? Here are some concrete tools and techniques for reporters to keep in mind.

A picture of the author, Megan O'Toole
Megan O'Toole Published on:
Sudan shows us why Africans must tell their own conflict stories

Africa lacks freedom of expression because its stories are told by others

Philip Obaji Jr
Philip Obaji Jr Published on:
Monitoring of Journalistic Malpractices in Gaza Coverage

On this page, the editorial team of the Al Jazeera Journalism Review will collect news published by media institutions about the current war on Gaza that involves disinformation, bias, or professional journalistic standards and its code of ethics.

A picture of the Al Jazeera Media Institute's logo, on a white background.
Al Jazeera Journalism Review Published on:
Ethics and safety in OSINT - can you believe what you see?

OSINT is increasingly important for journalists in a digital world. We take a look at ethics, safety on the internet and how to spot a ‘deepfake’

Sara
Sara Creta Published on:
Using Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT) in Journalism

Where once journalists relied on sources for information - also known as ‘human intelligence’ (HUMINT) - they now increasingly rely on ‘open-source’ intelligence (OSINT) gathered from the internet, satellite imagery, corporate databases and much, much more

Phil
Phil Rees Published on:
Verifying Information Is Not Just a Technical Process

From Context Manipulation to AI-Driven Digital Campaigns, Fact-Checkers Strive to Adapt to New Strategies and Methods of Fake and Misleading News Aimed at Constructing “Alternative Narratives.” On International Fact-Checking Day, colleague Hassan Khodary presents the experience of Sanad, Al Jazeera’s fact-checking agency, with a particular focus on its work in tracking the falsehoods within the Israeli narrative surrounding the genocide against Palestine.

hassan khodary
Hassan Khodary Published on:

More Articles

When Journalism Disappears: How Social Media Takedowns Are Reshaping What the World Can See

Governments do not need to shut down a newsroom to silence its reporting: repeated social media takedowns can sever its access to audiences, deprive journalists of sources and evidence, and leave gaps in the historical record.

Mehran Firdous Published on:
The Victims' Digital Resorrection…Reviving legacy or Commodifying Pain?

As artificial intelligence brings the dead back to life on screen, the article examines the troubling line between preserving victims’ memories and exploiting their suffering for digital engagement, raising urgent questions about consent, journalistic integrity, and accountability.

Khulod Hadaq Published on:
How to Protect Sources when Police Seize a Journalist’s Phone?

The increasing seizure of journalists' digital devices by authorities using advanced forensic tools and spyware poses a severe threat to source confidentiality and press freedom, forcing reporters to rely on strict digital hygiene and minimized data storage to mitigate risk.

Arsalan Bukhari, an independent journalist based in India
Arsalan Bukhari Published on:
Gaza’s Images in the World’s Memory

Among the thousands of images that have documented the genocide in Gaza, from famine and the demolition of residential towers to the faces of victims, some have appeared

Amira Nassar
Amira Nassar Published on:
News In the Race for Attention

As audiences turn to Reels, social media and AI for news, journalists are adapting to new demands while trying to protect the depth and quality of their reporting

Rehan Qayoom Mir. An independent journalist whose work has appeared in international and national outlets,
Rehan Qayoom Mir, Sajad Hameed Published on:
How Has Social Media Affected Television in Yemen?

Social media has transformed television in Yemen from a one-way broadcast medium into a more interactive, audience-driven system in which viewers help shape, source and even produce the content they watch.

Mohammed Alragawi Published on:
Why should journalists be cautious with Israeli sources?

Journalists should treat Israeli sources with particular scrutiny because anonymous briefings, military censorship, strategic leaks and recycled analysis can blur the line between verified information, speculation and propaganda, with real consequences for audiences on the ground.

Ahmad Al-Agha
Ahmad Al-Agha Published on:
Priorities for Media Recovery in Gaza

Rebuilding Gaza’s media requires more than restoring equipment and newsrooms: it means protecting and supporting journalists, rebuilding institutions, strengthening professional standards, and preserving journalism’s role as a living witness to the truth.

Sufian al-Shorbagy Published on:
Common Mistakes Made by Television Correspondents

Television correspondents earn trust not by being first or omniscient, but by reporting what they can verify, using images responsibly, resisting performance and speculation, and putting accuracy before speed.

Linda Shalash
Linda Shalash Published on:
Will We Write A Falsified History In The Future?

The digital transition of journalism has exposed a growing archive reliability gap, where online news documents are often subject to fake news, content manipulation, and a lack of verification mechanisms, challenging their role as official historical records.

Said El Hajji
Said El Hajji Published on:
Editorial Workflow in Television Journalism: From Oversight to Quality

Quality television journalism relies on cohesive teamwork rather than individual multitasking. A functional hierarchy is key, restoring the "gatekeeper" role by verifying facts and shielding the public from fake news and propaganda, especially in complex, high-tension environments.

Ali Najeeb Published on:
Nepal’s Deadly Floods Expose a Newsroom Safety Gap

Nepal’s deadly floods exposed a wider South Asian newsroom safety gap, where many journalists are often sent into dangerous assignments without formal risk assessments, adequate training, protective equipment, evacuation plans or mental-health support.

Hanan Zaffa
Hanan Zaffar Published on:
The migrant issue in Libya: did the media pass the test of professionalism?

Libya’s migration debate has become a test of whether the media can report legitimate public concerns without laundering rumours, fuelling hate, or turning vulnerable migrants into scapegoats.

Imad al-Madouli Published on:
The economics of truth: How Lack of Funding is Compromising Quality Journalism in Africa

Reporting and newsgathering cost money; they require time, patience and experienced personnel. However, globally limited funding is leading to a generally compromised journalism output.

Derick Matsengarwodzi
Derick Matsengarwodzi Published on:
We survived… and stayed alive!

A Palestinian journalist and mother recounts surviving Gaza’s genocide, where the press vest became a target, motherhood became terror, and staying alive did not feel like salvation.

Yumna al-Sayyid Published on:
A Continuing Crisis, an Intermittent Story: What Makes Famine Newsworthy?

An analysis of 180 articles from the BBC, The Guardian, The New York Times and CNN found that coverage of hunger in Gaza frequently linked the crisis to political decisions and identified responsibility rather than treating it only as a humanitarian emergency. Tracking the same outlets through early August 2026 also shows that this coverage came in sharp waves, with periods of intense reporting separated by months of limited attention even as severe food insecurity persisted.

Djamil Kerrouche Published on:
Who Decides the News? Inside India's Algorithm-Driven Newsrooms 

Editors once decided which stories mattered based on evidence, public interest and ethics. Today, recommendation algorithms and engagement metrics increasingly shape editorial decisions, prioritising what keeps audiences scrolling.

Seerat-Un-Nisa Published on:
As in Rwanda: Can the Israeli Press Be Prosecuted for Participation in Genocide?

Israeli media incitement has helped frame Palestinian journalists as security threats, weakening their legal and professional protection and legitimising attacks against them. Legal accountability is possible through the ICC, universal jurisdiction, and professional pressure against journalists and outlets that incite violence.

Nasser Adnan Thabet Published on:
A Soldier with the Rank of Correspondent in the Israeli Army

Israeli military journalism developed through a deep fusion of media, censorship, and the army, turning correspondents into carriers of the official security narrative. This embedded model later influenced Western war reporting, where access to the battlefield often came at the cost of independence and critical distance.

Sujood Awais Published on:
The Phenomenon of “News Avoidance”: Have We Come to Know More Than We Should?

Audiences are increasingly avoiding the news as the constant flow of crises, violence, and tragic human stories creates psychological exhaustion and anxiety. Media outlets need to respond with more responsible editorial choices, stronger media literacy, and coverage that balances urgent events with constructive, humane, and less harmful storytelling.

Wessam Kamal Published on:
From Srulik to Handala: Caricature as a Media Symbol

From the pro-occupation Israeli character 'Srulik' to the resilient and satirical Palestinian 'Handala', caricature emerges as another battleground for memory and the future. How did these characters come to be, what is their media symbolism, and why does caricature remain so influential?

Sujood Awais Published on:
“Sometimes You Work for Years Without Pay” – Cameroonian Journalists Demand Safety Nets

While many journalists demonstrate admirable resilience in producing quality journalism under precarious conditions, resilience should not be the only safety net. Journalism deserves protection, because democracy depends on it.

Akem
Akem Nkwain Published on:
When Modi’s Managed Media Met Europe’s Press

A brief, viral exchange in Oslo between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and a Norwegian journalist has exposed the widening gap between India's tightly controlled media environment and traditional adversarial press culture. Over the past decade, open, unscripted scrutiny has increasingly been replaced by carefully managed public relations, image-driven interviews, and direct digital reach. This systemic shift has reshaped the broader landscape of Indian news media, creating a culture of forced deference that prioritises political showmanship over holding power accountable.

Arsalan Bukhari, an independent journalist based in India
Arsalan Bukhari, Mehrunnisa Maryam Published on:
How Sources Shaped the Story of Gaza’s Aid-Site Killings

In conflict reporting, the question is rarely only about what happened. It is also who gets to explain what happened. The findings here suggest that the answer to that question often shapes the story that audiences ultimately receive.

Djamil Kerrouche Published on: